2015 Supreme(Kar) 844
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
S. Sujatha, J.
Ananda Kumar Appu Magadum - Appellant
Vs.
Keshav Tukaram Badiger And Others - Respondents
Regular Second Appeal No. 614 of 2004
Decided On : 2.6.2015
Important Points
Subject
Civil Law - Contract Law
Act Referred
Headnote
Legal Fees - Agreement - 20-8-1988 - O.S. No. 664 of 1995 - Recovery of Rs. 43,835/- - LAC No. 50/89 - MFA No. 1871 of 1990 - SLP No. 22754 of 1994 - High Court of Karnataka - Apex Court - AIR 1954 SC 557
Fact of the Case:
The plaintiff filed O.S. No. 664 of 1995 for recovery of Rs. 43,835/- from the defendants and for an injunction restraining the defendants from withdrawing the compensation amount deposited in C.C.D. No. 17. The Trial Court partly decreed the suit, but the First Appellate Court set aside the judgment and decree, leading to the plaintiff's appeal.
Finding of the Court:
The Court found that the plaintiff failed to prove the execution of the agreement for legal fees (Ex. P. 3) and that the First Appellate Court was right in reversing the judgment and decree of the Trial Court.
Issues: The issues included the plaintiff's entitlement to legal fees, the validity of the agreement (Ex. P. 3), and the defendants' denial of the agreement.
Ratio Decidendi: The Court held that the plaintiff failed to prove the execution of the agreement for legal fees and that the First Appellate Court was correct in setting aside the judgment and decree of the Trial Court.
Final Decision: The Court dismissed the plaintiff's appeal, affirming the decision of the First Appellate Court.
For the Appellants :Bahubali A. Danawade, Advocate.
For the Respondent Nos. 1 to 3:Hema Lekha for Sri G. Balakrishna Shastry, Advocates.
This is the plaintiff's appeal challenging the order passed by the District Judge, Dharwad in R.A. No. 206 of 2003, dated 13-4-2004.
2. The brief facts of the case are that the plaintiff filed O.S. No. 664 of 1995 for recovery of Rs. 43,835/- from the defendants and also for consequential relief of injunction restraining the defendants from withdrawing the compensation amount deposited in C.C.D. No. 17, dated 26-8-1995 of the Principal Civil Judge, Chikkodi. The respondents/defendants appeared and denied the claim of the appellant/plaintiff. Written statement were filed. Plaintiff examined one witness as P.W. 1 and Exs. P. 1 to P. 8 were marked. Ex. D. 2 was examined as a witness and Ex. D. 1 was marked.
The Trial Court framed the following issues:
1. Whether the plaintiff proves that the defendants have agreed to pay the fee of Rs. 35,000/- for conducting the LAC No. 50/89 pending before the Civil Judge Court, Chikkodi and executed an agreement to that effect as on 20-8-1988?
2. Whether the plaintiff proves that, the defendants are liable to pay the Advocate fee of High Court of Karnataka in MFA No. 1871 of 1990 and SLP No. 22754 of 1994 and the expenses spent upon?
3. Whether the plaintiff proves that, he is entitled to claim the suit claim amount of Rs. 43,835/- from the defendants?
4. Whether the defendant proves that, plaintiff has obtained their signatures on blank papers and prepared the false documents?
5. What order or decree?
3. After considering the evidence and the material on record, the suit filed by the plaintiff was partly decreed with costs. It was ordered and decreed that defendants 1 to 3 shall jointly and severally liable to pay the amount of Rs. 35,000/- to the plaintiff towards the legal fees.
4. Aggrieved by the said judgment and decree passed by the Trial Court, the respondents filed R.A. No. 206 of 2003 before the First Appellate Court and the First Appellate Court after elaborately considering the case of the appellant as well as the respondents, allowed the appeal by setting aside the judgment and decree passed by the Trial Court dismissing the suit of the plaintiff against which the appellant has filed this appeal.
5. At the time of admitting the above appeal, this Court has framed the following substantial question of law which reads as under:
"Whether the finding of the First Appellate Court reversing the judgment and decree passed by the Trial Court and consequently dismissing the suit of the plaintiff towards recovery of lawyers fee is contrary to the material on record and for non-consideration of the reason assigned by the Trial Court in decreeing the suit of the plaintiff?"
6. Heard Sri Bahubali A. Danawade, learned Counsel appearing for the appellant and Smt. Hemalekha, learned Counsel for the respondents.
7. Learned Counsel for the appellant contended that the plaintiff is a practicing Advocate and an agreement was executed by the respondents with the plaintiff to avail the legal services to conduct the case of the respondents with respect to acquisition proceedings initiated by the Government to acquire their lands situated at Ankaligrama and as per the said agreement, the respondents were liable to pay a sum of Rs. 35,000/- towards the legal fee along with other expenses totally amounting to Rs. 43,835/-. The Trial Court having rightly considered the agreement which is marked as Ex. P. 3, has decreed the suit of the plaintiff. On the contrary, the Appellate Court erroneously set aside the judgment and decree passed by the Trial Court, totally discarding the evidence of P.W. 1 and not considering Ex. P. 3 in the right perspective. It is further contended that the appellant/plaintiff being a legal Practitioner is entitled to avail the legal fee which the respondents have agreed to pay and a well-considered order passed by the Trial Court cannot be disturbed by the First Appellate Court in a frivolous manner and prayed to interfere with the order passed by the First Appellate Court and to allow