1926 Supreme(SC) 14
Privy Council
Ameer Ali, Sir John Edge, Blanesburgh, Justice Viscount Dunedin, JJ.
Balbhaddar Singh and another -Appellant
Versus
Badri Sah and another -Resopndent
Privy Council Appeal No. 66 of 1924 : from Oudh Appeal No. 17 of 1923
Decided On : 16-03-1926
Important Points
Subject
Civil Law - Torts
Act Referred
Headnote
(B) Malicious Prosecution - Burden of proof - The plaintiff must prove that the prosecution was instituted without any reasonable and probable cause and was due to the malicious intention of the defendant - Where information is given to authorities which leads to prosecution, the plaintiff must show that the defendant invented the story and tutored witnesses to implicate them - This constitutes a heavy onus of proof on the plaintiff. (Paras 26-27)
Facts of the case:
Two individuals confessed to a murder, implicating the appellants. Based on these confessions, the appellants were arrested but subsequently discharged by the Magistrate and the District Judge due to lack of evidence. During the trial of the confessors, both recanted their statements, leading to their own discharge. The appellants then filed a civil suit for malicious prosecution against a respondent, alleging that the respondent had tutored the witnesses to falsely implicate them due to long-standing family enmity.
Findings of Court:
The court found that the lower appellate court had taken a wrong view of the law by requiring the plaintiffs to prove their innocence. However, on the facts, the court held that the plaintiffs failed to discharge the heavy burden of proof required to establish that the respondent had invented the charges and tutored the witnesses, despite the existence of suspicion and enmity.
Issues: Whether the proof of innocence of the original charge is a necessary element for a successful action for malicious prosecution, and whether the plaintiffs established that the respondent maliciously instigated the criminal proceedings without probable cause.
Ratio Decidendi: In a claim for malicious prosecution, the essential requirement is that the proceedings terminated in the plaintiff's favour, not that the plaintiff was actually innocent of the crime. The burden remains on the plaintiff to prove that the defendant acted with malice and without reasonable and probable cause. Suspicion, even if grave, is insufficient to meet the heavy onus of proof required to establish that a defendant tutored witnesses to fabricate a crime.
Result: Appeal dismissed.
Legal Category Hierarchy
-
tort
-
malicious prosecution
- termination of proceedings
- burden of proof
-
malicious prosecution
-
crime and sentencing
-
offences against the person
- murder
-
offences against administration of justice
- false charges
-
offences against the person
Barrow Rogers and Nevill, S.L. Polak, T.B.D. Ramsey, A.M. Dunne, B. Dube, De Gruyther
Viscount Dunedin. -
The appellants and respondents are lambardars and the principal inhabitants in the village of Mohiuddinpur. The suit arises out of circumstances of a remarkable character, which took place in connexion with a crime as to which the complete truth will in all likelihood never be discovered.
One Sheo Bux, a humble inhabitant of the village, was last seen alive on the evening of the 17th September 1919. As he was under police supervision his ab sence after that date was noticed by the village policeman, but it was supposed that he had gone to some other village.
On the 20th September, a little after noon, a party of four persons arrived at the police office, which is situated at a place called Pasgawan, about two miles from the village. These were Badri Sah, a lambardar in the village, and one of the respondents, Hazari, a cultivator, his son, Raghunath, aged 18, and Bharat, a cultivator. The sub-inspector of Police was, at the moment, absent, and a policeman was in charge. Raghunath then proceeded to make a confession, which was recorded in the police diary of the day. The confession was to this effect :
The appellants had, some time ago, offered him Rs. 500 if he would do away with Sheo Bux. He had returned an ambiguous answer to the proposal. On the 17th September his father had gone away from the village. The appellant Bachchu had then said that this was the opportunity desired. Accordingly, when nightfall came the two appellants came to his house and despatched Teja, a barber, 16 years old, to fetch Sheo Bux. They all sat down ; then Balbhaddar fell upon Sheo Bux, put his hand on his mouth, while Bachchu grappled with him. With the assistance of Teja and himself, Raghunath, they carried him into the house. He and Teja held his feet. Balbhaddar sat on his chest and held his mouth and Bachchu, with a knife, cut his throat, and he died. A hole was then dug in the floor of the house and the body buried. He applied for his Rs. 500, but was told by the ap pellants he would get that when they took the body away. On the 19th Sep tember he asked them to take away the body, but they said that they had had no opportunity of doing so. This day, that is, the 20th, his father had returned and he told him the whole story. His father went to Badri Sah, who told him to bring Raghunath to him where he was sitting along with Bharat Singh. To them he repeated the story, whereupon they all took him to the police office. After this he was consigned to the lock up, and the policeman in charge sent a message to the Sub-Inspector. The Sub-inspector hurried back to the village and sent for Raghunath from the lock-up. He repeated to him the same confession, and on being taken to his house pointed out where the body was buried and where the shoes and garments of the deceased were also buried.
The body was exhumed ; the shoes and garments found. It was the body of Sheo Bux and his throat was cut. The Sub-Inspector thereupon arrested Teja and locked him and Raghunath up. The next morning he sent both Raghunath and Teja to Lakinpur, and there, on the 24th September, they were brought before the Magistrate. The Magistrate, as in duty bound, took a statement from each of them, no policemen being present, and he having duly informed them that he was a Magistrate. Raghunath repeated his confession with a little more dramatic detail, but in all essential respects as before. Teja gave a shorter account. He described the murder in identical terms. To each of these confessions the Magistrate appended this note :
I believe that this confession was voluntarily made. It was made in my presence and hearing. It was read over to the parson making it, and was admitted by him to be correct. It contains a full and true account of the statement made by him.
On the 27th October the Magistrate, having examined some other witnesses, among whom was Mt. Parbati, the mother of the murdered man, who swore that, on the 17th, she saw the two ap pellants along with Ragh