( 1 ) THIS appeal is against an order of the Customs, Excise and Gold (Control) Appellate Tribunal (CEGAT), dated 20-1-1995.

( 2 ) BRIEFLY stated, the facts are as follows: the appellants are manufacturers of motor vehicles. They also manufacture components of motor vehicles. The components are manufactured at their factory near Madras. Some of the components are then transferred from their factory at Madras to their own units at Hosur, Alwar and Bhandara. A small percentage of the components is also sold by them in the open market as spare parts for the vehicles. The question for consideration is what is the value to be taken for payment of excise duty in respect of the components which have been removed by the appellants from their factory at Madras and transferred to the units at Hosur, Alwar and bhandara.

( 3 ) THE Assistant Collector, Collector and CEGAT have held that the value has to be determined in accordance with Section 4 (1) (a) of the Central excise Act, 1944 (the Act ). It has been held that ascertainable sale price is available. According to the appellants, in respect of the components which are transferred by them to their sister units, the value has to be ascertain