2008(8) Supreme 76
SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Arijit Pasayat, Tarun Chatterjee and Lokeshwar Singh Panta, JJ.
Rajmohan Agarwal — Appellant
versus
Smt. Amna Abubakar & Anr. — Respondents
Civil Appeal No. 5231 of 2000
Decided on : 07-11-2008
Facts of the Case :
Suit for specific performance of a contract filed herein in the instant case was dismissed by Trial Court. Appeals there against were dismissed by High Court. Present appeals have been filed against said orders of High Court.
Findings of the Court :
Held portion of property already sold by respondents to one P and R by way of different sale deeds would not be disturbed and would be accepted as final and conclusive. Appellants shall purchase remaining area the portion of land not sold by the respondents at the current market value. Pursuant to the amicable settlement arrived at between the parties, and parties having broadly settled their dispute as to the valuation of the property on the terms and conditions as indicated, appeals disposed of on compromise on terms and conditions as mentioned in said compromise deed.
Result : Appeals disposed of.
JUDGMENT
Tarun Chatterjee, J. —
1. These four appeals are directed against the judgment and decree passed in four First Appeals, being Appeal No. 173/1995 (Shasi Mohan Agarwal Vs. Smt. Fatima Ahmed alias Begum Rashiduddin Siddiqui & 2 others), Appeal No. 174/1995 (Rajmohan Agarwal Vs. Smt. Amna), Appeal No. 204/1995 (Rajmohan Agarwal vs. Smt Amna Abubakar & Another) and Appeal No. 206/1995 (Shashi Mohan Agarwal Vs. Smt. Fatima Ahmed alias Begum Rashiduddin Siddiqui & 2 others), passed by a Division Bench of the High Court of Madhya Pradesh at Jabalpur, confirming the judgment and decree of the trial court in a suit for specific performance of a contract, by which the suit and the appeals were dismissed.
2. These appeals were heard for a considerable length of time, it was suggested by the Court that in the facts and circumstances of the case, the parties may explore the possibility of an amicable settlement. Accordingly, the parties have taken some time to look into the question whether an amicable settlement can be arrived at and finally mentioned before us that they have agreed to an amicable settlement in the following manner:-
[I] The portion of the property already sold by the respondents herein to Smt. Poonam Chokse and Smt. Rasmani Jaiswal by way of different sale deeds will not be disturbed and will be accepted as final and conclusive.
[II] The appellants shall purchase the remaining area (i.e. the portion of the land not sold by the respondents) at the current market value.
3. Pursuant to the amicable settlement arrived at between the parties, and the parties having broadly settled their dispute as to the valuation of the property on the terms and conditions as indicated hereinabove, these appeals can be disposed of on compromise on the following terms and conditions:-
a) The total area of the land was 49,259 Sq. Ft., out of which 24,477.89 marked ‘B’ in the sketch map annexed with the affidavit filed on behalf of the respondents as Annexure AA2 is still in possession of Begum Fatima Ahmed & Smt. Amna Abubaker (respondents herein). Since the parties have agreed that the portion of the property already sold by the respondents in favour of one Smt. Poonam Chokse and Smt. Rasmani Jaiswal shall not be disturbed and shall be accepted as final and conclusive, only the possession of the remaining area namely, 24,477.89, marked ‘B’ in the sketch map - Annexure AA2 shall be handed over to the appellants by the respondents at a consideration mentioned hereinafter. The parties before us through their learned counsel have suggested that whatever rate that is fixed by this Court shall be accepted by all of them. That being the stand taken by the parties before us and after making an enquiry we find that if Rs.5500/- per sq. feet is fixed as the valuation of the aforesaid unsold portion of the land in question, the estimated price would come to Rs.13,46,29,000 (Thirteen Crores Forty Six Lakhs and Twenty Nine Thousand) [Rs. 5500 X 24,478(round off)]. Therefore, we fix the rate of the land at Rs.5500/- per sq. ft. which comes to Rs.13,46,29,000/-(Thirteen crores forty six lakhs and twenty nine thousand) to be paid by the appellants to the respondents.
b) Out of the aforesaid total amount of Rs.13,46,29,000/-(Thirteen crores forty six lakhs and twenty nine thousand), a sum of Rs.4 crores shall be paid by the appellants to the respondents within one month and the balance amount of Rs.9,46,29,000/- (Nine Crores Forty Six Lacs and Twenty Nine Thousand) shall be paid by five equal monthly installments, starting from the date of the payment of the 1st Installment.
c) In default of payment of any of the installments, as directed above, the suit for specific performance shall stand dismissed and the appellants shall not be entitled to any portion of the land in dispute as indicated in the sketch map [ Annex. AA2 ] annexed with this order.
d) If the appellants duly pay the aforesaid amount of Rs.13,46,29,000/-(Thirteen crores forty six lakhs and twent
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.