2015 Supreme(Bom) 2555
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY
THIPSAY ABHAY M., J.
Pradeep Kashiram Kadam - Appellant
Versus
K.A. Verghese and others - Respondents
Criminal Appeal No.116 of 2006
Decided on : 24-06-2015
Important Points
Subject
Criminal Law - Negotiable Instruments Act
Act Referred
Headnote
Negotiable Instruments Act - Property Transaction - Section 138 of N.I.Act - Section 138
Fact of the Case:
The appellant, as the complainant, prosecuted the respondents for an offence under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. The respondents were acquitted by the Magistrate, leading to the appellant's appeal.
Finding of the Court:
The court found that the respondents were not justified in withholding payment of the cheques issued for the balance consideration of a property transaction. The court held that the respondents' contention regarding the area of the plot of land being less was not supported by satisfactory evidence.
Issues: The main issue was whether the respondents were entitled to withhold payment of the cheques based on the alleged discrepancy in the area of the property.
Ratio Decidendi: The court emphasized that the cheques were issued for the balance consideration, and the respondents had already obtained the property on the assurance of paying the balance. The court also highlighted that the respondents' claim of the area being less was not established and that they should have approached a civil court for resolution.
Final Decision: The court set aside the order of acquittal, convicted the respondents under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, and sentenced them to pay a fine with a compensation amount to the appellant.
For the Appellant :Mr. Jitendra G. Damani, Advocate.
For the Respondent:Mr. P.M. Havnur a/w. Ms. Najafiya Shroff, Advocates, Deepak Thakre, A.P.P.
Thipsay Abhay M., J.
The appellant is the original complainant. He had prosecuted respondent nos.1, 2 and 3 herein, on the allegation that they had committed an offence punishable under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act ('N.I.Act' hereinafter). The Metropolitan Magistrate, 44th Court, Andheri, Mumbai, after holding a trial found the said respondents not guilty and passed an order of acquittal. Being aggrieved by the said order of acquittal, the appellant, after obtaining special leave of this court, has filed the present appeal, challenging the order of acquittal.
2. For the sake of convenience and clarity, the appellant shall hereinafter be referred to as 'the complainant' and the respondent nos.1, 2 and 3 as 'the accused'.
3. The case of the complainant, as made out from the complaint filed by him, was in brief, as follows :
That, by an Agreement for Sale dated 6th July 1994, the complainant had agreed to sell, transfer and convey all his rights, title and interest in respect of a certain immovable property to the accused persons, who were, at the material time, carrying on business of builders and developers in the name and style of M/s.Kalpana Constructions. That, the accused persons made the part payment towards the purchase of the said property and requested the complainant to complete the transaction by executing the Conveyance in favour of the accused persons. That, the complainant agreed to convey the property to the accused persons, but required payment of a sum of Rs.4,79,000/, which was the balance consideration, to be paid by the accused to the complainant by August 1996. The three accused executed, by way of security for payment, an Indemnity bond cum Declaration, on 2nd November 1996, and relying on the representations of the accused, the complainant conveyed the property to the accused persons by executing a Conveyance Deed, though the full amount of consideration had not been received by him from the accused. That, the accused did not make the payment of the balance amount within the stipulated time, but issued two cheques - one in the sum of Rs,4,79,000/and the other in the sum of Rs.1,00,000/, being the amount due and payable towards the balance of the purchase price and the interest on delayed payment, respectively. When the said cheques were deposited by the complainant, they were dishonoured with the banker's remark 'payment stopped by the drawer'. That, the complainant then made a demand in respect of the amount of the said cheques as contemplated under Section 138 of the N.I.Act. The accused persons received the demand notice, but failed to comply with the requirement and raised certain false and frivolous contentions. It is, thereafter, that the complainant filed a complaint in the court of the Magistrate, pursuant to which, the accused, as aforesaid, came to be prosecuted.
4. I have heard Mr.Jitendra G. Damani, the learned counsel for the appellants. I have heard Mr.P.M.Havnur, the learned counsel for the accused nos.1, 2 and 3. I have heard Mrs.M.R.Tidke, the learned APP for the State - Respondent no.4. With the assistance of the learned counsel, I have gone through the record and proceedings before the Magistrate. I have gone through the evidence and the impugned judgment carefully.
5. The complainant examined himself as a witness during the trial. He also examined one Girish Shah - an employee of the bank - through whom the statement of accounts of M/s.Kalpana Constructions was got produced. The accused no.1 examined himself as a defence witness and also examined one Jayantilal Shah as the second witness for the defence.
6. That, the cheques in question had been signed by the accused no.1 is not in dispute, and that, the cheques had been signed and issued by him on behalf of all the accused, is also not in dispute. That, they had been issued in favour of the complainant is also not in dispute. That, they had been issued towards the transaction of the purchase of the property in quest