1928 Supreme(SC) 9
Privy Council
Sir John Wallis, Sinha, Atkinson, Justice Viscount Sumner, JJ.
Baijnath Ram and another -Appellant
Versus
Gopal Ram Khemka and others -Resopndent
Privy Council Appeal No. 124 of 1926 Patna Appeal No. 7 of 1926
Decided On : 09-02-1928
Important Points
Subject
Civil Law - Specific Performance of Contract
Headnote
Facts of the case:
A suit was instituted for the specific performance of a contract for the sale of a dwelling house. The plaintiffs alleged that an agreement had been reached for a specific price and that the purchaser failed to complete the purchase. The defense contended that the contract was not concluded because the seller failed to provide satisfactory title deeds and did not remove a tenant from the premises. The trial court dismissed the suit, holding that no completed contract existed. However, the High Court reversed this decision, finding that the settlement of price and the purchase of stamp paper indicated a completed agreement.
Findings of Court:
The court concurred with the High Court, finding that the evidence supported the existence of a completed agreement. The settlement of the purchase price, the preparation and approval of a draft deed, and the purchase of stamp paper were sufficient indicators that the negotiation stage had ended and a binding contract had been formed.
Issues: Whether the actions of the parties, specifically the settlement of price and the purchase of stamp paper, constituted a concluded contract for the sale of the property or remained at the stage of negotiation.
Ratio Decidendi: The court held that when the price and terms are fixed, a draft deed is approved, and stamp paper is purchased for the execution of the deed, these facts collectively point toward a completed contract. The failure to produce certain title documents or the presence of a tenant does not necessarily negate the existence of the agreement if the parties had already progressed to the stage of preparing the final deed.
Result: Appeal dismissed.
Legal Category Hierarchy
-
civil law
-
property law
- specific performance
- sale of immovable property
-
property law
-
contract law
-
formation of contract
- concluded contracts
-
formation of contract
-
practice and procedure
-
evidence
- appreciation of evidence
-
evidence
W. W. Box and Co., Watkins and Hunter, M. A. Maid, W. H. Upjohn, B. Dub, L. De Grunter
Lord Atkinson.-
This is an appeal from a judgment and decree, dated 15th December 1925, of the High Court of Judicature at Patina which reversed a judgment and decree, dated 2nd March 1922, of the Additional Subordinate Judge of Bhagalpur. The plaintiffs (respondents), on 15th February 1921, instituted the suit out of which this appeal has arisen against one Janki Das (since deceased), the father of the defendant, alleging that the said Janki Das had, in the last week of the month of June 1920, entered into an agreement to buy from Gopal Ram, one of the plaintiffs, a certain dwelling house for the price of Rs. 17,500 and had failed to complete the purchase thereof. The plaintiffs claimeda decree for specific performance of the said contract of purchase with damages and costs.
The house, the subject-matter of the aforesaid suit, was a municipal holding, No. 16 in Ward No. 11 of the Bhagalpur Municipality on the Khalifabagh road. Gopal Ram was at the hearing of the case before the Additional Subordinate Judge examined as a witness on behalf of the plaintiffs. He alleged that he was the ' managing member of their joint family and that the family had acquired the above-mentioned house by two sale deeds dated respectively 5th October 1909, and 29th June 1912 : that he entered into an agreement with Janki Das (since deceased) to sell to the latter, for Rs. 17,500, through Jagarnath Ram and two of the defendant's witnesses ; that he gave 1,016 pages of documents of title to one Rameshwar to be handed over to the purchaser, notwithstanding which the latter, without any reason, failed to complete the purchase. The oral evidence given at the trial is rather confused, not precise, definite or distinctly pointed to the vital issues in controversy, so that it is with a feeling of relief one turns to the consideration of the written or printed documents put in evidence. Janki Das, the purchaser, having delayed to complete the purchase, Gopal Ram, on, behalf of the vendors, caused the following notice, dated 25th August 1920, to be served upon the former. This notice is rather lengthy, but it purports to set out and describe so many relevant facts and incidents that it is desirable to quote it at length. It runs as follows :
From
Charu Chandra Ghosh, Pleader.
Adampore, Bhagalpur.
To
Babu Janki Dass, son of Babu Tularam, deceased, of Shujagunj, Thana Kotwali, District Bhagalpur.
Sir,
Under instruction from my clients Babu. Gopalram and Sagar Mal, sons of Babu Hukumi Chand, deceased, of Bazar Shujagunj, Bhagalpur, I beg to inform you that the contract of sale of a house belonging to my client, being. Municipal holding No. 16, Ward No. II, with boundaries specification given below, situate in mahalla Khalifabagh within the town of Bhagalpur, was complete between my clients and yourself, and that through the intervention of Babu Kheali Ram, son of Babu Dalooram, deceased, and Babu Rameshwar Lall, son of Babu Ram Chandra, deceased, the price of the said house was settled at Rs. 17,500 about two months ago, and in virtue of that completed contract of sale you sent over a draft of kebala for my clients' approval, and the said draft regarding, the sale of the said property was examined and substantially approved by Maulvi Allauddin Ahmad, B.L., Vakil, on behalf of my clients, and that it was settled that you would at once get the kebala duly executed and registered at your own costs on payment of Rs. 17,500 to my clients. That it is about a month and a half ago that my clients duly approved of the draft kebala, but in spite of their repeated demands you have not as yet got the kebala duly executed and registered, nor have you paid the consideration money to my client. That on account of delay in payment of the consideration money my clients have suffered pecuniary loss in the shape of interest and damages, etc., which I beg to note here he is entitled to get from you, and I am requested to inform you that you will kindly get the kebala duly executed and reg