SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Judicial Analysis Court Copy Headnote Facts Arguments Court observation
Listen Audio Icon Pause Audio Icon
judgment-img

2002 Supreme(AP) 1452

Andhra Pradesh High Court
Judges : B.S.REDDY
YEGITILA PANDU - Appellant
Versus
State OF A.P. - Respondent
Decided On : 12-19-02

Headnote:

Indian penal code - Sections 337 and 304-A – Criminal procedure code - Section 251 – Motor vehicle Act - Section 187 – Claim of compensation – Injury - Prosecution case in brief is as follows petitioner/accused was driver of apart bus bearing driver of tractor / trolley bearing at about - Tractor/trolley driven by I was proceeding towards – Held, In these circumstances rash and negligent driving of petitioner/accused cannot be inferred - In view of above reasons I find that it is not possible to accept findings of Courts below that petitioner/accused was driving the bus bearing in a rash negligent manner at time of accident - Appeal allowed

B. SESHASAYANA REDDY, J.

( 1 ) THIS criminal revision is directed against the judgment dated 13-2-2001 passed in Criminal Appeal No. 50 of 1999 on the file of the Sessions Judge, cuddapah, whereby the learned Sessions judge confirmed the conviction of the petitioner/accused for the offences under sections 337 and 304-A IPC, while modifying the sentence of imprisonment imposed for the offence under Section 337 ipc to fine and reducing the sentence of imprisonment for the offence under section 304-A IPC from 18 months to six months, passed in CC No. 38 of 1997 on the file of Judicial First Class Magistrate, badwel, Cuddapah.

( 2 ) THE prosecution case in brief is as follows: The petitioner/accused was driver of apsrtc bus bearing No. AP-9z-2990. P. W. 1 Kondareddi Venkatarami Reddy driver of the tractor / trolley bearing No. AP-04-T-4093/4094. On 1-3-1996 at about 6 a. m. the tractor/trolley driven by P. W. I was proceeding towards Siddavaram to danthalapalli. The tractor had a load of earth which was being carried to the fields of the owner of the tractor namely ramana Reddy, a journalist. Coolies were travelling on the trolley at that time. Deceased P. Kondaiah and deceased M. Thirupathiah, P. W. 2 T. Gurraiah, P. W. 3 mudium Santaiah, P. W. 4 Gin Anjaneyulu, p. W. 5 Katari Venkataiah, P. W. 6 Korivi peeraiah, P. W. 7 Nopuri Lakshmaiah p. W. 8 Tirupati Pedda Veeraiah were among the coolies travelling on the trolley. On reaching Chinna Naravagutta, the bus bearing No. AP-9z-2990 driven by the petitioner/accused came in high speed from opposite direction and dashed the front right side portion of the trolley and as a result the trolley went off the road and front tire disc of the trolley broke. P. Kondaiah and M. Thirupathaiah met with instantaneous death whereas P. Ws. l to 8 sustained injuries. P. W. 9 K. Subbamma who was travelling in the bus also sustained injuries. At about 8 a. m. P. W. I, driver of the tractor/trolley, took all the injured to porumamilla P. S. and presented. Ex. P-1 complaint before the SHO. P. W. 16 m. Prabhakar, Head Constable of porumamilla P. S. received Ex. P-1 complaint and registered a case in Cr. No. 12/96 under sections 337 and 304-A IPC and issued ex. P-11 FIR. He examined P. Ws. l to 5 and 8 and recorded their statements and sent the injured to Porumamilla Government hospital for treatment. He visited the scene of offence at 10 a. m. and conducted inquest on the dead bodies of P. Kondaiah and M. Thirupathaiah. After the inquest, the dead bodies were sent for post-mortem examination. P. W. 15 Dr. Muni Sekhar, medical Officer, Porumamilla examined p. Ws. 6 to 9 and L. W. 10 P. Ramaiah and issued Exs. P-5 to P-9 wound certificates. P. W. 17 Dr. S. K. Hussain, Civil Assistant surgeon, Cuddapah Government Hospital examined P. Ws. 2 to 5 and issued Ex. P-12 to 15 wound certificates. P. W. 15 conducted post-mortem examination on the dead body of deceased M. Tirupathaiah on 2-3-1996 at 10. 30 a. m. and issued Ex. P-10 postmortem report opining that the deceased died of injuries to vital organs like brain, lungs and bones. P. W. 18 S. Mahaboob basha, Circle Inspector of Police, Badvel took up investigation from P. W. 16 M. Prabhakar and examined P. W. 11 Pelluri ademma wife of deceased P. Kondaiah and P. W. 12 Mudium Venkatalakshumma wife of deceased M. Thirupathaiah and recorded their statements. He secured the presence of P. W. 10 Munam Anjaneyulu, conductor of the APSRTC bus bearing registration No. A. P. 9z 2990 and recorded his statement. The petitioner/accused surrendered himself on 1-3-1996 at 6. 30 p. m. before P. W. 18 who effected his arrest and produced him before the Court for being remanded to judicial custody. P. W. 18 sent requisition to the Motor Vehicle inspector to inspect the vehicles involved in the accident. After completing investigation p. W. 18 filed charge-sheet in the Court of judicial Magistrate of First Class, Badvel. The learned Magistrate took the charge-sheet on file as C.













Click Here to Read the rest of this document
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top