Andhra Pradesh High Court
Judges : V.ESWARAIAH
Mohd.Abdul Wahab - Appellant
Versus
State OF A.P. - Respondent
Decided On : 01-23-01
Motor Vehicles Act 1939 - Sections 8 7 (4) and 21-B – Transportation – Medical Certificate – Physical fitness certificate - Petitioners who is a Registered Medical Practitioner in Homeopathy and Unani filed this writ petition questioning notification issued by Government in Transport Roads and Buildings Department - It is stated that Transport used to accept Medical Certificates issued by any Registered Medical Practitioner such as petitioner even without possessing Degree or its equilant but after new came into force respondent has issued a notification declaring that Registered Medical Practitioners possessing in Allopathy or any equivalent qualification of any University in India alone are empowered to issue Medical Certificates for purpose of obtaining Learner and Conductor s Licence and thus it is submitted that when Authorities have been accepting Medical Certificate issued by Registered Medical Practitioners in Homeopathy and Unani and Allopathy there is no justification in issuing such a notification – Held Government Pleader further submits that to certify physical fitness to be given by applicant of Form I Registered Medical Practitioners with minimum quaification of in Allopathy alone are competent and qualified but Homeo and Unani Registered Medical Practitioners have no special qualification or any study in such course to issue such physical fitness certificates - with regard to applicants suffering from other ailments like hyper-tension epilepsy vision and/or colour blineness etc - Registered Medical Practitioners possessing minimum qualification in Allopathy alone can examine and certify as to whether a particular person is suffering from other ailments such as hyper-tension epilephsy vision and/or colour blindness and therefore ordinary Registered Medical Practitioners in Homeopathy and Unani have no special course to test and issue such medical certificates and therefore medical certificates issued by them cannot be accepted and therefore Government after having considered relevant factors issued notification - Petition dismissed.
( 1 ) HEARD the learned counsel for the petitioner and the learned Government Pleader for Transport.
( 2 ) THE petitioners, who is a Registered Medical Practitioner in Homeopathy and Unani, filed this writ petition questioning the notification issued by the Government in GO. Ms. No. 25, Transport, Roads and Buildings Department, dated 6-2-1992. It is stated that the Transport Authorities under the Old Motor Vehicles Act used to accept the Medical Certificates issued by any Registered Medical Practitioner, such as the petitioner, even without possessing the MBBS Degree or its equilant but after the new Motor Vehicles Act came into force, the 1st respondent has issued a notification in GO. Ms. No. 25, Transport, Roads and Buildings (Tr. II) Department, dated 6-2-1992 declaring that the Registered Medical Practitioners possessing the Degree of MBBS in Allopathy or any equivalent qualification of any University in India alone are empowered to issue Medical Certificates for the purpose of obtaining the Learner s Licence and Conductor s Licence, and thus, it is submitted that when the Authorities have been accepting the Medical Certificate issued by the Registered Medical Practitioners in Homeopathy and Unani and Allopathy, there is no justification in issuing such a notification. It is further stated that when the Transport Authorities started insisting upon the Medical Certificates to be issued by the Registered Medical Practitioners possessing the Degree of MBBS in Allopathy alone, W. P. Nos. 8668 of 1981 and 13017 of 1986 were filed, which were allowed on 14-4-1987 and 3-8-1987 respectively.
( 3 ) ADMITTEDLY, no notification has been issued by the State Goernment under Section 7 (4) and 21-B of the old Motor Vehicles Act, 1939, which are corresponding to Sections 8 (3) and 30 (3) of the new Motor Vehicles Act, 1988. The learned Government Pleader for Transport submits that as there is no notification issued by the Government in exercise of the powers under Ss. 7 (4) and 21-B of the old Motor Vehicles Act, 1939, the Transport Authorities used to accept the certificates issued by any Medical Practitioners irespective of qualification of MBBS in Allopathy; but it is submitted that in view of the notification issued u/ss. 8 (3) and 30 (3) of the Motor Vehilces Act, 1988 read with Rules 43 and 77 of the Andhra Pradesh Motor Vehilces Rules, 1989, it cannot be said that the said G. O. is illegal and arbitrary and without any authority of law.
( 4 ) THE learned Government Pleader further submits that to certify the physical fitness to be given by the applicant in Form (a) to (g) of Part-I and (a) to (c) under Part II of Form I, the Registered Medical Practitioners with the minimum quaification of MBBS in Allopathy alone are competent and qualified; but the Homeo and Unani Registered Medical Practitioners have no special qualification or any study in such course to issue such physical fitness certificates, i. e. with regard to the applicants suffering from other ailments like hyper-tension, epilepsy, vision and/or colour blineness etc. The Registered Medical Practitioners possessing the minimum qualification in MBBS in Allopathy alone can examine and certify as to whether a particular person is suffering from other ailments, such as, hyper-tension, epilephsy, vision and/or colour blindness, and therefore, ordinary Registered Medical Practitioners in Aurveda, Homeopathy and Unani have no special course to test and issue such medical certificates, and therefore, the medical certificates issued by them cannot be accepted, and therefore, the Government, after having considered the relevant factors, issued the notification.
( 5 ) IN view of the aforesaid reasoning, it cannot be said that the notification issued by the Government is illegal, arbitrary or without any authority of law, and I therefore, do no see any merit to set aside the same. The writ petition is accordingly dismissed. No costs. Petition dismissed.
SupremeToday
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.