Andhra Pradesh High Court
Judges : BILAL NAZKI
M.Venkata Ramana - Appellant
Versus
Collector and District Register, Hyderabad Dist. - Respondent
Decided On : 03-23-98
( 1 ) RULE Nisi.
( 2 ) THE petitioner is a retired Deputy Director, Information and Public Relations Department, Government of A. P. He states that prior to his retirement from the Government service the petitioner applied the State Government in the year 1983 for allotment of a residential plot of land for construction of a house. The Government issued orders on 19-2-1987 directing the A. P. Housing Board to sell him a plot measuring 233. 33 Sq. yards at Santoshnagar Colony, Hyderabad at the rate of Rs. 600. 00 per Sq. yard. The petitioner felt that the value fixed at Rs. 600. 00 per Sq. yard was excessive. He challenged the fixation of price through Writ Petition No. 9575/87 before this Court. The Writ petition was disposed of on 10-6-1991. The Court held that the price fixed at Rs. 600. 00per Sq. yard was arbitrary and directed the respondents therein to re-fix the market value in the light of the basic value fixed by the Department of Registration for similar lands in the locality and also in accordance with the observations made in the order. The order of the Court was further clarified by another order on 8-7-1992 by which respondents therein were directed to fix the price as on 19-2-1987. Pursuant to the orders of the Court the Housing Board re-fixed the market value of the land at Rs. 400. 00 per Sq. yard. The petitioner again filed a Writ petition being W. P. No. 12070/93 again challenging the fixation of price at Rs. 400. 00per Sq. yard. In the meantime, the Government of A. P. issued a notice vide letter No. 1266/ HG. 2/93-II, dated 3-8-93 by which the petitioner was threatened that the allotment made in his favour will be cancelled as the petitioner had failed to pay the land cost and other charges payable by him. He was further informed that he was not entitled to claim the plot as a house had been purchased by his wife. The petitioner again filed another Writ petition being W. P. No. 13629/93. This Court passed interim orders staying cancellation of allotment. Thereafter both the petitions were heard and disposed of by learned single Judge by order dated 6-2-1997. The Writ Petition No. 13629/93 was allowed and the proposed action of the respondents to cancel the allotment was quashed. The Writ Petition No. 12070/93 was dismissed and it was held that the petitioner was bound to pay the cost of plot @ Rs. 400. 00per Sq. yard and also the other incidental charges that may be payable by him. He was granted three months time from the date of order to make the payment. After this order was passed, the A. P. Housing Board initiated action to collect interest upon the value of Rs-400/- per Sq. yard. The Court had not ordered payment of any interest. Therefore, the petitioner filed a contempt petition being C. C. No. 1214/97 questioning the action of the respondent Board in seeking to charge interest upon the value of the land. After the contempt was filed the A. P. Housing Board immediately withdrew its demand for interest. Accordingly the contempt case was closed on 17-9-97. The petitioner thereafter ultimately made the payment towards the Housing Board and presented the sale deed for registration before the Sub-Registrar, Azampura, Hyderabad for registration under the Registration Act. The petitioner has made payment of Rs. 12,021. 00towards stamp duty and registration fee. But, on presentation of the document before the Sub-Registrar the Sub-Registrar referred the document bearing P. No. 719/97 to the Collector and District Registrar, Hyderabad for determination of market value in terms of Section 47-A of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899. In pursuance of said reference the Collector and District Registrar issued notice under Section 47-A of the Indian Stamp Act on 24-9-97. The petitioner submitted his explanation on 25-9-97 taking objection that the price of the land was fixed by the Hon ble High Court and accordingly it was not open to any authority to revise the value of the land and enhance the stamp duty
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.