1. Transfer petition — Restitution of conjugal rights — Wife's financial hardship and safety concerns. (Para 1 , 2 )
Back
Next 
2000 Supreme(SC) 118
SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
S.P.Bharucha : S.S.M.Quadri
Deepa
Versus
Anil Panicker
Case No. : 871 of 1999
Date of Decision : 1/17/00
In matrimonial transfer petitions, the court may transfer proceedings to the wife's place of residence if she demonstrates financial hardship and safety concerns, especially when such claims are not contested by the husband.
Headnote:(A) Transfer Petition - Matrimonial Suit - Restitution of conjugal rights - Transfer of proceedings - Convenience of the wife - Financial hardship and safety concerns - Where the wife is unemployed, has no source of income, and her parents are not financially in a position to pay for her journeys to defend the suit, and where she cannot safely undertake a long journey or stay alone in the city where the suit is pending, it is appropriate to transfer the proceedings to the court where the wife resides. (Para 2)
Facts of the case:
A petition for the transfer of a suit for restitution of conjugal rights was filed by the wife. The wife averred that she is unemployed, has no source of income, and her parents are not financially capable of funding her travel to the city where the suit was pending. Furthermore, she stated that she cannot safely undertake a long train journey alone or stay alone in the city where the suit was filed.
Findings of Court:
The court observed that the respondent husband had been served but chose not to appear. The averments made by the wife regarding her financial constraints and safety concerns remained undenied.
Issues: Whether the matrimonial suit should be transferred to the court where the wife resides based on her financial inability to travel and safety concerns.
Ratio Decidendi: In matrimonial proceedings, the court may allow the transfer of a case to the place of residence of the wife if she demonstrates a lack of financial means to travel and raises valid safety concerns, particularly when such claims are not contested by the opposing party.
Result: Transfer petition allowed.
Legal Category Hierarchy
Table of Contents
2. Wife's inability to travel and stay due to lack of income, financial constraints of parents, and safety concerns. (Para 2 )
3. Averments regarding the wife's financial inability to travel and safety concerns were not denied by the respondent. (Para 2 )
4. Matrimonial proceedings may be transferred when the wife demonstrates financial hardship and safety concerns preventing her from defending the suit. (Para 2 )
5. Transfer petition allowed — Matrimonial suit transferred to the competent court in the wife's place of residence — No order as to costs. (Para 2 , 3 )
6. Under what circumstances can a matrimonial suit be transferred to a different court?
A matrimonial suit may be transferred when the wife demonstrates that she is unemployed, lacks financial means for travel, and has safety concerns regarding traveling or staying alone in the city where the suit is pending. (Para 2 )
(1) THE respondent husband has been served but he has not chosen to put in an appearance.
(2) THE transfer petition is filed by the wife. It seeks the transfer of the petition for restitution of conjugal rights filed by the husband in the Court of the Judicial Commissioner, Ranchi to a competent court in Trichur. The wife stays in Trichur. She avers that she is not employed and has no source of income. Her parents are not financially in a position to pay for her journeys to Ranchi to defend the suit. Apart from this, she cannot safely undertake a train journey of forty-eight hours or so alone or stay in Ranchi alone. These averments are not denied. It appears to us, therefore, appropriate to allow the transfer petition and transfer Matrimonial Suit No. 60 of 1999 pending in the Court of the Judicial Commissioner, Ranchi to the Matrimonial Court, Trichur.
(3) NO order as to costs.
