2001 Supreme(Kar) 822
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE
K. Sreedhar Rao, J.
Swetha Education Society —Appellant
Vs.
Sri K. Ramanna —Respondent
Regular First Appeal Nos. 345 and 346 of 2000
Decided on : 30-05-2001
Important Points
Subject
Civil Law - Dispute Resolution
Act Referred
Headnote
Maintainability - Dispute over School Management - Order 39, Rules 1 and 2 Code of Civil Procedure - O.S. No. 249 of 1999, O.S. No. 4994 of 1999 - Order 14, Rule 5 Code of Civil Procedure
Fact of the Case:
Dispute over the management of a school run by Shwetha Education Society, involving claims of authority and rights to manage the school premises. Plaintiff filed suits seeking injunction against interference with school operations and possession of the school building. Trial Court rejected the applications for temporary injunction and dismissed the suits, finding the Plaintiff's claim of authority to be not maintainable.
Finding of the Court:
The trial Court acted hastily in dismissing the suit without giving proper opportunity to the parties concerned. The dismissal of the suit is set aside and the matters are remitted to the trial Court for disposal in accordance with law. The trial Court is directed to dispose of the suit within one year.
Issues: Dispute over authority and rights to manage the school premises, maintainability of the suit, and the trial Court's hasty dismissal of the suit without proper opportunity for the parties to address the issue of maintainability.
Ratio Decidendi: The trial Court should have considered and disposed of the question of maintainability separately and independently, and acted hastily in dismissing the suit without proper opportunity for the parties to address the issue of maintainability.
Final Decision: The dismissal of the suit is set aside and the matters are remitted to the trial Court for disposal in accordance with law. The trial Court is directed to dispose of the suit within one year.
Advocate Appeared:
Mr. P.B. Raju, for the Appellant
Mr. Vasanthi Associates, Lingappa, for the Respondent
K. Sreedhar Rao, J.—The two appeals arise out of O.S. No. 249 of 1999 as O.S. No. 4994 of 1999 on the file of the 7th Additional City Civil Judge, Bangalore.
2. The appellant is the Plaintiff in both the suits. O.S. 249 of 1999 is filed for permanent injunction against the second Respondent herein seeking permanent injunction not to interfere with the running of the school. The second Respondent is none other than the brother-in-law of the appellant.
3. From the facts in O.S. 249 of 1999 it discloses that a Society was registered under the name of Shwetha Education Society which undertook to run a school by name Kannada and English Primary and High School. There was a dispute regarding the claim of the Plaintiff that he is the Secretary of the said Society which was challenged by the second Respondent.
4. In O.S. No. 4994 of 1999 the appellant filed the suit seeking injunction against the Respondents herein not to interfere with the peaceful possession and enjoyment of the suit property which consists of the school building. In both the suits, an application was filed under Order 39, Rules 1 and 2 Code of Civil Procedure for grant of temporary injunction. The applications in both the suits were heard and disposed of by a common order. The prayer for grant of temporary injunction is rejected. It was also held by the trial Court that the suit is not maintainable, accordingly, dismissed the I. As. and as well the suits. Being aggrieved by the said order, the present appeals are filed.
5. The trial Court finds that the leased premises in which the school is run belongs to the Shwetha Education Society. The Plaintiff-appellant without competent authority or authorisation from the Society has instituted the suit and thus holds that the suit filed by the Plaintiff is not maintainable.
6. The grievance of the first Respondent in the appeal is that the rents of the leased premises is not being paid to him despite the directions given by this Court.
7. On hearing the Counsel for the appellant and the Respondent, the crux of the dispute in both the suits appears to project in the following way.
8. The Plaintiff claims that he is the Secretary of the Society and has a right to manage the school. The said assertion is challenged by the second Respondent contending that the Plaintiff is not the Secretary and he has no right to manage the school. On the other hand, the Defendant contends that he has right to manage the school.
9. In Original Suit No. 4994 of 1999, the Plaintiff's contention is that the suit schedule property is taken on lease individually in the name of Plaintiff and he has permitted the Shwetha Education Society to run the school. It is further contended that after the disputes arose, the school run by Shwetha Education Society is shifted to some other place and in the said premises a different school is run by name Poorna Pragathi School by a different society. This assertion is seriously challenged by the second Respondent. It is the contention of the Respondents that the premises is leased in favour of Shwetha Education Society and that the Plaintiff has no individual or personal interest in the lease, as such it is their contention that in the absence of proper authorisation given by the Shwetha Education Society, the suit filed by the Plaintiff is not maintainable. The trial Court while considering the question of grant of temporary injunction in detail gone into the rival contentions with regard to the management of the school and incidentally finds that the lease is executed in favour of Shwetha Education Society thus holds that the Plaintiff, in the absence of proper authorisation given by Shwetha Education Society is not competent to file the suit, accordingly dismissed the applications filed for temporary injunction and as well the suits.
10. In the present appeals, the question that precisely arise for consideration would be the propriety of the trial Court for dismissing the suit on the ground of maintainability