SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

1989 Supreme(Bom) 193

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY
(NAGPUR BENCH)
Desai A.A., J.
Vasantrao Bapurao Chiddarwar .... Appellant.
Versus
Raghunathrao Anantrao Deshmukh another.... Respondents.
Second Appeal No. 298 of 1988, decided on 31-7-1989.
Advocates appeared :
V.R. Manohar, for appellant.
B.P. Jaiswal, for respondents.

Subject

Limitation - Malicious Prosecution

Act Referred

LIMITATION ACT : S.74

Headnote

Article 74 -Starting point of Limitation-Accused acquitted by trial Court on 28-5-1984-Appeal against acquittal dismissed On 12-12-84-Suit for malicious prosecution filed on 5-12-85-Held, starting point of limitation Is from date of acquittal at first Instance i.e. by trial Court and therefore suit having been filed after one year of acquittal Is time barred.

       The Legislature, while drafting Article 74, has with a definite significance, used the phraseology "prosecution is otherwise terminated" or "on acquittal". The terms are definitely of a distinct and different purport and connotation. The terms "the prosecution is otherwise terminated" does not take within it sweep, an acquittal in appeal. The Legislature has, therefore in addition inserted a term "on acquittal". Therefore, to construe that the prosecution culminates when acquittal attains finality in appeal or revision, would be derogatory to the object of Legislature. Moreover, "on acquittal" as referred to in Article 74 connotes acquittal at the first instance may be at the stage of an appeal. It does not whisper either final or confirmed acquittal.

       The starting point of limitation for the accused for a civil action to claim compensation for malicious prosecution would be from the date of acquittal as in the instant case 28-5-1984. The suit presented OD 5-12-1985 is clearly beyond the period of limitation under Article 74 of the Act. The learned Courts below have rightly dismissed the same.

       

JUDGMENT - DESAI A.A., J.:—This appeal by the original plaintiff against the judgment and decree dismissing the suit for compensation on account of malicious prosecution, as beyond the period of limitation raised a question as to what would be the terminal point of a prosecution for the purposes of Article 74 of the Limitation Act (the Act)?

2. The respondents 1 and 2 original defendants prosecuted the appellant plaintiff for an offence punishable under section 500 of the Indian Penal Code. The learned Magistrate by a judgment dated 28-5-1984 acquitted the plaintiff. The defendants appealed against the order of acquittal. This Court on 12-12-1984 dismissed the appeal.

The plaintiff thereupon on 5-12-1985, filed a civil suit against the defendants claiming damages of Rs. 25,000/- for prosecuting him maliciously. The learned trial Court observed that the cause of action for a claim arose on the date of acquittal i.e. 28-5-1984. The period for limitation under Article 74 of the Act, began to run from that date. The suit filed on 5-12-1985 is as such beyond one year, a period of limitation as prescribed. The learned trial Court, therefore, dismissed the suit. In appeal the same was confirmed.

3. In this second appeal, Shri Manohar, the learned Counsel for the original plaintiff contended that civil appeal as an undisputed proposition, is a continuation of suit proceedings. On the same analogy it is urged that an appeal against acquittal is a continuation of a criminal prosecution. The prosecution has, therefore, come to an end on 12-12-1984 when the this Court dismissed the appeal and confirmed the acquittal. The suit presented on 5-12-1985 as such is within limitation.

4. Mr. Manohar invited my attention to Article 74 of the Act which reads as thus:

"74 for compensation for One Year When the plaintiff

a malicious prosecution is acquitted or

the prosecution is

otherwise terminated."

He, in support of his submission, placed reliance on a decision of Full Bench of Madras High Court reported in A.I.R. 1938 Madras 249 (Soora Kulasekara Chetty v. Tholasinsam Chetty)1. The Full Bench has observed that "appeal or revision is a further step to secure conviction." Relying on this ratio, the Kerala High Court (1962 Kerala Law Times 143)2, Jammu and Kashmir High Court (1965 Kashmir Law Journal 64)3, and Oudh High Court (A.I.R. 1942 Oudh 489)4, have held that "prosecution proceeding terminates on dismissal of appeal or revision." It is, therefore, submitted that the starting point of limitation would be 12-12-1984 i.e. the date of dismissal of appeal against acquittal which has brought an end to the prosecution.

5. In view of the rulings cited supra, the learned Counsel reiterated that filing of an appeal is an attempt subsequent to acquittal to secure conviction of the accused. It therefore amounts to continuation of a prosecution initiated by presenting a complaint.

The Code of Criminal Procedure does not define the term "prosecution". In A.I.R. 1946 Nagpur 46 (Sk. Mehtab v. Balaji)5, relying on the dictionary meaning, it is observed that a prosecution means institution or carrying on of legal proceedings. The term "prosecution" as used in Article 74 of the Act does not appear to be of that wide import. As such it cannot be assigned with the meaning of an universal sense. The term is used according to me with a restricted and definite meaning. It conveys only prosection for a criminal offence. Every legal proceeding, therefore, cannot be equate or held analogous to prosecution.

6. Appeal (against the order of acquittal) is a remedy to the complainant, provided by the Code. Appeal questions the legality, propriety or otherwise correctness of the findings of acquittal. The higher judicial forum in appeal, scrutinises the material made available during the course of a trial as well the relevant provisions of law to approve or disapprove the findings of acquittal. However, the scope in such appeal is very limited. True it is, the Appel













1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top