2019 Supreme(Kar) 1950
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
K. N. PHANEENDRA, J.
Addu Padil @ Adrama S/o Abdul Kadher – Appellant
Versus
State Of Karnataka By Puttur Town Police – Respondent
CRL.P. No. 4465 of 2019
Decided On : 21-08-2019
Advocate Appeared:
For the Appellant :Sri. Lethif B, Advocate For Sri. Abdul Ansar P., Advocate
For the Respondent: Sri. Honnappa, Hcgp
Headnote:
Indian Penal Code - Sections 143, 147, 148, 341, 323, 324, 504, 307 and 149 - Jurisdiction of trial Court – Anticipatory bail - Whether injuries sustained by complainant were sufficient to cause death of a person and in turn it attracts Section 307 of IPC has to be established during course of full dressed trial - Allegations in brief as per the records are that one called complainant’s brother who was working in Dubai and abused his mother in filthy language hence called complainant to enquire with said about the said incident - Accordingly complainant warned to that effect - In that context when complainant was on way back to his house from Mosque after completing Namaz near Circle accused along with other persons by forming into an unlawful assembly with a common object way laid him and abused him in filthy language and manhandled him – Held, Learned HCGP has brought to the notice of this court that charge sheet has not been filed – However injured was admitted to the hospital and he was discharged - Further it is also made known to this court that said injured in the counter case has surrendered himself before court and enlarged on bail - Looking to above it is clear that there are case and counter case registered in same jurisdictional police station for similar offences - It appears some quarrel has taken place between two groups and persons of both groups have sustained injuries and both groups have filed a complaint and counter complaint and hence it appears a case and counter case are filed with same jurisdictional police – Moreover injured are discharged from the hospital and also there is no life threat to the complainant – Further whether injuries sustained by the complainant were sufficient to cause death of a person and in turn it attracts Section 307 of IPC has to be established during course of full dressed trial - It is also submitted that petitioner has been in jail for more than days – Therefore considering nature of allegations and existence of case and counter case between two groups in pursuance of a quarrel court of opinion that it is a fit case to enlarge petitioner on bail - Petition is allowed
ORDER :
1. Heard the learned counsel for the petitioner and the learned HCGP for the Respondent –State. Perused the records.
2. The petitioner is arraigned as Accused No.1 along with other six accused in Crime No. 47/2019 of Puttur Town Police, Puttur Taluk, D.K. registered for the offence punishable under Sections 143, 147, 148, 341, 323, 324, 504, 307 r/w 149 of IPC, which is now pending on the file of 5th Additional District and Sessions Judge at Puttur Taluk.
3. The allegations in brief as per the records are that, on 22.05.2019, one Rafeek (A7) called the complainant’s brother Safwan, who was working in Dubai and abused his mother in filthy language, hence Safwan called the complainant to enquire with the said Rafeek about the said incident. Accordingly the complainant warned Rafeek to that effect. In that context, when the complainant was on the way back to his house at 10.30. pm from the Mosque after completing Namaz, near Ambedkar Circle, Salmara, Chickmudnoor Village, Puttur Taluk, the accused along with other persons by forming into an unlawful assembly, with a common object, way laid him and abused him in filthy language and manhandled him. When the complainant asked the reason, Accused No.1 assaulted him with an iron rod on his head on temporal region and attempted to kill him and also threatened him with dire consequences of life, as a result of which, the complainant sustained severe injuries and was admitted to the hospital for treatment.
4. The learned counsel for the petitioner (A1) submitted that, earlier the victimcomplainant has assaulted one Mr. Ibrahim, who is said to be the relative of the petitioner (A1) and the Puttur Town Police had registered FIR against the Victim (Complainant herein) in Crime No. 46/2019, but by using the political influence, the victim (complainant herein) has managed to register a false case against the present petitioner (A1). Learned counsel reiterated the grounds urged in the petition that the Prosecution has mislead the Jurisdictional Court viz., 5th Addl. District and Sessions Court at Puttur by stating that, the petitioner (A1) is a rowdy sheeter and several cases have been registered against him and others. But no such other case is pending against the petitioner.
5. Learned HCGP has brought to the notice of this court that, the charge sheet has not been filed. However, the injured was admitted to the hospital and he was discharged. Further, it is also made known to this court that, the said injured in the counter case, has surrendered himself before the court and enlarged on bail.
6. Looking to the above, it is clear that there are case and counter case registered in the same jurisdictional police station for similar offences. It appears some quarrel has taken place between two groups and persons of both the groups have sustained injuries and both the groups have filed a complaint and counter complaint and hence, it appears a case and counter case are filed with the same jurisdictional police. Moreover, the injured are discharged from the hospital and also there is no life threat to the complainant. Further, whether the injuries sustained by the complainant were sufficient to cause death of a person and in turn it attracts Section 307 of IPC has to be established during the course of fulldressed trial. It is also submitted that the petitioner has been in jail for more than 70 days. Therefore, considering the nature of allegations and the existence of case and counter case between two groups in pursuance of a quarrel, am of the opinion that, it is a fit case to enlarge the petitioner (A1) on bail. Hence, the following:
ORDER
The petition is allowed. The petitioner (A1)Addu Padil @ Adrama shall be released on bail in connection with Crime No.47/2019 of Puttur Town Police Station, registered against him for the aforesaid offences, now pending on the file of 5th Additional District and Sessions Judge, Puttur Taluk, D.K., subject to the following conditions:
(i) The petitioner shall ex