IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH AT HYDERABAD
M. Seetharama Murti, J.
The New India Assurance Company Limited – Appellant
Vs.
Srikantha – Respondent
Civil Revision Petition No. 2380 of 2012
Decided On : 22.04.2014
Motor Vehicles Act, Section 163 – A - Accidents – Claim of compensation - Revision petition is directed against order correctness or otherwise of income tax deducted at source position of law and correct procedure that ought to be followed by Insurance Company at time of deduction of tax at source from amount of compensation/interest awarded to claimants by Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal provisions of Motor Vehicles Act - consideration for disposal of present revision petition and relevant exposition of law - Claim petition filed by claimants/Decree Holders was allowed by Tribunal and compensation was awarded to claimants - They had filed execution petition for realization of awarded amount of interest and costs by attachment and sale of execution petition schedule movable properties of Judgment debtor - New India Assurance Company/Judgment Debtor/Revision Petitioner had deposited certain amount towards part satisfaction of awarded compensation amount with interest and costs to credit of Original Petition before Tribunal said amounts were withdrawn by claimants/decree holders - Claimants/decree holders filed their calculation memo – Held, It is not clear from record as to how Tax Deductible at Source was arrived at and deducted – However at this stage it cannot be said that insurance company is not entitled to deduct income tax at source on interest amount without first ascertaining whether interest amount in case of each of claimants had exceeded prescribed limit or not - Therefore as rightly urged by counsel for revision petitioner this Court is of the well-considered view that this is a fit case to set aside orders of the tribunal and remit matter to tribunal to decide afresh on requirement if any and correctness or otherwise of amount deducted at source towards income tax and then dispose of execution petition in accordance with procedure established by law - Petition allowed (Para 7)
M. Seetharama Murti, J.
1. This revision petition is directed against the order dated 15.04.2011 passed by the learned First Additional District Judge-cum-Chairman, Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Adilabad ('the Tribunal', for short) in E.P. 4 of 2010 in M.V.O.P. No. 135 of 1994. The issues involved in the revision are as follows: (1) Adjustment and appropriation of payments towards costs, interests and principal; and (2) The correctness or otherwise of the income tax deducted [or to be deducted] at source, the position of law and the correct procedure that ought to be followed by the Insurance Company at the time of the deduction of tax at source from the amount of compensation/interest awarded to the claimants by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal under the provisions of the Motor Vehicles Act.
2. The facts necessary for consideration for the disposal of the present revision petition and the relevant exposition of law, in brief, are as follows: "The claim petition filed by the claimants/Decree Holders was allowed by the Tribunal and compensation was awarded to the claimants. They had filed the execution petition for realisation of the awarded amount of Rs. 3,17,000/- and interest and costs by attachment and sale of execution petition schedule movable properties of the Judgment debtor. The New India Assurance Company/Judgment Debtor/Revision Petitioner herein had deposited certain amount towards part satisfaction of the awarded compensation amount with interest and costs to the credit of the Original Petition before the Tribunal. The said amounts were withdrawn by the claimants/decree holders. The Claimants/decree holders filed their calculation memo. The Judgment debtor had also filed a memo and contended that the entire amount was deposited towards full satisfaction of the award long time back. However, the Insurance Company had deducted certain sum towards Income Tax Deductible at Source ('TDS' for short). However, the Decree Holders/claimants had disputed inter alia such tax deduction at source as contrary to Law and incorrect and claimed that the said deducted amount as still due from the judgment debtor. The Tribunal had accepted the adjustment of the amounts deposited as shown by the decree holders as correct and proper as on that particular date and had held that the claimants/decree holders are further entitled to the execution petition amount and granted time to the Judgment Debtor for the deposit of the said amount and the amount that became due thereafter. Aggrieved of the orders of the Tribunal, the Assurance Company had preferred the present Revision Petition.
3. I have heard the submissions of the learned counsel for the revision petitioner/Insurance Company and the claimants/decree holders.
4. Now, the first question is about the proper manner in which the amount deposited by the Judgment debtor is to be adjusted and appropriated towards the amount due under the decree/award. This question need not detain this Court for long as the position is well settled. The execution petition claim as per the award and decree consists of claims towards interest on the principal amount of compensation awarded, costs and the principal amount of compensation. Admittedly the judgment debtor made certain payments towards the amount due under the award and the decree. There is admittedly no direction in the award and decree regarding the manner of appropriation of the part-payments/payments towards principal/interest/costs. In M/s Industrial Credit and Development Syndicate (ICDS) Ltd., vs. Smt. Smithaben H. Patel and others AIR 1999 SC 1036 the Hon'ble Supreme Court held as under:
16. In view of what has been noticed hereinabove, we hold that the general rule of appropriation of payments towards a decretal amount is that such an amount is to be adjusted firstly strictly in accordance with the directions contained in the decree and in the absence of such direction, adjustments, be made firstly in payment of interest and cost
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.