SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Judicial Analysis Court Copy Headnote Facts Arguments Court observation
Listen Audio Icon Pause Audio Icon
judgment-img

1996 Supreme(SC) 343

1996(2) SUPREME 567
SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
S.C. Agrawal and G.T. Nanavati, JJ.
Thirumuruga Kirupananda Variyar Thavathiru Sundara Swamigal Medical Educational & Charitable Trust -Appellant
versus
State of Tamil Nadu & Ors. -Respondents
Civil Appeal Nos. 3214-15 of 1996
(Arising out of SLP (C) Nos. 9632-33 of 1993)
Decided on 12-2-1996

IMPORTANT POINT
For establishment of new medical college, policy power now rests with Central Govt. subject to grant of essentiality certificate by State Govt. Since State Govt. wrongly refused it, the Central Govt. can consider grant of permission to the Trust-Appellant for establishing a new Medical College in Salem without insisting upon said essentiality certificate by State Govt.

Headnote:Tamil Nadu Medical University Act,1987(now re-named as Dr. MGR Medical University Act)-Section 5(5)-Medical University Act empowering Tamil Nadu Medical University to affiliate Medical Colleges-Trust appellant desirous or establishing a Medical College at Salem-Refusal of application on ground that a no objection certificate should be obtained from State Govt.-Writ dismissed-Writ appeal dismissed-Central Ordinance 13 of 1992 replaced by (Central) Medical Council (Amendment) Act, 1993 amending Indian Medical Council Act, 1956-State Govt. refused to grant permission twice-Stand of State that permission cannot be given to a private trust to establish the Medical College-Scope and ambit of Legislative power of Parliament and State Legislative on Medical education-Whether there is repugnancy between the proviso to Section 5(5) of the Medical University Act inserted by State Act and Section 10A introduced in the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956 by the Central Act? (Yes) (Para 30)-Effect-For establishment of new Medical Colleges Cental Regulations 1993 will apply-Regulations needing essentiality certificate by State Govt.-Refusal of same-Whether correct? (No) (Para 34)-Whether State Govt. should again be directed to reconsider ? (No) (Para 35)-Result appeal allowed (Constitution of India-Article 136 and Article 254 r/w 7th Schedule, List I, Entries 63 to 66 and List III, Entry 25 Education).

       Held : The appeals are, therefore, allowed, the impugned judgment of the High Court is set aside and the Central Government is directed to consider the application submitted by the Trust for grant of permission to establish a new medical college in accordance with the provisions of Section 10A of the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956 without insisting upon the Trust to comply with condition regarding obtaining essentiality certificate from the State Government. The Central Government shall consider and pass an order in this regard within a period of one month. In the event of permission being granted by the Central Government for the establishment of the medical college by the Trust the Medical University shall consider the application of the Trust for affiliation of the said medical college to the Medical University without insisting upon the requirement of obtaining prior permission of the State Government for establishing the medical college. The appeals are disposed of accordingly. No orders as to costs. (Para 37)

JUDGMENT

S.C. Agrawal, J.-Special leave granted.

2. These appeals by Thirumuruga Kirupananda Variyar Thavathiru Sundara Swamigal Medical Educational and Charitable Trust (hereinafter referred to as the Trust ) relate to the establishment of a Medical College at Salem in the State of Tamil Nadu. The Trust has been formed for establishing various educational institutions and for other charitable purposes. It has established a Pharmacy College, a Dental College, a Homoeopathy College, an Engineering College, a Polytechnic, an Industrial Training Institute, etc. in the town of Salem. It is desirous of establishing a medical college at Salem.

2. In 1987, the Tamil Nadu State Assembly enacted the Tamil Nadu Medical University Act, 1987 (Act No.37 of 1987) which is now re-named as Dr. M.G.R. Medical University Act (hereinafter referred to as the Medical University Act ) whereby Tamil Nadu Medical University, re-named as Dr. M.G.R. Medical University, (hereinafter referred to as the University ) was established. Sub-section (5) of Section 5 of the Medical University Act empowers the University to affiliate colleges to the University as affiliated colleges, within the University area under conditions prescribed and withdraw such affiliation. On December 2, 1987, the Trust submitted an application to the University seeking affiliation to the University a medical college which the Trust wanted to start. The University, however, refused to entertain the said application of the Trust on the ground that a no objection certificate should be obtained from the Government of Tamil Nadu (hereinafter referred to as the State Government ) for starting a medical college and without such a no objection certificate the application could not be considered. The Trust filed a Writ Petition (W.P. No. 2776 of 1989) in the Madras High Court against the said order of the University refusing to entertain the application of the Trust for affiliation of the proposed medical college to the University. On the said Writ Petition, a learned single Judge (K. Venkataswamy J., as the learned Judge then was) passed an order, on April 13, 1989, with the consent of the parties, wherein it was recorded that the University would not insist on the prior permission of the Government and that the Trust would apply for affiliation in the prescribed form and the University would consider the same on merits without insisting upon prior permission of the State Government and pass orders in accordance with law. Thereafter, the Trust submitted an application for affiliation of the medical college on October 30, 1989. The said application was rejected by the University by order dated December 18, 1989 on the ground that the application ought to have been received on or before October 31, 1989 and it was received on November 7, 1989. The Trust filed another Writ Petition (W.P. No. 10453 of 1990) in the Madras High Court against the said order of the University dated December 18, 1989. The said Writ Petition of the Trust was allowed by a learned single Judge of the High Court (Somasundram, J.) by order dated February 1, 1991 and the order dated December 18, 1989 was set aside on the ground that application for affiliation has been sent by post on October 30, 1989 and the requirement of statute 37 with regard to the period of limitation for submitting the application was complied with. The University was directed to re-consider the said application of the Trust on merits. In the meanwhile, the Tamil Nadu State Legislature had enacted Dr. M.G.R. Medical University Tamil Nadu (Amendment and validation) Act, 1989 [XXXII of 1990] (hereinafter referred to as the State Act ) on July 6,1990. By the said Act, which was brought into force with effect from September 24, 1987, a proviso was inserted in sub-section (5) of Section 5 of the Medical University Act whereby it was prescribed that "no college shall be affiliated to the University unless the permission of the Government to es







































































































Click Here to Read the rest of this document
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
logo-black

An indispensable Tool for Legal Professionals, Endorsed by Various High Court and Judicial Officers

Please visit our Training & Support
Center or Contact Us for assistance

qr

Scan Me!

India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!

For Daily Legal Updates, Join us on :

whatsapp-icon Back to top