( 1 ) THIS Writ Apeal is directed against the order of Gopalakrishna Nair, J. in W. P. No. 212 of 1964. The third respondent in the Writ petition is the Appellant.

( 2 ) THE dispute in the appeal relates to the permit of a stage carriage MDV 1947 which was subsequently renumbered as A. P. V. 482, which belonged to the Motor Works Union of Bheemunipatnam in Visakhapatnam District, which is the third respondent appellant, one Babulal, claiming to but a member of the Union, purported to have sold the vehicle to the first respondent in the appeal (petitioner in the writ petition ). The first respondent and a person by name J. V. Ramanaiah, who purported to be the Secretary of the Union filed in 1958, a joint application to the Regional Transport Authority, Visakhapatnam, for the stage carriage to the 1st respondent (the petitioner ). That application was notified by the Regional Transport Authority calling for objections. The appellant Union, represented by its Secretary, K. Ramanaiah, (different from J. V. Ramamaiah) who signed the Joint application for transfer filed its objections raised are Babulal had no right to sell the stage carriage belonging to the Union, th