SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2006 Supreme(AP) 841

2006(3) L.S. 22
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE ANDHRA PRADESH : : AT HYDERABAD
Present:
The Hon’ble Dr.Justice
G. Yethirajulu
M/s. Narne Estates Pvt.
Ltd., & Ors., Sec’bad ..Petitioners
Vs.
Dr.E. Surender Rao
& Anr., Nizamabad ..Respondents
Crl.P.No.5623/05 Date:26-7-2006
Mr.Koneti Raja Reddy, Advocate for the Petitioners.
Public Prosecutor for Respondent No.2.

Subject

Criminal Law - Breach of Trust and Cheating

Act Referred

CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE : S.482
INDIAN PENAL CODE : S.420, S.406

Headnote

INDIAN PENAL CODE, Secs.406 & 420 - CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE, Sec.482 - Quashing of FIR - Petitioner/accused/Company agreed to sell plot to respondent/complainant on condition of payment of consideration in instalments - Allotment of plot cancelled on ground of default in payment of instalments - Subsequently, on payment of arrears of instalments by respondent/complainant, restored allotment but altered plot - Hence complaint for alleged breach of trust and cheating.

        Unless there is fraudulent intention or breach of trust with mens rea, a criminal prosecution cannot be maintained though it may amount to civil wrong - In present case, from inception respondent/complainant does not plead that accused had any fraudulent intention to defraud him to part with money - Prima facie, it disclosed that complainant himself failed to pay instalments as per agreement - As there is no prima facie material in complaint to attract ingredients of Sec.406 or 420 IPC, continuation of investigation would lead to unnecessary exercise and hardship to accused - FIR, quashed - Criminal petition, allowed.

       

O R D E R


This Criminal Petition is filed by the accused in F.I.R.No.21 of 2005 on the file I Town Police Station, Nizamabad to quash the proceedings against him in the said crime.

2. The crime was registered for the offences under Sections 406 and 420 of I.P.C. against the petitioners. The first petitioner is Messers Narne Estates Private Limited, the second petitioner is the Managing Director and the third petitioner is the Vice President of the first petitioner company. The accused floated a scheme called Golden Heights Plots. Those who have subscribed Rs.1,00,000/- became the members of the said scheme. Under the said scheme, plots will be allotted to the members to an extent of 500 square yards each for a total consideration of Rs.4,80,000/-. Rs.1,00,000/- has to be paid initially and thereafter Rs.10,560/- has to be paid for 35 months and in the 36th month a sum of Rs.10,000/- has to be paid.

3.The complainant alleged that the company agreed to sell plot No.323 and represented that they would arrange a loan, but failed to arrange the same, therefore, he started paying installments @ Rs.5,000/- per month from August, 2003. The accused through the letter dated 13-03-2004 cancelled the allotment of the plot on the ground of default in payment of instalments for more than six months. On further correspondence, the accused through the letter 17-06-2004 agreed to restore the plot on payment of Rs.2 27,415/- by 25-06-2004. He paid Rs.1,96,760/- on 19-06-2004 towards arrears of instalments. By a letter dated 05-07-2004, the company restored the plot with an understanding that arrears would be cleared by 25-07-2004. The company also reduced the interest to 15% per annum. The interest was paid by him on 24-07-2004. However the company through its letter dated 21-08-2004 unilaterally changed the plot to GH-335 in the place of 323. The company sent a letter dated 09-09-2004 that the complainant accepted for change of plot. The company restored the allotment and thereafter altered the plot and as such the Managing Director, Vice President and the Directors have committed breach of trust and cheated him. Accordingly a report was given and a complaint was registered as F.I.R.No.21 of 2005 of Nizamabad Town P.S.

4. The learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that the complainant has become one of the members of the scheme and he was allotted a plot bearing No.323, but he failed to pay the instalments for a period of 10 months and the arrears of instalments counted to Rs.1,25,000/-. Under the above circumstances, the company has no option other than to get cancel the allotment and to return the amount as per the terms of Clause 17 of the agreement.

5.As the complainant brought recommendation, the company was willing to give a plot to him, but he again failed to pay the instalments regularly as stipulated by the company, therefore, the earlier allotment stood cancelled. The company changed the allotment of plot to GH-335 instead of 323. The company also raised a dispute with regard to the total amount of dues and sought for fresh settlement of account. By the letter dated 27-08-2004, the company stated that after cancellation of the plot, it was allotted to another person and he was given alternative plot. If he is not willing to take the alternative plot, he may take back his amount by intimating the same to the company. When the complainant got issued a legal notice, the company again issued a letter dated 03-11-2004 renewing the offer made by the letter dated 27-08-2004 failing which the allotment automatically gets cancelled in terms of clause 17 of Membership conditions. The complainant came along with two persons to the office of the company on 01-01-2005 and used unparliamentary language and tried to assault the Chairman. The same was intimated to the P.S., Karkhana. On 03-01-2005, the entire amount paid by the complainant was sent to him by way of cheques along with a covering letter. The complainant accepted the amount




























1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top