1. Sales tax dispute — Challenge to judgments via writ petitions — Request for withdrawal to raise issues before the concerned authority. (Para 1 , 3 )
Back
Next 
2000 Supreme(SC) 1165
SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Commercial Tax Officer
VERSUS
Canara Bank
July 26, 2000
Important Points
The court has the discretion to allow the withdrawal of writ petitions with liberty to raise all issues before the concerned authority, and to set aside judgments and orders under appeal, leaving all arguments open to either side in subsequent proceedings.
Subject
Civil Law - Administrative Law
Act Referred
Headnote
Legal Issues - Withdrawal of Writ Petitions - The court allowed the withdrawal of writ petitions with liberty to raise all factual and legal issues before the concerned authority, setting aside the judgments and orders under appeal and leaving all arguments open to either side in proceedings before the Sales Tax authorities.
Fact of the Case:
The respondents sought leave to withdraw the writ petitions with liberty to raise all issues factual and legal before the concerned authority, after the court expressed reservations about the correctness of the judgments under appeal.
Finding of the Court:
The court allowed the withdrawal of the writ petitions, set aside the judgments and orders under appeal, and left all arguments open to either side in proceedings before the Sales Tax authorities.
Issues: Withdrawal of Writ Petitions, Setting Aside Judgments and Orders, Open Arguments in Sales Tax Proceedings
Ratio Decidendi: The court allowed the withdrawal of the writ petitions with liberty to raise all issues before the concerned authority, setting aside the judgments and orders under appeal and leaving all arguments open to either side in proceedings before the Sales Tax authorities.
Final Decision: The writ petitions were allowed to be withdrawn, the judgments and orders under appeal were set aside, and all arguments were left open to either side in proceedings before the Sales Tax authorities.
Legal Category Hierarchy
Table of Contents
2. Respondents seek withdrawal of writ petitions to present factual and legal particulars before the concerned authority. (Para 1 )
3. The court expressed strong prima facie reservations regarding the correctness of the judgments under appeal. (Para 2 )
4. Withdrawal of writ petitions with liberty to raise issues before the concerned authority results in the setting aside of the judgments under appeal. (Para 3 )
5. Writ petitions are allowed to be withdrawn, judgments under appeal are set aside, and all arguments remain open before Sales Tax authorities. (Para 3 , 4 , 5 )
6. What is the effect of allowing the withdrawal of writ petitions with liberty to raise issues before the concerned authority?
The court may allow the withdrawal, which consequently sets aside the judgments and orders delivered in those petitions and any subsequent appeals. (Para 3 )
7. Do parties lose the right to argue their positions before the original authority after withdrawing a writ petition?
No, the court may direct that all arguments remain open to both sides in the proceedings before the relevant authorities. (Para 4 )
( 1 ) LEARNED counsel for the respondents make the following statement :
"in view of the fact that for a proper appreciation of the legal issues arising for consideration, the particulars of the nature of transactions is necessary, leave is sought for withdrawing the writ petitions with liberty to raise all the issues factual and legal, before the concerned authority. "
( 2 ) THE statement is made after we have heard learned counsel for the appellants and, partly, learned counsel for the respondents and have expressed our strong, prima facie, reservations about the correctness of the judgments under appeal.
( 3 ) ON the application of learned counsel for the respondents aforestated, the writ petitions filed-before the High Courts of Karnataka and Kerala (Writ Petition Nos. 18751/88, 13591/89, 1339/93-H, 9508/94-F, 962-63/93-M and 15547/92-A) are allowed to be withdrawn. Consequently, the judgments and orders delivered therein and in appeals therefrom, i. e. , the judgments and orders under appeal stand set aside.
( 4 ) ALL arguments shall be open to either side in proceedings before the Sales Tax authorities.
( 5 ) NO order as to costs. Order accordingly.
