SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

1975 Supreme(AP) 132

Andhra Pradesh High Court
Judges : K.RAMACHANDRA RAO
P.Venkatadri Sastri - Appellant
Versus
Sardar Kesara Singh - Respondent
Decided On : 08-04-75

Important Points

Contingent fees, i.e. fees payable to the plaintiff's lawyers only if the plaintiff were successful in the proceedings, are unlawful by the law of India on the ground that they are contrary to public policy.

Subject

Contract Law - ADVOCATE AND CLIENT

Headnote

LEGAL FEES - CONTINGENT FEE - ADVOCATE AND CLIENT - BAR COUNCIL RULES - RULE 20 - PUBLIC POLICY - UNENFORCEABLE AGREEMENT - RECOVERY OF FEES.

Fact of the Case:

Plaintiff, an advocate, sued the defendant, a former Deputy Superintendent of Police, for recovery of Rs. 5000/- as legal fees allegedly agreed to be paid by the defendant for conducting a suit on his behalf. The defendant contended that he agreed to pay only Rs. 500/- and that the plaintiff had filed a fee certificate for Rs. 500/-.

Finding of the Court:

The court found that the plaintiff had filed a fee certificate for Rs. 500/- and that the defendant had not paid any fee either to the plaintiff or to his junior counsel. The court also found that the plaintiff had not proved that the defendant had agreed to pay Rs. 5000/- towards fee.

Issues: 1. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to claim the sum of Rs. 5000/- as fees for conducting the suit. 2. Whether the fixation of contingent fee is opposed to the Bar Council rules and public policy.

Ratio Decidendi: 1. The court held that the plaintiff's claim for recovery of Rs. 5000/- is not enforceable as it is contingent upon the success of the defendant in the suit, which is contrary to Rule 20 of the Bar Council of India Rules and public policy. 2. The court also held that the plaintiff's claim is not enforceable as he had filed a fee certificate for Rs. 500/- and had not proved that the defendant had agreed to pay Rs. 5000/- towards fee.

Final Decision: The court dismissed the plaintiff's appeal and upheld the lower court's decision to decree the suit for Rs. 500/- with interest.

K. RAMACHANDRA RAO, J.

( 1 ) THE plaintiff is the appellant. He filed the suit against the defendant- respondent for recovery of a sum of Rs. 5000/- towards legal fees alleged to have been agreed to be paid by the defendant,

( 2 ) THE trial Court decreed the suit for Rs. 500/- with interest thereon at 6% per annum from 6-10-1969 with proportionate costs and dismissed the suit in other respects with proportionate costs hence the appeal.

( 3 ) THE defendant who was working as Deputy Superintendent of Police under the Government of Andhra Pradesh, was dismissed from service. He then filed the suit O. S. No. 40/1964 on the file of the First Additional Chief Judge s Court city Civil Court, Hyderabad in forma pauperis for damages valuing the suit at Rs 89,866-87 ps. it was originally filed as a pauper suit and taken on file as 0. P. No, 153/1954. The Plaintiff s case is that the defendant approached him and engaged him to conduct the entire suit and that the defendant agreed to pay him a fee of Rs, 5000/ -. On the other hand, it is the defendant s case that he agreed to pay only Rs, 500/- and that actually the plaintiff filed a fee certificate ex. A-4 on 29. 6. 1964 for Rs. 500/- and therefore he would not be entitled to claim anything more than Rs, 500/ -.

( 4 ) THE defendant contended that actually he engaged Sri B V. Subbarayudu to conduct the case, that, the plaintiff was working in the office of Sri B. V. Subbarayudu and that Sri Subbarayudu. himself filed the vakalat and conducted the case along with his juniors Sri. Kameswara rao and Sri Appa Rao.

( 5 ) THE Plaintiff on the other hand contended that though Sri B. V. Subbarayudu, filed his vakalat, it was the plaintiff that conducted the entire suit, that the suit was his exclusive brief and that he alone could be entitled to the fee of Rs. 5000/- which the defendant agreed to pay.

( 6 ) THE plaintiff examined himself as P. W. I and the learned Government pleader who appeared in the suit O S, no. 40/1964 as P. W. 2 whereas the defendant examined four witnesses d. Ws. I to 4. Sri P. Kameswara Rao junior of Sri B. V. Subbarayudu, was examined as C. W. I.

( 7 ) IT was contended before the lower court that Ex. A-4 was typed by the defendant after obtaining the signature of the plaintiff on a blank paper and smuggled into the court records, that the plaintiff gave a manuscript written in his own hand, that the fees payable was rs. 5000/- and that the defendant got it wrongly typed as Rs. 500/ -. But this version of the plaintiff was not believed by the lower court, f am also not inclined to accept this version because Ex. A-4 is a typed document containing the signature of the plaintiff. It is not possible to believe that, an advocate of the standing of the plaintiff, would nave given a blank paper signed by him, especially when the document to be filed, was a fee certificate. The learned counsel for the appellant could not successfully challenge this finding of the Court below that Ex. A-4 was filed by the plaintiff, if Ex. A-4 was a trua certificate filed by the plaintiff himself, it is not possible to accept his case that the defendant agretd to pay him rs. 5000/- as fees. Moreover, it is Sri b. V. Subbarayudu, that issued the suit notice and also filed his vakalat at a later stage. It appears from the record and it is found by the lower Court that it is the plaintiff alone that conducted the suit. It is also found by the lower court that sri Subbarayudu was giving instructions in the matter and making corrections in the notes of arguments and was present in court when the suit was going on. Whether it is Sri B. V. Subbarayudu. that was to conduct the case or whether it was the plaintiff, the question for consideration is whether the plaintiff is entitled 10 claim the sum of Rs. 5000/- as fees for conducting the suit. On this aspect, Ex, A-4 the fee certificate clearly negatives the plaintiff s case that the fees agreed was rs. 5000/- Apart from the aforesaid factual finding, ther






1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top