The High Court of Delhi has upheld the life imprisonment sentence of Ajay Kumar Tomar, a former police officer convicted in the double murder of a businessman and a civilian during a 2011 robbery. A division bench comprising Justice Navin Chawla and Justice Ravinder Dudeja dismissed the appeals filed by both the convict and the prosecution, rejecting the state’s demand for the death penalty.

The case originated from a violent incident on September 24, 2011, near the Railway Hospital on SPM Marg in Delhi. The prosecution established that Tomar, while off-duty but in police uniform, stopped an Alto car occupied by businessman Amarjeet Singh Chadha. During the confrontation, Tomar snatched gold chains and lockets from the deceased before firing three fatal shots. As he fled the scene toward Pul Mithai, he was pursued by a police team assisted by a civilian, Harender Singh, also known as Sunny, who was driving his own motorcycle. During the chase, Tomar fired a shot that struck Sunny in the neck, leading to his death two days later.

The court's decision followed a rigorous examination of the evidentiary record, which included ocular testimonies, medical reports, ballistic analysis, and fingerprint evidence. The judges observed that the prosecution’s case was bolstered by the contemporaneous discovery of the stolen items and the weapons used in the crime. Forensic reports linked the firearms recovered from Tomar to the crime scenes, while fingerprint experts identified his prints inside the victim’s car.

Despite the heinous nature of the crimes, the court determined that the case did not meet the " rarest of rare " threshold required for capital punishment . The judgment highlighted the dual nature of the aggravating circumstances , noting that while Tomar had betrayed his position of public trust, the law provides for a nuanced balancing act in sentencing. The bench observed, "The commission of two murders, though a grave aggravating circumstance, cannot mechanically lead to the conclusion that the death penalty must follow."

The court noted that the convict’s position as a police officer entrusted with protecting citizens made his actions particularly reprehensible. However, the bench emphasized that a breach of public trust, while a significant aggravating factor, does not independently justify the death penalty under current legal standards. The judges underscored the principle that " Life imprisonment is the rule and death sentence is an exception."

Throughout the proceedings, the defense had challenged the reliability of the eyewitnesses, claiming they were "planted" by the authorities. The High Court rejected these arguments, finding the testimony of key witnesses consistent and credible. The bench concluded that the discrepancies identified by the defense pertained to collateral details rather than the core facts of the crime. The presence of the victim’s blood on the clothing of an eyewitness and the immediate reporting of the crime by police officers on patrol provided a robust, unified evidentiary chain.

The medical evidence further solidified the prosecution's position. Post-mortem reports for both victims confirmed that the firearm injuries were the direct and sufficient cause of death. The court observed that the appellant’s decision to use a lethal weapon against his pursuers during his escape showed a clear intent to inflict fatal harm, satisfyng the legal requirements for murder under Section 300 of the Indian Penal Code.

The bench explicitly addressed the necessity of reformation in sentencing. While the crimes resulted in the loss of two lives, the court noted that the record did not reveal "such exceptional brutality, extraordinary depravity or circumstances of such nature" as to conclude that the appellant was beyond the possibility of rehabilitation. Consequently, the High Court declined to enhance the sentence to death, affirming that the life sentence imposed by the trial court was sufficient to meet the ends of justice.

The dismissal of the appeals filed by the State and the son of the deceased ensures that the original sentence stands. Tomar remains convicted under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code for the murders of both Amarjeet Singh Chadha and Sunny, as well as under the Arms Act for the use and possession of illegal firearms. The judgment concludes the appellate process, leaving the original sentence of life imprisonment, along with the imposed fines, in full effect. The authorities have been directed to ensure the implementation of the sentence, concluding a legal battle that has spanned fifteen years.