SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

1996 Supreme(SC) 1572

1997(6) Supreme 379
SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
K. Ramaswamy and G.B.Pattanaik, JJ.
Subdivisional Inspector (Postal) & Ors. -Appellants
versus
K.K. Pavithran -Respondents
Civil Appeal No. 13115-16 of 1996
(arising out of SLP (C) No. 14451-52 of 1996)
Decided on 30-9-1996
Counsels for the Parties :
For the Appellants : A.S. Nambiar, Sr. Advocate and T.C.Sharma, C.V.S. Rao, Advocates.
For the Respondent : K.M.K. Nair, Advocate.

Important Points

IMPORTANT POINT
When order of dismissal for misconduct of temporary absence from duty was converted into one of reinstatement with lesser punishment, employee could not be held entitled to back-wages.

Subject

Employment Law - Disciplinary Action

Act Referred

SERVICE LAW: .

Headnote

Service Law-Respondent in service as Extra Departmental Agent, removed from service for misconduct of temporary absence from duty -Order of dismissal was converted into one of reinstatement with lesser punishment-Tribunal was not right in directing payment of back wages.

       Held : This Court in Rajasthan State Road Transport Corporation v. Bhagyo Mal & Ors. (1994 Supp. (1) SCC 573) held that while the High Court had found that the respondent-employee deserved punishment on account of his misconduct, and awarded lesser punishment, it is not liable to grant back-wages particularly when the Tribunal had converted the order of dismissal into stoppage of two increments with cumulative effect. Therefore, the order of the High Court was set aside to that effect. It is now settled law that imposition of punishment is in the discretion of the disciplinary authority. But the authority is expected to exercise the discretion properly taking into consideration all the relevant facts and circumstances. In this case, the punishment of removal was found to be not justified for the reason that the respondent was temporarily absent from duty. But the order of dismissal having been converted into one of reinstatement with lesser punishment, the question arises whether the respondent is entitled to back-wages? The Tribunal was not right in directing payment of back-wages for the reason that the respondent was found to be responsible for misconduct though lesser punishment was imposed. Under these circumstances and following the above judgment, we hold that the respondent is not entitled to back-wages. (Para 3)

       

Legal Category Hierarchy

  • administrative law
    • service law
      • disciplinary proceedings
        • quantum of punishment (Para 3)
        • back-wages (Para 3)

Table of Contents

1. Misconduct proceedings for temporary absence from duty under P & T Extra Departmental Agents (Conduct and Services) Rules, 1964 — Removal from service — Reinstatement — Dispute over back-wages. (Para 2 )

2. Whether an employee reinstated after a reduction in punishment for established misconduct is entitled to the payment of back-wages. (Para 2 )

3. Disciplinary authorities exercise discretion in punishment; where misconduct is established but punishment is reduced to allow reinstatement, back-wages are not automatically granted. (Para 3 )

4. An employee found responsible for misconduct is not entitled to back-wages even if the original punishment of removal is reduced to a lesser penalty. (Para 3 )

5. Appeals allowed; direction for payment of back-wages set aside. (Para 3 )

6. Is an employee entitled to back-wages if the punishment for established misconduct is reduced?

No. If the employee is found responsible for misconduct, they are not entitled to back-wages even if the original punishment of removal is reduced to a lesser penalty allowing for reinstatement. (Para 3 )

7. How should the disciplinary authority exercise its discretion regarding the imposition of punishment?

The imposition of punishment is at the discretion of the disciplinary authority, which is expected to exercise that discretion properly by taking into consideration all relevant facts and circumstances. (Para 3 )

ORDER

Delay condoned.

Leave granted

Heard learned counsel on both sides.

2. The respondent while in service as Extra-Departmental Agent was charge-sheeted, for misconduct of temporary absence from duty, under Rule 8 of the P & T Extra Departmental Agents (Conduct and Services) Rules, 1964 on June 6, 1985. By order dated March 31, 1986, the enquiry was cancelled and fresh enquiry was conducted. Later, on conclusion of the departmental enquiry proceedings, by order dated July 9, 1990, the respondent was removed from service. He filed an application in the Tribunal. By order dated May 28, 1992, the Tribunal remitted the matter for reconsideration on the nature of punishment. That order was unsuccessfully challenged in this Court and had become final. Subsequently, when the order of removal was passed again, it was challenged in the Tribunal. The Tribunal by order dated September 4, 1993 quashed the proceedings and directed reconsideration of the quantum of punishment on the basis of amended rules. Again, it was challenged in the special leave petition before this Court which was dismissed. Consequently, the respondent was reinstated. He again filed an application. In the impugned order dated December 5, 1995 made in O.A. No. 787/94, the Tribunal has directed payment of back-wages. Thus, these appeals by special leave.

3. This Court in Rajasthan State Road Transport Corporation v. Bhagyo Mal & Ors.1 held that while the High Court had found that the respondent-employee deserved punishment on account of his misconduct, and awarded lesser punishment, it is not liable to grant back-wages particularly when the Tribunal had converted the order of dismissal into stoppage of two increments with cumulative effect. Therefore, the order of the High Court was set aside to that effect. It is now settled law that imposition of punishment is in the discretion of the disciplinary authority. But the authority is expected to exercise the discretion properly taking into consideration all the relevant facts and circumstances. In this case, the punishment of removal was found to be not justified for the reason that the respondent was temporarily absent from duty. But the order of dismissal having been converted into one of reinstatement with lesser punishment, the question arises whether the respondent is entitled to back-wages? The Tribunal was not right in directing payment of back-wages for the reason that the respondent was found to be responsible for misconduct though lesser punishment was imposed. Under these circumstances and following the above judgment, we hold that the respondent is not entitled to back-wages.

The appeals are accordingly allowed. No costs.

Appeal allowed.

********

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top