2014 Supreme(Kar) 247
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE
MOHAN .M. SHANTANAGOUDAR, J.
N.SRINIVAS S/O LATE NARAYANAPPA - Appellant
Versus
V.NARAYANASWAMY S/O VENKATARAYAPPA - Respondent
MFA NO.2071/2014 (CPC)
Decided on: 18.3.2014
Subject
Election Law - Municipal Election
Act Referred
CONSTITUTION OF INDIA : Art.243(q), Art.243(w)
KARNATAKA MUNICIPALITIES ACT : S.27, S.25, S.24
Headnote
Advocate Appeared
For the Appellant: (BY SRI.NANJUNDA REDDY, SR. COUNSEL FOR SRI.NISHANTH.A.V., ADV.)
For the Respondent: (BY SRI.P.S.RAJAGOPAL, SR. COUNSEL FOR SRI.B.M.IRSHAD AHMED, ADV., FOR R2, SRI.VIJAYA RAGHAVA SARATHY, ADV., FOR R1 NOTICE TO R3 – DISPENSED WITH V/O DT.18.3.14)
The order passed by the Election Tribunal/Senior Civil Judge, Chickballapur in E.Misc.No.9/2013 on IA.No.2 is called in question in this appeal.
2. Records reveal that the appellant herein was declared elected as Municipal Councilor of City Municipal Council, Chickballapur (Ward No.30). The election of the appellant is questioned by a voter respondent No.1 herein in E.Misc.No.9/13 in the Court of Senior Civil Judge, Chikkaballapur. In the said Election Petition, application came to be filed by the 1st respondent herein under Order 39 Rules 1 and 2 of Code of Civil Procedure praying for an order of injunction restraining the appellant herein from casting his vote in the ensuing election of President and Vice President of City Municipal Council, Chickballapur. The election is scheduled to be held on 19.03.2014 at 1.00 p.m. The said application came to be allowed, after hearing both the parties, by the impugned order. Consequently, appellant is restrained from casting his vote in the ensuing election of President and Vice President of City Municipal Council, Chickballapur.
3. Sri.Nanjunda Reddy, learned senior advocate for the appellant submits that the impugned order is bad in law inasmuch as it does not assign any reason much less valid reason; that the Election representative cannot be restrained from performing his normal duties as elected member of the Municipal Council; consequently, appellant cannot be restrained from casting his vote also.
He relies upon the judgments of this Court in W.P.No.39405/2013 disposed of on 6th March 2014 in the case of SMT.DEVI VS. SMT.LATH AND OTHERS, in the case of P.SIDDANNA VS. ZILLA PARISHAD, BELLARY AND OTHERS [1991 (4) KAR.L.J. 451], in the case of MAHADEV JYOTI UMRANI VS. SMT.SUMITRA [ILR 2004 KAR 512] and in the case of VINAYKUMAR SOORINJE AND ANR. VS. THE RETURNING OFFICER/TAHSILDAR MANGALORE AND ORS [ILR 2005 KAR 4835] in support of his contentions, that, the elected member cannot be prohibited to perform his normal duties including to cast his vote in the ensuing election of President and Vice President of City Municipal Council, Chickballapur
Sri.P.S.Rajagopal, learned senior advocate appearing on behalf of respondents 1 and 2 opposes the appeal by contending that the appeal itself is not maintainable inasmuch as no appeal is provided under Karnataka Municipalities Act as against the interim order passed by the Senior Civil Judge, Chickballapur/Election Tribunal; the Court below on viewing the CD produced before it and being satisfied about the fraud committed by the Tahsildar to help the appellant, has granted the order of injunction. He further submits that there is no bar for the Election Tribunal to grant the interim order of injunction particularly when Section 24 of the Karnataka Municipalities Act specifies that the provision of Code of Civil Procedure shall be followed by the Election Tribunal.
4) Section 24, 25 and 27 of the Karnataka Municipalities Act reads as under:
“24. Procedure to be followed by the Election Tribunal.—The procedure provided in the Code of Civil Procedure,1908, in regard to suits shall be followed by the Election Tribunal as far as it can be made applicable, in the trial and disposal of an election petition under this Act.
25. Decision of the Election Tribunal.—(1) At the conclusion of the trial of an election petition, the Election Tribunal shall make an order,—
(a) dismissing the election petition; or
(b) declaring the election of all or any of the returned candidates to be void; or
(c) declaring the election of all or any of the returned candidates to be void and the petitioner or any other candidate to have been duly elected.
(2) If any person who has filed an election petition has in addition to calling in question the election of the returned candidate, claimed declaration that he himself or any other candidate has been duly elected and the Election Tribunal is of opinion,—
(a) that in fact the petitioner or such other candidate receive