SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

1997 Supreme(SC) 427

1997(3) Supreme 320
SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
K. Ramaswamy and G.T. Nanavati, JJ.
State of M.P. & Anr. -Appellants
versus
Brijesh Kumar Awasthi & Ors. -Respondents
Civil Appeal No. 1977 of 1997
(Arising out of SLP (C) No. 2924 of 1997)
Decided on 10-3-1997
Counsel for the Parties :
For the Appellants : B.S. Banthia and S.K. Agnihotri, Advocates.
For the Respondents : S.S. Tiwari, Advocate.

Important Points

The Court held that when a decree is challenged on grounds of fraud and collusion, particularly where the official who entered the compromise lacked authority, an interim injunction should be granted to prevent the execution of the allegedly fraudulent decree pending the final disposal of the suit.

Subject

Civil Law - Injunctions

Act Referred

Headnote

Civil Procedure Code, 1908-Order XXIX Rule 1 & 2-Suit for declaration to set aside decree on ground to collusion and fraud played upon the Government-Suit property was acquired and award was passed under Indian Forest Act-Award became final-State came in possession of property-Award came to be set aside on compromise by third respondent though having no authority from the State Government-Pending suit, appellants were entitled to injunction restraining respondents from executing the decree-Trial Court and High Court committed manifest error of law in not granting injunction. (Paras 3 & 4)

       

Legal Category Hierarchy

  • practice and procedure
    • civil procedure
      • interim injunctions (Para 2, 3, 4, 5)
      • execution of decrees (Para 2)
  • administrative law
    • government authority and sanction (Para 2, 3)
  • property law
    • land acquisition (Para 2)
    • forest act (Para 2, 3)

Table of Contents

1. Land acquisition under Section 16, Indian Forest Act — Compromise decree obtained without government sanction — Suit to set aside decree on grounds of fraud and collusion. (Para 2 )

2. State's contention that the compromise decree was obtained through fraud and collusion without government sanction, necessitating an interim injunction to prevent execution. (Para 2 , 3 )

3. A valid award under the Forest Act set aside via unauthorized compromise, where the State remains in possession, warrants an injunction against executing a fraudulent decree. (Para 3 )

4. Where a decree is allegedly obtained through fraud and collusion without authority, an interim injunction is maintainable to prevent execution pending final adjudication of the suit. (Para 3 , 4 )

5. Appeal allowed — Orders of High Court and Civil Courts set aside — Interim injunction granted pending suit — Trial court directed to dispose of suit expeditiously. (Para 5 )

6. When is an interim injunction appropriate in cases involving a compromise decree?

An interim injunction is appropriate when a decree is allegedly obtained through fraud and collusion without government sanction, especially where the State is in possession and is agitating its rights to prevent the execution of such a fraudulent decree. (Para 3 , 4 )

7. What is the legal position regarding a compromise decree entered into by a government official without state sanction?

Such a decree can be challenged on the grounds of fraud and collusion. If the State is agitating its rights, it is entitled to an injunction restraining the execution of the fraudulent decree pending the suit. (Para 2 , 3 )

ORDER

Delay condoned.

Leave granted.

We have heard learned counsel for the parties.

2. This special leave petition arises from the judgment of the High Court of Madhya Pradesh, Jabalpur Bench, made on April 11, 1996 in M.A. No. 414/96. Respondent No. 2, Shivshankar Shukla was the owner of the land from Khasra No. 336, Peesajhodi, Tehsil in District Betul. The said property was acquired and an award came to be made under Section 16 of the Indian Forest Act by the Forest Superintending Officer. In lieu of compensation, the land to an extent of 4.50 acres of Khasra No. 282/1 and 292 was given to them. That award became final. After taking over possession thereof, the standing timbers (bamboos) were removed. The respondents filed Civil Suit No. 4A of 1988 for a declaration of title to the land in Khasra No. 336 and for compensation of Rs. 39,000/-. After filing the written statement contesting the suit, Narendra Kumar, the Conservator of Forest, the third respondent colluded with the respondents 1 and 2 without any sanction of the State Government and appears to have suffered a compromise decree in that suit. The additional District Judge, Betul, accordingly, passed a decree on May 8, 1992 setting aside the award. After one and a half years, the respondents filed an execution application upon which the appellants came to know of the decree for the first time. Consequently, they filed an application under Section 47, CPC, objecting to the execution on the ground of fraud. The application was dismissed. The writ petition filed by the appellants was dismissed by the High Court with liberty to agitate their right in an appropriate suit. Consequently, the suit was filed for declaration and to set aside the decree on the ground of collusion and fraud played upon the Government. Along with the suit, an application under Order XXXIX, Rule 1 and 2, CPC came to be filed. The application for injunction was dismissed and the appeal has also been dismissed by the High Court. Thus, this appeal by special leave.

3. From the above narration of the facts, it is seen that there was a valid award passed under the provisions of the Forest Act and the award came to be set aside on a compromise by third respondent though having no authority from the State Government. It is the admitted position that when the first suit was filed by them, the State was in possession of the property. On that premise, they sought damages against the State. Under these circumstances, when the State is agitating the right on the ground of fraud and collusion, it is obvious that, pending suit, the appellants were entitled to an injunction restraining the respondents from getting the fraudulent decree passed against the State, executed.

4. Under these circumstances, the trial Court as well as the High Court has committed manifest error of law in not granting the injunction.

5. The appeal is accordingly allowed. The order of the High Court and also of the Civil Courts stand set aside. There should be an interim injunction pending suit. The trial court is directed to dispose of the suit expeditiously. No costs.

Appeal allowed.

********

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top