1983 Supreme(Bom) 244
M.R.WAIKAR, V.V.VAZE
Ishwar Chinga Shetty & another – Appellant
Versus
Jivanji Bhulabhai Patel since deceased by his heirs & others – Respondent
JUDGMENT - M.R. WAIKAR, J.:---While hearing Appeal from Order No. 159 of 1980 and Civil Revision Application No. 628 of 1980, the learned Single Judge (S.K. Desai, J.) found that in these two matters, so also in several others pending in the City Civil Court, questions often arise about the scope of section 7 of the Maharashtra Ownership Flats (Regulation of the Promotion of Construction, Sale, Management and Transfer) Act, 1963 (hereinafter called ''the Act''). The learned Single Judge found that in view of one decision of the learned Single Judge of this Court (Nasik, J.) in Appeal from Order No. 299/1965 (Shri Kantilal v. Ganesh Sadashiv)1, decided on 24-10-1966, the jurisdiction of a Civil Court in these matters is almost ousted inasmuch as Naik, J., held that it is the jurisdiction of the Housing Commissioner which pervades and takes under its wide umbrella cases not only of changes in the construction of the tenements occupied by the purchasers, but cases of additional structures or enclosures to open area or of structures which were to be open on all sides. The learned Judge (Desai, J.), therefore, made a reference to a Division Bench with these observations :---
''I would b
Click Here to Read the rest of this document