1. Writ petition — NRI/foreign quota in private engineering colleges — Request for 5% quota and permission to fill vacant seats with non-NRI candidates. (Para 1 )
Back
Next 
1998 Supreme(SC) 892
SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
A.S.Anand : D.P.Wadhwa
A.P.Private Engineering College Management Association
Versus
Government Of A.P.
Case No. : 163 of 1998
Date of Decision : 8/28/98
Important Points
Private engineering colleges are permitted a 5% NRI quota, and any unfilled seats within this quota may be filled by the management at its discretion, provided the admissions adhere to the merit, qualification, and fee structure prescribed by the government.
Subject
Education Law - Admissions and Quotas
Headnote
(A) Education Law - Admission to Private Engineering Colleges - NRI Quota - Permission to fill 5% NRI quota and unfilled seats with non-NRI candidates - Management's discretion to fill vacant seats subject to merit, qualification, and government-prescribed fee structure. (Para 4)
Facts of the case:
An association of private engineering colleges sought a directive for a 5% NRI/foreign quota and the liberty to admit other students if those seats remained vacant. The state government had previously issued orders permitting such admissions based on prior court directions, subject to final orders in pending cases.
Findings of Court:
The court directed the state to allow the 5% NRI quota to be filled as previously directed and permitted the management of private engineering colleges to fill unfilled NRI seats at their discretion, provided they follow the criteria of merit, qualification, and fee structure prescribed by the government for current and successive academic years.
Issues: Whether the management of private engineering colleges should be allowed to fill the 5% NRI quota and utilize vacant seats for non-NRI candidates.
Ratio Decidendi: The court held that the 5% NRI quota should be maintained and vacant seats may be filled by the management at its discretion, provided that the admissions are governed by the merit, qualification, and fee structure prescribed by the government.
Result: Writ petition allowed.
Facts of the case:
An association of private engineering colleges sought a directive for a 5% NRI/foreign quota and the liberty to admit other students if those seats remained vacant. The state government had previously issued orders permitting such admissions based on prior court directions, subject to final orders in pending cases.
Findings of Court:
The court directed the state to allow the 5% NRI quota to be filled as previously directed and permitted the management of private engineering colleges to fill unfilled NRI seats at their discretion, provided they follow the criteria of merit, qualification, and fee structure prescribed by the government for current and successive academic years.
Issues: Whether the management of private engineering colleges should be allowed to fill the 5% NRI quota and utilize vacant seats for non-NRI candidates.
Ratio Decidendi: The court held that the 5% NRI quota should be maintained and vacant seats may be filled by the management at its discretion, provided that the admissions are governed by the merit, qualification, and fee structure prescribed by the government.
Result: Writ petition allowed.
Legal Category Hierarchy
Table of Contents
2. Petitioners seek 5% NRI quota and liberty to fill vacancies — State contends existing orders and government guidelines already permit such admissions subject to prescribed criteria. (Para 1 , 2 )
3. Court noted previous directions allowing 5% NRI quota and the government's establishment of criteria and fee structures for filling unfilled seats with non-NRI candidates. (Para 2 , 3 )
4. Private engineering colleges may fill the 5% NRI quota and remaining vacancies at their discretion, subject to government-prescribed merit, qualification, and fee criteria. (Para 4 )
5. Writ petition allowed — State directed to permit 5% NRI quota and discretionary filling of unfilled seats subject to government criteria for current and successive years. (Para 4 , 5 )
6. Can private engineering colleges fill vacant NRI quota seats with non-NRI candidates?
Yes, the court permitted the management of private engineering colleges to fill unfilled NRI quota seats at their own discretion, provided they follow the merit, qualification, and fee structure prescribed by the government. (Para 4 )
7. What are the conditions for filling the unfilled NRI quota in private engineering colleges?
The filling of unfilled NRI quota seats is subject to the criteria of merit, qualification, and the fee structure as prescribed by the government. (Para 4 )
8. For what period does the direction to allow the 5% NRI quota apply?
The direction applies to the current academic year as well as successive academic years until the main matter in the pending cases is decided by the court. (Para 4 )
(1) IN this writ petition filed by the Association of Private Engineering Colleges in Andhra Pradesh, the following prayers have been made:
"(a) direct grant of NRI/foreign quota for private engineering colleges in the State of A.P. at 5% with the liberty to admit others within this quota in case NRI/foreign students are not available and the seats are vacant, until the judgment of this Honble Court in Unnikrishnan case is reviewed; (b) issue a writ of mandamus to the respondent as in prayer (a): and (c) pass such further or other order or orders as this Honble Court may deem fit on the facts and circumstances of the case."
(2) UPON notice being issued, counter has been filed by Shri A.K. Goyal, Secretary to Government, Education Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad. In the counter-affidavit, it is stated that the orders made in Unnikrishnan case were modified by this Court on 14-5-1993 when it was clarified that it shall be open to the management of the private colleges to admit the NRI students to the extent of 5% of the total intake on a fee structure for the NRIs to be fixed by a committee. Subsequently, on 9-8-1996, another order came to be made by this Court, which confirmed the directions earlier issued on 14-5-1993 and also provided that in the event the seats reserved for NRI candidates in 5% quota are not filled up, the non-NRI candidates could be admitted against that quota. The State Government, subsequently, issued orders vide GOMs No. 428 dated 24-12-1997, permitting the management to fill up 5% seats under the NRI quota and also to take non-NRI students in case that quota was not filled up by the NRI students. These directions were, however, made subject to the final orders to be made by this Court in the pending cases.
(3) DIRECTIONS have been issued by this Court on year-to-year basis regarding the 5% seats of NRI quota. The Government has also provided the criteria for admission of the non-NRIs against the unfilled 5% seats of the NRIs and the fee structure regarding these seats.
(4) AFTER hearing learned counsel for the parties, we direct that the State of Andhra Pradesh shall allow the 5% NRI quota in the private engineering colleges in the State of Andhra Pradesh to be filled up in the manner earlier directed by this Court and to permit the management of the private engineering colleges to fill up the unfilled NRI quota, at its own discretion, subject, however, to the criteria of merit, qualification and fee structure as prescribed by the Government not only for the current academic year but also for successive academic years, till the main matter is decided by this Court in the pending cases.
(5) THE writ petition is allowed in the above terms. No costs.
