2018 Supreme(Bom) 208
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY BENCH AT NAGPUR
V.M. DESHPANDE, J.
Vijay Naibrao Jadhav – Applicant
Versus
The State of Maharashtra – Respondent
Criminal Revision Application No. 137 of 2011
Decided On : 15-02-2018
Subject
Marriage Law - Special Marriage Act, 1954
Act Referred
INDIAN PENAL CODE : S.495, S.34, S.420, S.498(a), S.468, S.494, S.496, S.107
SPECIAL MARRIAGE ACT : S.13, S.24, S.3, S.4, S.5, S.6(2), S.7, S.9, S.11, S.12, S.13
Headnote
Special Marriage Act, 1954 - Section 13 - Indian Penal Code,1860 - Sections 498A, 420, 468, 494, 495, 496 r/w Section 34 - of conviction - register the marriage - Regular Criminal Case - Guilty for the offence- First Information Report - Prior to registration of marriage on first informant and applicant submitted their application in office of Marriage Registrar- At that time it was not disclosed to first informant by applicant or his parents accused Nos- 2 and 4 that applicants marriage is already performed with original accused No- 3 - After marriage on went to her matrimonial house as per First Information Report- Thereafter she was subjected to cruelty at hands of applicant for demanding money from her parents- Not only that he withdrew all amount which was deposited by parents of first informant in an account in her name in Post Office - It is further stated in First Information Report that first informant found a file containing some documents which contains a letter issued by Social Welfare Officer addressed to applicant and said was in respect of inter caste marriage of applicant- That gives suspicion in mind of first informant and she gave a telephonic call to her father- Accordingly her father PW-1 came at her matrimonial place at – Held, impugned order while he was functioning so- It was argued before Honble Apex Court in support of order of detention that as Lall Singh was holding a charge of current duties of office of District Magistrate and as no one else had been posted to that office he was in fact in law District Magistrate- Honble Apex Court allowed appeal and quashed detention order passed by Shri Lall Singh in paragraph No- 9 of said report in said judgment Honble Apex Court has ruled that even if an officer is exercising power of District Magistrate on there being a vacancy in office of District Magistrate he is still not District Magistrate until he is appointed a such under Section 10 (1) of Code- Honble Apex Court has also Ruled and relevant portion is extracted - another decision of Honble Apex Court in Harichand vs- Batala Eng- Co- Ltd- and Others AIR 1969 SC 483 is also on same line - Criminal Revision is allowed
For the Applicant : N.B. Kalwaghe.
For the Respondent: N.S. Rao.
V.M. DESHPANDE, J.
1. An interesting point is required to be answered for deciding the present Criminal Revision Application. The point is whether a Clerk in the office of the Sub-Registrar when was discharging his duties as in-charge Sub Registrar was empowered to discharge the duties as Marriage Officer and was empowered to register the marriage under the Special Marriage Act, 1954 and could issue the certificate as contemplated under Section 13 of the Special Marriage Act, 1954?
2. The present revision application arises out of judgment and order of conviction passed by learned Judicial Magistrate, First Class (2nd Court), Buldhana in Regular Criminal Case No. 257 of 2003 dated 5.3.2008 holding the applicant guilty for the offence punishable under Section 495 of the Indian Penal Code and was directed to suffer simple imprisonment for three years and to pay a fine of Rs. 2,000/- and in default, to suffer simple imprisonment for four months. The appeal against the said judgment and order of conviction before the Sessions Judge, Buldhana bearing Criminal Appeal No. 7 of 2008 was dismissed on 19th September 2011. Hence, this revision.
3. Few facts giving rise to the present revision can be enumerated herein-under:
(A) A charge-sheet was filed for the offence punishable under Sections 498A, 420, 468, 494, 495, 496 r/w Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code against the present applicant and three others. The applicant was shown as accused no. 1. Accused Nos. 2 and 4 were the parents of the applicant, whereas accused No. 3-Kavita was the wife of the present applicant. First Information Report Exh.77 was lodged by Seema Thete (PW-2) against all the accused persons.
(B) As per the report, marriage of first informant was solemnized with the applicant on 16.1.2003 in the office of the Marriage Registrar at Buldhana. Prior to the registration of the marriage on 10.12.2002, the first informant and the applicant submitted their application in the office of Marriage Registrar. At that time, it was not disclosed to Seema, the first informant by the applicant or his parents the accused Nos. 2 and 4 that the applicant's marriage is already performed with original accused No. 3 Kavita. After the marriage, on 16.1.2003 Seema went to her matrimonial house as per the First Information Report. Thereafter she was subjected to cruelty at the hands of the applicant for demanding money from her parents. Not only that, he withdrew all the amount which was deposited by the parents of the first informant in an account in her name in the Post Office. It is further stated in the First Information Report that on 26.3.2003 the first informant found a file containing some documents which contains a letter issued by Social Welfare Officer addressed to the applicant and the said was in respect of inter caste marriage of the applicant. That gives suspicion in the mind of the first informant and she gave a telephonic call to her father. Accordingly, her father PW-1 Pralhad Thete came at her matrimonial place at Jalna. The letter was shown to him. Thereafter, PW-1 Pralhad Thete made an inquiry and during inquiry it was revealed to him that present applicant on 21.6.2002 had performed the marriage with one Kavita (accused no. 3) at Aurangabad and the said was a registered marriage. A complaint therefore was lodged with Police Officer, Buldhana by Seema PW-2. In spite of knowing that the applicant was already married, he has performed his marriage with the first informant.
(C) A crime was registered with Police Station Buldhana vide Crime No. 72 of 2003 by Police Station Officer. The investigation in the crime was done by two investigating officers; Mahadev Darade (PW-6) and Avinash Gir (PW-7) (though they are wrongly shown as PW-5 only). Avinash Gir, PSI received the case diary of Crime No. 72 of 2003 for investigation. He recorded the statement of the first informant. He seized a pass book of first informant (Exh.75). He also recorded statement of relatives of t