SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Judicial Analysis Court Copy Headnote Facts Arguments Court observation
Listen Audio Icon Pause Audio Icon
judgment-img

1996 Supreme(SC) 2386

SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Kuldip Singh and S. Saghir Ahmad, JJ.
M.C. Mehta - Petitioner
Versus
Union of India and others - Respondents
I.A. No. 32 in W.P. (C) No. 4677 of 1985
Decided On : 10-12-1996

Headnote:

Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 - Sections 3, 4 and 5 - planning for sustainable water resource management - control imposed by the institutional agencies - ensure equitability in water availability and pragmatic land – Claim of compensation - Central Groundwater Board, filed an affidavit pursuant to this Courts order - He stated in affidavit that during onwards water levels in the country are declining - So much so during fall in water level was National Capital Territory - There was a further fall of water level more than 8 m during period - One of reasons stated in affidavit for the decline of water level was the enhanced - Keeping in view the facts stated by this Court issued notice to Union of India through the Secretary, Ministry of Water Resources and to the Government of NCT Delhi through its Chief Secretary - Various authorities have filed affidavits indicating the factual position regarding the fall of water levels in the country – Held, Learned counsel assisting us in this matter have vehemently contended that keeping in view the declining level of underground water all over the country, it is necessary to regulate withdrawal of the underground water - It is no doubt correct that there are legislations in some of the States to regulate the water resources development, but by and large underground water is being exploited all over the country without any regulations. It has, therefore, been rightly suggested by NEERI in its Report that an Authority under Act be constituted with the powers necessary to deal with the situation created by the depletion of the groundwater levels, dwindling surface water resources, deterioration of surface and groundwater quality and haphazard land use - In order to address the complex issues in water resource management it is prudent that the Central Government considers constituting an authority under the Environment Act, 1986 and confers on this authority all the powers necessary to deal with the situation created by the depletion of groundwater levels, dwindling surface water resources, deterioration of surface and groundwater quality and haphazard land use - Authority should be headed by a retired with expertise in the field of hydrology, hydrogeology, information technology - Recommendations: A Central Water Resource Management Authority, with the composition as delineated in Section 6 above, with mandate for coordination and implementation of all activities of planning, development, allocation, implementation, research and monitoring of all water resources need to be established to promote intra and inter-generational equity, as also to precautionary principle in sustainable water resource management. All the States need to constitute similar authorities with functions in the State as of the Central Authority - Mandate of the authority needs to include the following - It has been stated by in their respective affidavits that enhanced and unregulated of the water is primarily responsible for the decline in the water levels of the country - Main object for the constitution of the Board as an Authority is the urgent need for regulating the indiscriminate boring and withdrawal of underground water in the country – Court have no doubt that the Authority so constituted shall apply its mind to this urgent aspect of the matter and shall issue necessary regulatory directions with a view to preserve and protect the underground water - This aspect may be taken up by the Authority on an urgent basis – Appeal disposed of

ORDER :

S. Saghir Ahmad, J.

1. This Court on 20-3-1996 took notice of the news item under the caption ?Falling Groundwater Level Threatens City?, appearing in the Indian Express of 18-3-1996. This Court issued notice to the Central Groundwater Board and the Delhi Pollution Control Committee. The news item was brought to the notice of this Court by Mr M.C. Mehta, Advocate. On 3-4-1996, this Court issued notice to the Municipal Corporation of Delhi and the Delhi Waterworks and Sewerage Disposal Undertaking.

2. Dr P.C. Chaturvedi, Scientist ?D? (Director), Central Groundwater Board, filed an affidavit pursuant to this Court's order. He stated in the affidavit that during the years from 1962 onwards, the water levels in the country are declining. So much so, during the years 1971-83, the fall in water level was from 4 m to 8 m in the National Capital Territory. There was a further fall of water level from 4 m to more than 8 m during the period 1983-85. One of the reasons stated in the affidavit for the decline of water level was the enhanced pumpage. Keeping in view the facts stated by Dr Chaturvedi, this Court issued notice to the Union of India through the Secretary, Ministry of Water Resources and to the Government of NCT, Delhi, through its Chief Secretary. Various authorities have filed affidavits indicating the factual position regarding the fall of water levels in the country.

3. This Court by the order dated 4-9-1996, requested Dr P. Khanna, Director, NEERI, to have the matter examined at the Institute level by experts in the field and to file a report in this Court. The NEERI was asked to give suggestions and recommendations for checking further decline of underground water level. NEERI filed the examination report dated 23-9-1996 regarding ?Water Resources Management in India, Present Status and Solution Paradigm?. Mr Arun Kumar, Additional Secretary, Ministry of Water Resources, filed an affidavit dated 24-10-1996, commenting on the NEERI Report and also indicating an overall picture of the declining water levels in the country and also the various schemes and activities undertaken by various Departments of Government of India to monitor the groundwater. The relevant paragraphs of the affidavit are as under:

    4.2 It may be pointed out that the main reason for gradual decline in the level of groundwater in certain areas of the country is over-exploitation. Presently the control being exercised in the country for regulating groundwater development is in the form of indirect administrative measures being adopted by institutional finance agencies who by and large insist on technical clearance of the schemes from authorised groundwater departments of the respective States. These departments in turn look into the various aspects of groundwater availability. Another control imposed by the institutional agencies, availing financing facilities from National Bank for Agriculture and Rural Development is by way of prescribing spacing criteria between the groundwater structures. Yet another method of indirect control is by way of denial of power connections for the pump-sets financed through loans from banks. However, in the absence of any law, the administrative measure do not prevent affluent farmers from constructing wells in critical areas. An affluent farmer with his large capital investment can construct a high capacity well which affects shallow wells in the neighbourhood. In order to arrest the depleting trend and to avoid indiscriminatory withdrawal of groundwater, the Government of India had circulated a Model Bill to the States/Union Territories in 1970 to help them to bring out suitable legislation on the lines of the Model Bill to regulate and control the development of groundwater in their respective areas.

    5. This para outlines the need for regulation and extraction of groundwater and lays emphasis on integrated water resources management including regulation on land use and proposed agriculture practices, human settlement

      Click Here to Read the rest of this document
      1
      2
      3
      4
      5
      6
      7
      8
      9
      10
      11
      SupremeToday Portrait Ad
      supreme today icon
      logo-black

      An indispensable Tool for Legal Professionals, Endorsed by Various High Court and Judicial Officers

      Please visit our Training & Support
      Center or Contact Us for assistance

      qr

      Scan Me!

      India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!

      For Daily Legal Updates, Join us on :

      whatsapp-icon Back to top