Andhra Pradesh High Court
Judges : BILAL NAZKI, ELIPE DHARMA RAO
Sogra Begum - Appellant
Versus
State OF A.P. - Respondent
Decided On : 11-02-01
Urban Land Ceiling Act, 1979 - Section 27 - Income Tax Act - Sale deed – Certificates - Peaceful possession - Appeal filed by plaintiffs against judgment and decree passed by trial Court dismissing suit was filed for a declaration that plaintiffs were absolute owners and possessors of suit property measuring sq Yards which is part and parcel of house bearing - Property was declared evacuee property and it vested with Custodian of evacuee property and was taken over by Custodian - Custodian divided property into four parts and put it to auction - In auction a portion of the property measuring sq. yards bearing Municipal was purchased by an extent of sq yards was purchased by an extent of sq yards was purchased by and remaining portion of property sq. yards was purchased – Held, State Government may direct survey of Government land or of any boundary of such land - Survey of lands ordered has to be notified by survey officers - Then lays down that survey officer shall have power to determine and record as undisputed any boundary in respect of which no dispute is brought to his notice - lays down that notice of every decision of survey officer shall be given in prescribed manner to registered holders of lands boundaries of which may be affected by decisions - Appeal against orders can be made lays down that an appeal can be made within three months from date of service of notice - And finally completion of demarcation has to be notified a suit can be filed within three years to establish rights claimed in respect of boundary of property surveyed - In present case since there was no notice given to plaintiffs predecessor in interest has no application - Besides this factual background have been informed of judgment of a single Judge of this Court delivered - Appeal allowed
( 1 ) THIS is an appeal filed by the plaintiffs against the judgment and decree passed by the trial Court dismissing OS No. 1506 of 1993 on 14-8-1997. The suit was filed for a declaration that the plaintiffs were absolute owners and possessors of the suit property measuring 2318 sq. yards, which is part and parcel of house bearing No. 5-9-7/2, situated at Saifabad. They also sought perpetual injunction restraining the defendants 1 to 6 from interfering with their peaceful possession and enjoyment over the suit property.
( 2 ) THE facts leading to filing of the suit were that the suit property originally known as roshan Manzil was owned by one Sir Afsar-U1-Mulk who sold it to Feroz Shah in 1908. The said Feroz Shah sold it to Nawab Mohd. Yer-Jung in September, 1913. Nawab Jung died in 1942 and the total property measuring 15,105 sq. yards devolved on his heirs. Some of his heirs migrated to Pakistan at the time of partition. The property was declared evacuee property and it vested with the Custodian of the evacuee property and was taken over by the Custodian. The Custodian divided the property into four parts and put it to auction. In the auction a portion of the property measuring 4165 sq. yards bearing Municipal No. 5-9-7/2 was purchased by Mehabubimnisa Begum, an extent of 3958 sq. yards was purchased by Dr. Brij Raj, an extent of 682 sq. yards was purchased by Akbar Hussain Latif and the remaining portion of the property i. e. , 6300 sq. yards was purchased by Smt. Sofia Begum. In the said auction necessary sale certificates were issued by the competent officer to the respective purchasers and the purchasers were put in possession. The plaintiffs purchased the land from Mehbubunnisa Begum who had purchased 4165 sq. yards in the auction. The said Mehbubunnisa Begum remained in possession of the property till it was sold by her to the plaintiffs through sale deed dated 19-11-1979. Before the sale deed was executed, permission under Section 27 of Urban Land Ceiling Act, 1979 and clearance certificate under Section 230 (A) of the Income Tax Act were obtained. It is further stated in the plaint that the suit property was being managed and supervised by Mohammed Mohamood, the husband of the 1st plaintiff and GPA holder of both the plaintiffs. It is stated that the plaintiffs were enjoying the property. The plaintiffs vendor had leased out the suit premises to B. S. Venkat Ram and K. Rami Reddy, partners of Gopi Hotel, for running a hotel. After purchase of the property, the plaintiffs vendor filed eviction petition before the Principal Rent Controller being RC No. 72 of 1980 against the tenant, as a result the tenant vacated the suit premises and handed over the vacant possession to the plaintiffs on 25-4-1988. They levelled and developed the rear side open land of the suit premises into two blocks by getting boulders cut into pieces and investing amounts. When the plaintiffs were levelling the second block on the eastern end, the defendants 3 and 6 started illegal interference and created hurdles in the development of the property. They contended that the property was the Government land. The plaintiffs issued notices dated 13-10-1989 to the defendants 1 to 5 not to interfere with their peaceful possession and enjoyment of the suit property. The plaintiffs also requested the defendants to allow them to carry out necessary corrections in revenue records for recording the total extent of town survey No. 42, Ward No. 52, Block d as 3482 sq. metres as against wrong recording of 1544 sq. metres. Defendant No. 5 sent a reply on 5-12-1989. The Government never claimed the suit property as its own at any time either at the time of vesting or auctioning. Since the defendants made an attempt to interfere with the peaceful possession of the plaintiffs over the suit property which was sought to be justified on the basis of a town survey record, the plaintiffs filed a writ being WP No. 1021 of 1990 in the High Court. Th
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.