D.A. DESAI, J.

(1) RESPONDENTS 1,2 and 3 in Civil 357/77 filed writ petition 5462/74 challenging the selection by U. P. public service commission (Commission for short) and subsequent appointment by U. P. State government of appellant and respondent 6 to the post of Professor in Medicine in State (Govermnent Medical Colleges. A learned single judge of tne High court quashed the selections. Four appeals came to be preferred against the judgment quashing selections. Special Appeal 232/75 was filed by Dr. R. N. Tandon, respondent 6; Special Appeal 233 of 1975 was preferred by the present appellant Dr. M. C. Gupta; Special Appeal 264 of 1975 was preferred by the State of U. P.; and Special Appeal 256 of 1975 was filed by respondents 1, 2 and 3 in Civil Appeal 35//77 against that part of the judgment of the learned single judge by which appointment of appellant Dr. M. C. Gupta and respondent 6, Dr. R. N. Tandon, was not quashed.

(2) THE appellate bench partly allowed the appeals and while con- firming the order quashing the selection of Dr. M. C. Gopta and Dr. R, N. Tandon, also quashed their appointment and remitted the matter to the Commission directing it to re-examine