SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

1989 Supreme(AP) 425

Andhra Pradesh High Court
Manduri Raghava Rao - Appellant
Versus
Nadella Radba Krishna Murthy - Respondent
S.A.No.583/87
Decided On : 09-22-89
Advocates Appeared :
Mr. M. Chandrasekhar Rao,Mr. C.V.N. Sastry

Subject

Civil Law - Property Rights

Act Referred

ANDHRA PRADESH GRAM PANCHAYAT RAJ ACT : S.85, S.85(3)
CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE : O.1 R.13

Headnote

CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE, Order 1, Rule 13 - AP GRAM PANCHAVAT ACT, Sec 85 - Plaintiff filed suit for declaration of their customary rights in a tank, against the defendants who are interfering their enjoyment - Neither Government nor Panchayat issued Notification under Sec 85 (3) nor caused any obstruction to plaintiff s enjoyment - Government or Panchayat are not necessary parties to the suit Distinction between necessary parties and proper parties-Stated Waiver contemplated under Rule 13 of Order 1, applies only to cases where proper parties are not implead to a suit

       Held : There is a distinction between proper parties and necessary parties and the waiver contemplated under Or 1, Rule 13 applies to a case where proper parties have not been impleaded and does not apply to non-joinder of necessary parties In the latter case, the Suit itself is defective and no relief can be granted

       In this case, the plaintiffs claiming a customary right of user, filed the suit against the defendants, who were interfering with the said right They have no grievance against any other persons other than the defendants for no one interfered with their rights It is not the duty of the person asserting that right to make all possible claimants as parties Whether he acquired such a right would be decided in the suit If the defendants intended to raise a plea of "Jus Terti" it is always open to him to apply for making the third party a party to the suit The plaintiff is not asking any relief against the Government or the Panchayat In these circumstances, it is manifest that neither the Government nor the Panchayat are necessary parties to the suit

K. AMARESWARI, J.

( 1 ) PLAINTIFFS are the appellants. The four plaintiffs filed the suit representing themselves and also representing the entire Harijans of kalasamalapalli.

( 2 ) THEY filed the suit for a declaration that the villagers of Kalasamalapallihave got customary right of user in respect of the tank called gottipativari Cheruvu situate at one furlong from Kalasamalapalli. The tank is an extent of 4 acres 93 cents and the plaintiffs case is that they have been using the said tank for washing purposes and for feeding their cattle by drinking water in the tank during summer season and neither the government nor the Panchayat can deprive them of their right and the defendants have no manner of right, title or interest. They also sought for a permanent injuction restraining the defendants from interfering with the enjoyment of the suit tank.

( 3 ) THE defendants resisted the suit contending that the allegationthat the plaintiffs have been using the tank for washing clothes and for feeding their cattle is incorrect, that the suit property is not a tank, that the needs of the residents of Kalasamalapalli are served by another channel known as Karuvu Kaluva, that the tank has become defunct and ceased to be a tank, that the Revenue Authorities issued a patta to the 1st defendant in respect of 2 acres 43 cents and to the 2nd defendant for 2 acres 50 cents in 1975, that the 1st defendant is working in the Army and the 2nd defendant is working in the Indian Air Force and when the plaintiffs sought to repair the bunds the Defendants obstructed them without any right, title or interest.

( 4 ) THE trial Court found that the residents of Kalasamalapalli havebeen enjoying the suit tank since times immemorial and they have acquired communal rights over the tank. The trial Court further found that the panchayat or Government cannot interfere with the communal rights of the plaintiffs and that the defendants have no valid title. On these findings, the suit was decreed.

( 5 ) THE defendants carried the matter in appeal. The Appellatejudge had confirmed all the findings of the trial Court. The Appellate court found in para 27 of the judgment that the suit tank is a communal tank and that the inhabitants of Kalasamalapalli have got customary rights to use the water of the suit tank for their cattle and for washing clothes and they are entitled to have the same protected by the issuance of injunction. However, the Appellate Judge dismissed the suit on the sole ground that the panchayat and the Government are necessary parties and since they have not been impleaded as defendants, the suit is liable to be dismissed. On this finding, the Appellate Judge dismissed the suit.

( 6 ) IN this Second Appeal, the. main contention of Mr. M. Chandrasekhararao, the learned Counsel for the appellants is that the finding of the Appellate Judge that the Panchayat and Government are necessary parties is grossly erroneous and in any event, the defendants cannot be permitted to raise the. question of non-joinder of parties at the appellate stage for the first time, and they must be deemed to have waived their right in view of Rule 13 of Order 1 C. P. C.

( 7 ) ON the other hand, it is submitted by Mr. C. V. N, Sastry, thelearned Counsel for the respondents-defendants that Order 1 Rule 13 C. P. C. has no application to a case where necessary parties have not been impleaded and the waiver contemplated under Order 1 Rule 13 C. P. C. applies to a situation where proper parties have not been joined.

( 8 ) THE undisputed facts are that no objection was raised by thedefendants either in the written statement or at the time of arguments in the trial Court or in the Memorandum of grounds of appeal that the suit should fail for non-joinder of the Panchayat and the Government and that they are necessary parties. This argument was advanced at the time of hearing of the appeal in the lower appellate Court.

( 9 ) ORDER I Rule 13 C. P. C. , reads as follows :"13. All obje























1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top