1. Insurance policy renewal — Dispute over whether an accident occurred during the operative period of the policy given a specific commencement time. (Para 1 , 2 )
Back
Next 
1996 Supreme(SC) 1941
SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
G.T.Nanavati : K.Ramaswamy : K.Venkataswami
National Insurance Company
Versus
Jikubhai Nathuji Dabhi
Case No. : .
Date of Decision : 11/20/96
Advocates Appeared: Dara Gunwant : Gaur P. : Raichura H.A. : Sharma Jitendra : Vij Meenakshi
Specific contractual terms regarding the commencement time of an insurance policy override the general statutory presumption under the General Clauses Act, 1897, that a contract becomes operative from midnight.
Headnote:(A) Insurance Law - General Clauses Act, 1897 - Operation of insurance policy - Renewal of policy - Specific time of commencement - Where an insurance policy specifically states that the cover is reinstated and renewed from a particular time on a given date, the policy becomes operative only from that specific time - General rule that a contract is operative from midnight in the absence of a specific time mentioned does not apply when a special contract specifies a different time - Accident occurring prior to the specified time of commencement falls outside the insurance coverage. (Paras 2 and 3)
Facts of the case:
An insurance policy was suspended due to the renewal premium being paid after the renewal date. The policy was subsequently reinstated and renewed for a period of twelve months, with the contract specifically coming into force at 4:00 p.m. on a certain date. An accident occurred at 11:14 a.m. on the same date the policy was renewed.
Findings of Court:
The accident occurred before the renewal of the contract had taken effect, as the policy became operative only from 4:00 p.m. on the date of renewal.
Issues: Whether the accident occurred during the operation of the insurance policy in controversy.
Ratio Decidendi: While the General Clauses Act, 1897 suggests a contract is operative from midnight in the absence of a specific time, a special contract specifying a particular time of commencement overrides this general provision. Since the accident occurred before the specified time of 4:00 p.m., the insurance coverage was not applicable.
Result: Appeal allowed.
Legal Category Hierarchy
Table of Contents
2. Whether the insurance coverage was operative at the time of the accident despite the specific commencement time stipulated in the renewal agreement. (Para 1 , 2 )
3. The specific time of 4:00 p.m. stipulated in the insurance policy overrides the general midnight rule provided under the General Clauses Act, 1897. (Para 3 )
4. Specific contractual terms regarding the commencement time of insurance coverage prevail over the general presumption of midnight operation under the General Clauses Act, 1897. (Para 3 )
5. Appeal allowed; insurance company not liable as the accident occurred before the policy became operative. (Para 4 )
6. When does an insurance contract become operative if no specific time is mentioned?
In the absence of a specific time mentioned in the contract, the contract becomes operative from the midnight of the day by operation of the provisions of the General Clauses Act, 1897. (Para 3 )
7. Does a specific commencement time in an insurance policy override the General Clauses Act?
Yes, a special contract specifying a particular time for the insurance policy to become operative overrides the general rule that contracts start at midnight. (Para 3 )
(1) THIS appeal by special leave is confined to the question as to whether the accident had occurred during the operation of the insurance policy in controversy. The admitted position is that the renewal of the insurance was effected as under:
"ADDRESS: Jul Apartment, ... Rd. Vile Parle (N), Bombay 5
IT is hereby understood and agreed that the renewal premium of Rs 1307 only under this Policy having been paid on 25/10/1983 and not within the renewal date viz. 14/10/1983 the Insurance by this Policy is suspended from 14/10/1983 (4 p.m.) to 24/10/1983.
FURTHER, it is declared and agreed that the cover under this Policy is reinstated and renewed for a further period of twelve months from 25/10/1983 to 24/10/1984 at a premium of Rs. 1,307.00."
(2) THE tribunal also had recorded, as a fact, that on 25/10/1983 at 4.00 p.m., the contract of renewal had come into force and it would he operative up to 24/10/1984. The tribunal also recorded, as a fact, that the accident had occurred on 25/10/1983 at 11.14 a.m., that is, before the renewal of the contract. Under these circumstances, it would be clear that the accident had occurred when the renewal had not taken effect.
(3) THIS court in New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Ram Dayal had held that in the absence of any specific time mentioned in that behalf, the contractwould be operative from the midnight of the day by operation of provisions of the General Clauses Act, 1897. But in view of the special contract mentioned in the insurance policy, namely, it would be operative from 4.00 p.m. on 25/10/1983 and the accident had occurred earlier thereto, theinsurance coverage would not enable the claimant to seek recovery of the amount from the appellant-Company.
(4) THE appeal is accordingly allowed only to the above extent. In respect of any claim against the owner, the respondent is at liberty to have it recovered. No costs.
