SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

1995 Supreme(AP) 69

Andhra Pradesh High Court
Judges : B.K.SOMASEKHARA
Daniel Padma Rao - Appellant
Versus
Heroid Earnest Lawrence Davey - Respondent
Decided On : 02-10-95

Important Points

No application under Section 5 of the Limitation Act is necessary to condone the delay in filing the application to set aside the ex parte decree. The Court is bound to examine the materials before it to be satisfied or otherwise about the sufficiency for such delay in filing the appeal petition etc.

Subject

Civil Law - Limitation Act

Act Referred

CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE : O.9 R.13, O.19 R.2, O.19 R.1
LIMITATION ACT : S.3, S.5, Art.123

Headnote

LIMITATION ACT - ARTICLE 123 - PERIOD OF LIMITATION FOR SETTING ASIDE EX PARTE DECREE - SECTION 5 - CONDONATION OF DELAY - NO APPLICATION NECESSARY - COURT TO EXAMINE MATERIALS TO BE SATISFIED ABOUT SUFFICIENT CAUSE - CIVIL RULES OF PRACTICE RULE 60 - PROOF OF FACTS BY AFFIDAVIT - COURT BOUND TO EXAMINE MATERIALS TO SATISFY OR NOT, WHETHER THERE WAS SUFFICIENT CAUSE FOR CONDONATION OF DELAY.

Fact of the Case:

Defendant was duly served with suit summons in O. S. No. 550of 1991. He engaged an Advocate to represent him. His Advocate filed the vakalat into the Court from him on 30-9-91. The case was adjourned from time to time to3-10-91,28-10-91 and 27-1-92 on which date neither the defendant nor his Advocate appeared in the Court and therefore, the suit was decreed ex parte. The defendant filed LA. 337/92 on 23-3-1992 to set aside the exparte decree.

Finding of the Court:

The period of limitation of 30 days to set aside the decree passed exparte began to run when the defendant as knowledge of the decree and not from the date of the decree and therefore, the learned trial Judge was not justified in holding that the application was barred by limitation.

Issues: 1. Whether the period of limitation of 30 days to set aside the decree passed exparte began to run when the defendant as knowledge of the decree and not from the date of the decree? 2. Whether the learned trial Judge was justified in holding that the application was barred by limitation?

Ratio Decidendi: 1. The period of limitation for filing an application under Order 9 Rule 13 of C. P. C. to set aside the decree passed exparte is 30 days from the date of the decree or the date of knowledge of the decree, whichever is later. 2. No application under Section 5 of the Limitation Act is necessary to condone the delay in filing the application to set aside the ex parte decree. The Court is bound to examine the materials before it to be satisfied or otherwise about the sufficiency for such delay in filing the appeal petition etc.

Final Decision: The appeal is allowed. The order of dismissal of I. A. No. 337/92 in O. S. No. 550/91 dated 30-4-1992 is set aside. The matter is remitted back to the trial court for disposal on merits according to law and in the light of the observations supra.

B. K. SOMASEKHARA, J.

( 1 ) THE Order of the learned First Additional Judge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad in LA. No. 337/92 in O. S. No. 550/91 dated 30-4-1992 dismissing it, is assailed in this appeal. It was filed under Order 9 Rule 13 of C. P. C. to set aside the exparte decree dated 27-1-1992 passed against the defendant-appellant. The respondent is the plaintiff who filed the suit and got the decree.

( 2 ) THE defendant was duly served with suit summons in O. S. No. 550of 1991. He engaged one Sri Reddi an Advocate to represent him. His Advocate filed the vakalat into the Court from him on 30-9-91. The case was adjourned from time to time to3-10-91,28-10-91 and 27-1-92 on which date neither the defendant nor his Advocate appeared in the Court and therefore, the suit wasdecreed ex parte. The defendant filed LA. 337/92 on 23-3-1992 to set aside the exparte decree.

( 3 ) IT was opposed by the plaintiff. The learned trial Judge held that the petition was barred by the period of limitation of 30 days prescribed under Article 123 of the Indian Limitation Act (hereinafter called the Act ). The contention that the period of limitation commenced from the date of knowledge of the decree which the defendant had, was rejected and since no application was filed under Section 5 of the Limitation Act to condone the delay, the petition to set aside the ex parte decree was dismissed for want of limitation. Consequently no find ing was given regarding the merits of the case namely, the sufficient cause sought to be shown by the defendant from appearing in the Court when the suit was called on for hearing.

( 4 ) NUMBER of grounds are raised in the appeal challenging the order of the learned trial Judge including the merits of LA. No. 337/92 and also the merits of the suit. However, to confine to the scope of this appeal, the learned Advocate as raised the following contentions in support of the relevant grounds in the appeal: (1) The period of limitation of 30 days to set aside the decree passed exparte began to run when the defendant as knowledge of the decree and not from the date of the decree and therefore, the learned trial Judge was not justified in holding that the application was barred by limitation. (2) Since the period of limitation to set aside the ex parte decree began to run when the defendant had the knowledge of the decree and since the petition was not barred by limitation, the learned Munsif was wrong in dismissing the petition on the ground that no application under Section 5 of the Act was filed to condone the delay. (3) The learned trial Judge was in error in not examining the cause on merits about the sufficient cause pleaded by the defendant to set aside the ex parte decree. Despite the defendant not filing any application to condone the delay in filing the petition to set aside the decree passed ex parte, the learned trial Judge was bound to cosider the materials on record to examine and hold whether there was sufficient cause to condone the delay in filing the petition. The order of the learned trial Judge is illegal and therefore, liable to be set aside.

( 5 ) AS against this, Mr. M. V. Suresh Kumar, the learned Advocate for the respondent-plaintiff has contended to the contrary and tried to support the order of the trial Judge. The first contention is squarely opposed to the known and settled law relating to the period of limitation fo r filing an application under Order 9 Rule 13 of C. P. C. to set aside the decree passed exparte. In Schedule III Division Part I Article 123 of the Limitation Act operates the law and rejects the first contention. To repeat: description of suits period of Limitation begins to run time from which period 123. To set aside a decree passed ex parte or to rehear an appeal decreed or heard ex parte thirty days (30 days) the date of the decree or whether the summons or notice was not duly served, when the applicant had knowledge of the decree simpliciter for an application to set aside a d














1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top