1991 Supreme(Bom) 369
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY
(NAGPUR BENCH)
B.U. Wahane, J.
Dulichand s/o Puran Katre and another.... Applicants.
Versus
Smt. Sheela wd/o Lakhanlal Sahu and others.... Non-applicants.
Criminal Revision Application No. 204 of 1990, decided on 12-8-1991.
Advocates appeared :
G.P. Patel, for the applicants.
R.K. Borkar, for the non-applicants 1 to 4.
Headnote:Section 145-Proceedings under Section 145 initiated-Revision-Proceedings quashed as not maintainable-However still proceedings continued due to oversight and order passed-Revision against.
Held, when question of maintainability already decided by revisional court, that question cannot be reopened.
2. This application is directed against the order dated 17-9-1990, passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Gondia, in Criminal Revision No. 20 of 1985, Lakhanlal (through His L. Rs.) and others v. Dulichand and another, by which the order of learned Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Gondia, passed on 12-8-1982 in Miscelleneous Criminal Case No. 62 of 1980 was set aside.
3. The facts leading to the proceedings under section 145 of the Criminal Procedure Code and subsequent revisions in that matter, are as under :
The applicant No. 1 Dulichand executed an aggreement of sale on 13-4-1976 of Gat No. 470 area 0.94 acre and Gat No. 471 area 0.35 acre of the land situated in village Chutiya-tola, in favour of the deceased Lakhanlal and also put him in possession of the said land on the same day. Since then, Lakhanlal and thereafter his L. Rs. are in possession of the land and they had also sown the paddy crops in that land. It is the case of deceased Lakhanlal and his L. Rs. that the applicant Dulichand and others obstructed their possession some times in the year 1979 and, therefore, reports and counter-reports were lodged by both the parties to the Dawaniwada Police Station. As there was a breach of peace, the P.S.O., Dawaniwada, presented an Istagasa before the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Gondia under section 145 Cr.P.C. against the party No. 1 (deceased Lakhanlal) and Party No. 2 (Dulichand and others). On 21st day of October, 1980, the learned S.D.M., Gondia, passed the preliminary order under section 145 Cr.P.C., as under:
"WHEREAS reliable information has laid before me by the Police Station Officer Daoniwada for the following effect that ---
2. Gat No. Acres
470 0.94 decimals of mouza
471 0.35 decimals Chutiya
3. And whereas from the report of the Police Station Officer, Daoniwada, I am satisfied that a dispute is likely to be occasion a breach of peace. I, V.N. Gondhalekar, Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Gondiya hereby direct the parties to appear before me at Gondiya on and to put in written statement and such a documents or to adduce by putting in affidavit and evidence of such persons as they rely upon in respect of their respective claims as respects the facts of actual possession of the subject of dispute.
Party No. 1 Party No. 2
1. Lakhanlal w/o Laxminarayan Sahu. 1. Dulichand Puran Katre.
2. Gopaldas Ganpatlal Sahu, Gondiya. 2. Tanu Dulichand Katre, both r/o Lodhitola Dhutiya.
Details of property in dis