SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2000 Supreme(SC) 1345

SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
A.P.Misra : N.Santosh Hegde
National Textile Corporation (Maharashtra South) Limited
Versus
Standard Chartered Bank
Case No. : 12050 of 2000
Date of Decision : 8/16/00

Important Points

Writ jurisdiction under Article 226 is not the appropriate forum for resolving factual disputes, such as allegations of fraud or determination of possession area, when alternative remedies like a civil suit or Order 21 Rule 97 of the CPC are available.

Subject

Civil Law - Writ Jurisdiction

Act Referred

Headnote

(A) Constitution of India - Article 226 - Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 - Order 21, Rule 97 - Challenge to Consent Terms - Writ jurisdiction - Factual disputes regarding possession and fraud - Not the proper forum - Remedy available through civil suit or Order 21, Rule 97 of CPC. (Para 3)

(B) Writ Petition - Scope - Questions of fact, such as the extent of area in possession or allegations of fraud, cannot be adjudicated in writ proceedings - Proper course of action is to seek relief through a civil suit or specific provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure. (Para 3)

Facts of the case:
A tenant of a portion of office premises challenged a Consent Term entered into between the landlord and another tenant. The tenant alleged that the Consent Term erroneously included the area in their possession and that fraud was committed by the other parties. The tenant approached the court via a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, claiming that they had been dispossessed and had no other remedy.

Findings of Court:
The court held that the writ petition was misconceived as the issues raised—specifically the allegation of fraud and the determination of the area in possession—are fundamentally questions of fact. Such disputes cannot be resolved in writ proceedings.

Issues: Whether a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India is the appropriate remedy to challenge a Consent Term based on factual disputes regarding possession and fraud.

Ratio Decidendi: Writ jurisdiction is not the proper forum for resolving disputes that are essentially questions of fact. Where a party is aggrieved by a Consent Term or claims dispossession, the appropriate legal remedy is to move under Order 21, Rule 97 of the Code of Civil Procedure or to file a civil suit.

Result: Special leave petition fails, it is accordingly dismissed.

Legal Category Hierarchy

  • constitutional law
    • writ jurisdiction
      • article 226 (Para 3)
  • practice and procedure
    • civil procedure
      • execution of decrees
        • order 21 rule 97 (Para 3)

Table of Contents

1. Dispute over the area of premises recorded in a Consent Term between a landlord and tenant, affecting a third-party tenant's possession. (Para 2 )

2. Petitioner contends the Consent Term is non-binding and fraudulent; respondents dispute the claim of actual dispossession. (Para 3 )

3. Writ proceedings under Article 226 are inappropriate for resolving factual disputes regarding fraud and the extent of area in possession. (Para 3 )

4. Factual disputes concerning possession and fraud should be addressed through a civil suit or Order 21 Rule 97 of the Civil Procedure Code. (Para 3 )

5. Special leave petition dismissed; writ petition held misconceived, without prejudice to the petitioner's right to seek alternative legal remedies. (Para 4 , 5 )

6. Can a writ petition under Article 226 be used to resolve disputes over factual possession and fraud?

No, the court held that questions of fraud and the extent of area in possession are basically questions of fact, making a writ petition a misconceived and improper forum. (Para 3 )

7. What is the proper legal remedy for a party disputing the area of possession in a consent term?

The proper course of action is to move under Order 21 Rule 97 of the Civil Procedure Code or to seek relief through a civil suit. (Para 3 )

(1) HEARD learned Counsel for the parties.

(2) THE petitioner is a subsidiary of National Textile Corporation and respondent no.1 is the landlord of the suit premises. Respondent no.2 is the tenant of respondent no. 1 in respect of suit office premises and petitioner is the sole tenant in respect of part of the suit office premises. That during the pendency of the suit, respondent no.2 entered into a Consent Term with respondent no. 1 on 6th September, 1999 and under which he agreed to hand over to respondent no.1, 7800 square feet area of the suit office premises. In the Consent Term it is recorded that the area in occupation of the petitioner is only 3617 square feet out of the total area of 11, 417 square feet. This part of the Consent Term is the subject matter of the challenge in this petition.

(3) THE submission on behalf of the petitioner is that the said Consent Term was inter se between respondent no. 1 and respondent no. 2 and the petitioner was not a party to the said Consent Term and hence, the same is not binding. However, it seems the petitioner chose the wrong forum to challenge this, through writ petition under Articles 226 of the Constitution of India, which in our considered opinion, was misconceived and not proper forum. The submission on behalf of the petitioner is that in fact, fraud is committed as against the petitioner by both respondent no. 1 and respondent no. 2 by including the area in possession of petitioner, without bringing petitioner a party to the said Consent Term. The question of fraud and to what extent the area covered by Consent Term includes the area in possession of petitioner cannot be gone into writ proceedings. This is basically a question of facts. The proper course open to the petitioner was to have moved under Order 21, Rule 97 of the Civil Procedure Code. However, in view of the fact that he is actually dispossessed from the area, the submission is, this remedy is not available, as was left with no other remedy, he filed the writ petition. The submission of the respondent is that they are not actually dispossessed, but it is again a matter of dispute, which cannot be gone into in the present proceedings. In view of the facts of this case the remedy to the petitioner is to seek relief through a suit.

(4) ACCORDINGLY, we hold that proceeding taken through writ petition is misconceived. However, this is without prejudice to the rights of the petitioner to take such proceedings as advised in accordance with law. It is also made clear that any observation made by the courts below, will be without prejudice to the proceeding, if taken by the petitioner.

(5) WITH the aforesaid observations, the special leave petition fails, it is accordingly dismissed.

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top