SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
RANJAN GOGOI, R.K. AGRAWAL, N.V. RAMANA, JJ.
Samaj Parivartana Samudaya & Ors. - Petitioners
Versus
State of Karnataka & Ors. - Respondents
I.A. Nos. 188, 225, 230 In I.A. No. 188, I.A. Nos. 237, 238, 239, 240 & 244 In Writ Petition (Civil) No. 562 of 2009
Decided On : 30-07-2015
Mines and Minerals Act, 1957 – Commerce and Industries Department – Production limit of all the mines – Evidence – Condo nation of delay - From materials on record and statement made by Secretary Commerce and Industries Department Government of Karnataka, it appears that 15 of the Category C mines are ready for auction - Court therefore, direct that auction of aforesaid mines details of which are indicated herein below will commence immediately and stand concluded within outer limit of 32 weeks, preferably within 26 weeks with effect from today – Held, Member Secretary Central Empowered Committee on being called upon by Court with reference to prayer of the applicant-Federation of Indian Mineral Industries made in paragraph 42 of the Additional Affidavit has made a statement that the production limit of all mines taken together may exceed cap - However, the actual production cannot exceed said figure - In view of aforesaid statement made by Member Secretary, CEC Court see no difficulty in CEC considering prayer made by applicant FIMI in paragraph stated above which obviously will be as per norms contained in Para 8 judgment in and others Versus State of Karnataka and others - A prayer has also been made in Additional Affidavit filed on behalf of FIMI for a direction to CEC to refund the guarantee monies deposited by lessees who have completed R&R works after necessary satisfaction that works have been completed - CEC is to file a report on completion of such works by leaseholder where after Court will pass appropriate order - A prayer has also been made in Additional Affidavit filed on behalf of FIMI for a direction to CEC to refund guarantee monies deposited by lessees who have completed R&R works, after necessary satisfaction that works have been completed - CEC is to file a report on completion of such works by leaseholder(s) where after Court will pass appropriate orders – Petition dismissed
ORDER :
The issue with regard to modalities that would govern the auction of the Category 'C' mines which have been ordered to be cancelled by our judgment and order dated 18th April, 2013 passed in Writ Petition (Civil) No. 562 of 2009 [Samaj Parivartana Samudaya and others versus State of Karnataka and others] and other connected matters is being dealt with by the present order.
2. Shri Nilaya Mitash, IAS, Secretary, Commerce and Industries Department (Mines), Government of Karnataka, Bangalore is personally present in Court at the request of the Court. From the materials on record and the statement made by Shri Nilaya Mitash, Secretary, Commerce and Industries Department (Mines), Government of Karnataka, it appears that 15 of the Category 'C' mines are ready for auction. We, therefore, direct that the auction of the aforesaid mines, details of which are indicated herein below will commence immediately and stand concluded within outer limit of 32 weeks, preferably within 26 weeks with effect from today.
| S. No. | Name of the Mine | ML No. |
| 1. | Deccan Mining Syndicate (P) Ltd. | 2525 |
| 2. | Karthikeyas Managanese | 2559 |
| 3. | Hothur Traders | 2313 |
| 4. | V.S. Lad & Sons | 2290 |
| 5. | B.R. Yogendranath Singh | 2186 |
| 6. | M/s Lakshminarayan Mining Co. | 2487 |
| 7. | Rama Rao Paol | 2621 |
| 8. | Ramgad Mines & Mineral Pvt. Ltd. | 2451 |
| 9. | M/s Channakeshava Reddy | 2566 |
| 10. | M/s Nidhi Mining Company | 2433 |
| 11. | M/s S.B. Minerals | 2393 |
| 12. | M/s Srinivasalu Mines | 2631 |
| 13. | M/s Tungabhadra Minerals Pvt. Ltd. | 2365 |
| 14. | M/s Tungabhadra Minerals Pvt. Ltd. | 2366 |
| 15. | M/s Mineral Mines and traders | 2185(A) |
3. The modalities which would govern the auction would be as follows:
1. The lease boundary of each of the mining lease will be as approved by this Court by judgment and order dated 18th April, 2013.
2. Only the end-users engaged in production of sponge iron and/or pig iron and/or steel and/or pellets will be eligible to take part in the auction. The end-users will include Public Sector Undertakings;
3. The reserve price under Rule 8(1) Mineral (Auction) Rules, 2015 will be specified in the tender documents at 35%.
4. The permissible annual production will be as prescribed under the approved R&R Plan prepared until such time that the same is modified by this Court.
5. The successful bidder/lessee will be required to produce and dispatch every year at least 50% of the permissible annual production as prescribed under the approved R&R Plan. Whenever the dispatch in a year is below the guaranteed dispatch as indicated above in that case irrespective of the quantity actually dispatched the total amount payable during the year will be based on the guaranteed dispatch. In addition, the lessee may also be required to surrender the lease. This condition will not be applicable during the initial period of 18 months provided to the successful bidder/lessee to obtain the statutory approvals;
6. The successful bidder/lessee will be required to implement the prescriptions/provisions of the approved R&R Plan in accordance with the guidelines approved by this Court. The cost incurred for this will be reimbursed by the State Government to the successful bidder/lessee after recovering the same from the erstwhile lessee;
7. Consortium of end-users will not be eligible to participate in the auction;
8. The existing statutory approvals/clearances in favour of the lessee of the erstwhile Category 'C' mining leases will be transferred in favour of the new lessees. The concerned authority will take expeditious action for the grant of the statutory approvals such as the environmental clearance and approval/TWP under the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980;
9. The State of Karnataka will be at liberty to reduce the reserve price for the mining leases for which no bid above the reserve price is received;
10. The sale proceeds of the auction, for the prese
Samaj Parivartana Samudaya and others Versus State of Karnataka and others
SupremeToday
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.