SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2026 Supreme(SC) 1380

SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
PRASHANT KUMAR MISHRA, VIPUL M. PANCHOLI, JJ.
Bheemanagouda @ Bheemajja – Appellant
Versus
State by Harapanahalli Police – Respondent
Criminal Appeal No. 5402 of 2026 (Arising out of SLP(Crl.) No. 13798 of 2025)
Decided On : 18-11-2026

Important Points

Recovery of stolen property under Section 27 Evidence Act establishes a presumption of theft under Section 114, but cannot infer murder unless the robbery and homicide are proved to be part of the same transaction. "Last seen" evidence requires timely recording and independent corroboration to sustain a conviction.

Subject

Criminal Law - Homicide and Circumstantial Evidence

Act Referred

Headnote

(A) Indian Penal Code, 1860 - Sections 302 and 201 - Indian Evidence Act, 1872 - Sections 27, 106 and 114 - Circumstantial evidence - Conviction based on recovery of ornaments and last seen theory - Chain of circumstances must be complete and unbroken and inconsistent with any hypothesis of innocence - Motive based on conjectures cannot be used to sustain conviction. (Paras 9, 10.2)

(B) Last seen together theory - This circumstance does not lead to an inference of guilt unless there is proximate and independent corroborative material - Unexplained and inordinate delay in recording statements under Section 161 Cr.P.C. renders such evidence unreliable and insufficient to establish a link between the accused and the crime. (Paras 11, 11.2)

(C) Recovery under Section 27 Evidence Act - Unexplained possession of articles belonging to the deceased enables a presumption under Illustration (a) to Section 114 Evidence Act regarding theft or receipt of stolen property - Such possession cannot be stretched to infer guilt for murder unless the prosecution conclusively proves that the robbery and murder were integral parts of the same transaction. (Paras 13.5)

Facts of the case:
Following the discovery of a woman's body in an iron drum, the cause of death was determined to be ligature strangulation. The prosecution alleged that the accused, who shared an illicit relationship with the deceased, committed the murder and robbed her ornaments. Conviction under Section 302 IPC was based on the recovery of ornaments from the accused's house and the "last seen together" theory. The Trial Court convicted the accused of murder but acquitted him under Section 201 IPC. The High Court subsequently affirmed the conviction.

Findings of Court:
The motive was found to be a matter of conjecture as no evidence established the accused's suspicion or quarrels with the deceased. The "last seen" evidence was rejected due to an unexplained 58-day delay in recording witness statements. The recovery of ornaments was deemed insufficient to prove murder, as the prosecution failed to prove that the ornaments were worn by the deceased at the time of her death or that the theft and murder were part of the same transaction.

Issues: Whether the chain of circumstantial evidence was complete and unbroken, and whether the recovery of stolen property and the "last seen" theory were sufficient to sustain a conviction for murder.

Ratio Decidendi: The prosecution failed to establish an unbroken chain of evidence. Motive cannot be based on surmise; "last seen" evidence requires proximity and timely recording to be reliable; and the recovery of stolen property under Section 27 Evidence Act only supports a presumption of theft, not murder, unless the two crimes are linked as a single continuous transaction. (Paras 10.2, 11.2, 13.5)

Result: Appeal allowed. Conviction under Section 302 IPC quashed and set aside; appellant acquitted.

Legal Category Hierarchy

  • crime and sentencing
    • offences against the person
    • offences involving property
      • theft/robbery (Para 3, 7, 13)
  • practice and procedure
    • evidence
      • appreciation of evidence (Para 9, 11, 13, 15)
      • circumstantial evidence (Para 7, 9, 15)
    • investigation
      • police statements (Para 11)
      • discovery and recovery (Para 5, 13)

Advocates appeared:
For the Petitioner(s): Mr. A. Sirajudeen, Sr. Adv. Ms. Jyotika Kalra, AOR Mr. Inderdeep Singh, Adv. Ms. Sonakshi Shankar Dikshit, Adv.
For the Respondent(s): Ms. Patil Rekha Chandra Gouda- 3361, AOR Mr. Avishkar Singhvi, AAG. Mr. Rajesh Gulab Inamdar, AOR Mr. Himanshu Mishra, Adv. Mr. Vivek Kr. Singh, Adv.

Table of Contents

1. Appeal against a conviction for murder under the penal code following the discovery of a deceased person's body and subsequent recovery of personal effects from the accused. (Para 2 , 3 )

2. Appellant challenges circumstantial evidence, particularly the reliability of motive, witness statements regarding being last seen together, and the recovery of ornaments under the evidence act. (Para 7 , 8 )

3. Court observes that the prosecution failed to establish a complete and unbroken chain of circumstantial evidence, noting gaps in motive, witness credibility, and recovery protocols. (Para 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 )

4. In circumstantial cases, conviction requires an unbroken chain of evidence; unexplained possession of stolen property without nexus to the murder does not per se prove homicide. (Para 13 , 15 )

5. Conviction and sentence for murder are set aside due to lack of proof beyond reasonable doubt; appellant is acquitted and ordered released. (Para 16 , 17 )

6. Can recovery of property under Section 27 of the Evidence Act alone sustain a murder conviction?

No. Recovery of stolen articles without proof that the theft and homicide formed a single continuous transaction only raises a presumption of theft, not necessarily murder under Section 302 IPC. (Para 13 )

7. What is the legal effect of an unexplained, inordinate delay in recording eyewitness statements under Section 161 CrPC?

An inordinate, unexplained delay in recording 161 CrPC statements renders the "last seen" circumstantial evidence unreliable and insufficient for forming an unbroken chain of guilt. (Para 11 )

8. Must the prosecution establish motive in a case resting on circumstantial evidence?

Yes, while not a sine qua non in direct evidence cases, motive is a critical link in the chain of circumstantial evidence and must be proven rather than conjectured. (Para 10 )

JUDGMENT :

Vipul M. Pancholi, J.

1. Leave granted.

2. The present appeal challenges the final judgment and order dated 09.07.2024 passed by the High Court of Karnataka at Bengaluru in Criminal Appeal No. 1355 of 2017. By the said impugned judgment, the Division Bench of the High Court dismissed the criminal appeal preferred by the appellant and confirmed the judgment of conviction dated 27.04.2017 and order on sentence dated 28.04.2017 rendered by the II Additional District & Sessions Judge and Special Judge, Davanagere in Sessions Case No. 101 of 2014. The Sessions Judge had convicted the appellant for an offence punishable under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (hereinafter “IPC”) and sentenced him to undergo imprisonment for life with a fine of Rs.25,000/- and in default, to undergo simple imprisonment for 1 year. By the same judgment, the Sessions Judge had acquitted the appellant of the charge framed under Section 201 IPC.

FACTUAL MATRIX

3. The brief facts material to the disposal of the present appeal are as under:

    3.1. At about 9:00 a.m. on 05.09.2013, the complainant, Ramappa (PW-1), who ran a limestone kiln along with others in the tank-bed area of Hirekere near Harihara Circle, Harapanahalli Town, received a phone call that a dead body of an unidentified woman was lying inside an iron drum kept near a lime furnace belonging to one Huligemma. PW-1 visited the place, saw the dead body stuffed inside the drum and lodged an oral complaint at Harapanahalli Police Station.

    3.2. Based on the said complaint, Crime No. 178 of 2013 was registered by Vasanth V. Asode, Police Sub-Inspector (PSI - PW-19) against unknown persons for offences punishable under Sections 302 and 201 IPC and the FIR was transmitted to the jurisdictional Magistrate. Mahantesh Sajjan, Circle Police Inspector (CPI - PW-24) took up the investigation and drew the spot panchanama and inquest mahazar on 05.09.2013. A plastic belt-like strap was seized from a nearby Babul tree and as the identity of the deceased was unknown, pamphlets containing photographs of the dead body were published and circulated to the public.

    3.3. On 07.09.2013, the family members of the deceased, including her son Ramesh (PW-8), nephew Lingaraj (PW-5), niece Kavitha (PW-10) and cousin Ramappa (PW-11), identified the deceased as one Sharadamma, wife of Hanumanthappa (PW-7) of Yarabalu village. It emerged that the deceased had attended the cradle ceremony of the daughter of PW-11 at Mitlakatte village on 01.09.2013. On 03.09.2013, PW-8 and the deceased’s mother returned to Yarabalu, while the deceased stayed behind. On 04.09.2013, at around 11:30 AM, the deceased left Mitlakatte to return home, wearing gold and silver ornaments, however, she did not reach her matrimonial or parental village and when her body was discovered, the ornaments were found missing.

    3.4. According to the prosecution, the appellant, Bheemanagouda @ Bheemajja, was in an illicit relationship with the deceased, who had been estranged from her husband for over a decade. The prosecution alleged that the appellant harboured suspicion that the deceased was also involved in an illicit relationship with another person. On the night of 04.09.2013, at about 12:00 midnight, the appellant took the deceased to the limestone furnace in Sy. No. 539/B1/BP1 near Hirekere, Harapanahalli, murdered her by strangulation with a plastic strap, robbed her ornaments and dumped her dead body inside an iron drum to screen the offence.

    3.5. On 12.09.2013, the appellant was arrested. It is the case of the prosecution that pursuant to his disclosure statement, the appellant led the police and panch witnesses to the spot and thereafter to his house at Yarabalu village, from where he produced a plastic bag kept in a trunk containing gold and silver ornaments. The said ornaments were seized under seizure mahazar in the presence of one Ashok, Mehaboob Basha (PW-12) and Venkatesh (PW-23) and were subsequently identified by the relatives of the dec

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top