Supreme Court Of India
Decided On : (July 31, 1978)
UJJAGAR SINGH
Versus
STATE OF DELHI
Pay to the Hirelings - In view of concurrent findings of sessions court and high court on principal issues arising in case we see no justification for granting special leave for a reconsideration of question as regards guilt of petitioners evidence establishes complicity of petitioners in crime charged beyond a reasonable doubt beyond perhaps even an unreasonable doubt so explicit and eloquent are facts of case - There is hardly a case civil or criminal which does not raise some question of law or other but no question of law of general public importance I involved in these petitions – Held, If there is anything at all in this case which shocks our conscience it is this that if death sentence was at all to be awarded it should have been awarded to hirelings and that husband and his mistress who promised to pay to hirelings large sums of moneys in order to procure murder of wife should have been awarded lesser sentence - But we shall not go into that question any further since sessions court and high court have concurrently taken view that sentence of life imprisonment is enough to meet ends of justice insofar as two latter are concerned - Petitions are accordingly dismissed.
( 1 ) IN view of the concurrent findings of the Sessions court and the high court on the principal issues arising in the case we see no justification for granting special leave for a reconsideration of the question as regards, the guilt of the petitioners. . The evidence establishes the complicity of the petitioners in the crime charged beyond a reasonable doubt, beyond perhaps even an unreasonable doubt. So explicit and eloquent are the facts of the case. There is hardly a case, civil or criminal, which does not raise some question of law or the other. But no question of law of general public importance i involved in these petitions. It is time that it was realised that the jurisdiction of this court to grant special leave to appeal can be invoked in very exceptional circumstances. A question of law of general public importance or a decision which shocks the conscience of the court are some of the prime requisites for the grant of special leave. If there is anything at all in this case which shocks our conscience it is this : that, if the death sentence was at all to be awarded, it should have been awardedto the hirelings and that the husband and his mistress who promised to pay to the hirelings large sums of moneys in order to procure the murder of the wife should have been awarded the lesser sentence. But we shall not go into that question any further, since the Sessions court and the High court have concurrently taken the view that the sentence of life imprisonment is enough to meet the ends of justice insofar as the two latter are concerned.
( 2 ) THE special leave petitions are accordingly dismissed.
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.