The has issued a significant directive requiring the food delivery platform Zomato, operated by Eternal Limited, to take down 132 restaurant listings that allegedly infringe upon the of Kakas Hospitality. This order, passed by Justice Tejas Karia, marks a stern judicial response to the unauthorized use of the "Kake-Da" brand identity, which has become central to a contentious legal battle over restaurant naming rights and consumer protection in the digital delivery space. The court’s intervention follows the plaintiff's complaint that various entities were using the "Kake-Da" name to confuse consumers and siphon off business, specifically noting that some operators had attempted to circumvent existing judicial restrictions by relisting under slightly modified names.
The current legal proceedings stem from an ongoing suit where Kakas Hospitality seeks to protect its established brand, which has served Indian and Mughlai cuisine for several years. In , the court had already granted an , restraining several defendants from offering services under a range of marks including "KAKE DAA HOTEL," "KAKA KA HOTEL," and "KAKE KA DHABA." Despite these restrictions, the plaintiff reported that certain defendants, specifically identified as Defendant Nos. 3 and 6, had resumed their operations on the same online platform using different URLs while maintaining the identical physical addresses. This trend of "re-listing" prompted the plaintiff to seek further relief, arguing that the persistent presence of these during the high-volume festive season caused substantial financial loss and reputational damage.
Addressing Evasive Online Tactics
The court observed that the plaintiff had established a
case for the removal of the new listings. In its order, the bench noted,
"the plaintiff has made out a case for taking down the new listings as well as the fresh listings of Defendant Nos. 3 and 6, which have been made available to circumvent the
."
The court expressed concern regarding the technical ease with which infringing operators can shift from one URL to another, effectively rendering initial injunctions ineffective unless the platform takes proactive measures to block such activities. The identified listings included a wide variety of names such as "Kake Da Dhaba," "Kake Da Chicken," and "Kake Da Punjabi Dhaba," all of which were found to be using the essential features of the plaintiff’s protected trademark without any authorization.
A critical challenge highlighted by the plaintiff was the anonymity of these operators, many of whom run their businesses as "cloud kitchens." These virtual storefronts often operate without clear identification, making it extremely difficult for the plaintiff to serve legal notices or track the actual individuals responsible for the infringement. The plaintiff submitted that out of the newly identified listings, approximately 81 are cloud-based, and it remains unclear whether the physical addresses displayed on the platform correspond to actual, legitimate business locations. This lack of transparency has hindered the progress of the lawsuit, as the plaintiff has been unable to complete service upon several defendants due to inaccurate or insufficient address information provided in the listing details.
Platform Accountability and Transparency
Recognizing the gravity of these procedural hurdles, the court directed Zomato to go beyond merely removing the infringing URLs. It mandated that the platform disclose comprehensive data regarding the operators of the disputed listings within two weeks. This directive requires the disclosure of names, contact numbers, email addresses, postal addresses, licence numbers, GSTIN, PAN, and bank account details linked to these specific listings. The court specified that this information must be provided in a password-protected format or a sealed envelope to ensure both data security and the effective implementation of further legal service. This measure is intended to facilitate via alternative means such as WhatsApp and electronic mail, ensuring that defendants can no longer evade the of the court by hiding behind vague digital profiles.
The court's decision underscores the increasing responsibility placed on online platforms to maintain the integrity of their marketplaces. While Zomato’s counsel expressed a commitment to comply with the order, they requested a two-week window for implementation, citing the upcoming holiday period. The court granted this request, allowing the platform until the next phase of the process to finalize the takedown and the data handover. This timeframe is seen as a balanced approach, allowing for operational compliance without compromising the urgent needs of the plaintiff to halt the confusion in the marketplace.
The ongoing litigation has cast a spotlight on the complexities of enforcement in the age of app-based food delivery, where the barrier to entry for new sellers is minimal and the potential for is significant. By linking the removal of listings to the disclosure of actual business particulars, the court has provided a pathway for the plaintiff to pursue the individual infringers rather than merely playing "whack-a-mole" with URLs.
As the matter moves forward, the court has scheduled the next hearing for . The existing interim orders, which prevent the specified defendants from using the disputed marks, will remain in effect until the next date of hearing. The outcome of this case could serve as a vital precedent for how rights are managed on large-scale delivery platforms, reinforcing that digital convenience does not grant immunity from established trademark laws or the duty to prevent the infringement of registered brand identities. The plaintiff remains focused on securing , while the court continues to monitor the platform’s compliance with its directives to restore the sanctity of the "Kake-Da" brand.
intellectual property - online restaurant listings