PATNA HIGH COURT
Shashank Kr.Singh, J.
Dumraon Industries Private Limited
Versus
State Of Bihar
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 2323 of 1984 ;
Decided On : JANUARY 11, 1991
Money Claim - Contract Dispute - Companies Act, 1956 - Art. 14 of the Constitution - AIR 1968 SC 718, AIR 1983 SC 848, AIR 1990 SC 1031, 1990 (2) SCC 746
Fact of the Case:
The petitioner, a private limited company, supplied lanterns to the Government of Bihar as per an advertisement. The government delayed payment, causing financial strain on the petitioner.
Finding of the Court:
The court found that the government's delay in payment was unjustified and directed the government to pay the balance amount to the petitioner.
Issues: Dispute over payment for supplied goods, violation of Art. 14 of the Constitution, and the applicability of the Companies Act, 1956.
Ratio Decidendi: The government's acceptance of the lantern supply and partial payment bound them to honor the agreed price. The delay in payment caused financial strain on the petitioner, justifying the court's intervention.
Final Decision: The court directed the government to pay the balance amount to the petitioner within four months.
1. In the present case a preliminary objection has been raised by Mr. P. K. Sahi, learned counsel, appearing on behalf of the State, that as the claim of the petitioner is a money claim, he should be directed to file a suit and should not be allowed to invoke the extraordinary jurisdiction of this Hon ble Court. Present writ petition was filed on 2-5-1984 and admitted on 7-8-1984. The statutory period for filing the suit has already elapsed since long. This objection should have been taken at the time of admission itself. In view of the facts, as stated above, I am disposing of the aforesaid writ petition on merit, but, this shall be an exception and will not be treated as precedent in other similar cases.
2. That the petitioner No. 1 M/s Dumraon Industries Private Limited is a private limited company incorporated under the Companies Act, 1956, and is indulged in manufacturing lanterns and is a registered Small Scale Industry, with the Industry Department, of Bihar, Patna. That on 16-4-1983 an advertisement was published in the Indian Nation, a local newspaper, inviting tenders for supply of one Lakh lanterns for the Adult Education Programme of the Government of Bihar. The said advertisement is appended as Annexure-1 to this writ petition. That pursuant to the said tender the petitioner submitted his application on 29-4-1983 stating therein the price of lanterns to be supplied by them at the rate of Rs. 205.00 per dozen besides other taxes to be levied. A copy of the application dt. 29-4-1983, filed by the petitioner, is appended as Annexure-2 to the writ petition. That subsequently the petitioners application was accepted and after negotiation the price of Rs. 195.00 per dozen was fixed and was communicated to the petitioner vide letter No. 26/ P 6-56/82-2152 dt. 8-10-1983; written by the Director, Adult Education, Department of Education, Government of Bihar, respondent No. 3. The petitioner accepted the offer of respondent No. 3 by his letter dt. 10-10-1983 with a request that the last day of supply of the lanterns may be extended because of intervening Dasahara Holidays. By letter dt. 12-10-1983 the petitioner No. 1 was directed by respondent No. 3, the Director, Adult Education, to supply 31,500 lanterns at the rate of Rs. 195.00 per dozen in the various districts of the State of Bihar as per the details given by him in the aforesaid letter. A copy of the aforesaid letter is appended as Annexure-5 to this writ petition. The petitioners in pursuance of the direction, as contained in Annexure-5, supplied the lanterns to the various districts Head Quarters as directed and submitted his bill vide letter dt. 1-11-1983 and 7-11-1983 for Rs. 3,96,199.55 paise and Rs. 1,36,084.26 paise respectively totalling Rs. 5,32,283.81 paise. It has also been stated by the learned counsel for the petitioners that subsequently an agreement was signed between the representative of the petitioner No. 1 and respondent No. 3 as per the letter No. 2202 dt. 12-10-1983. A true copy of the agreement is appended as Annexure-7 to this writ petition. It has further been stated that after the supply was completed the petitioners approached respondent for making payment in time, explaining their difficulty in meeting their financial obligation, like payment of salary and liquidation of loans taken from the Bank and interest, etc. which they had to bear on that account. But the payments were not made. The petitioner company again wrote to respondent No. 3. vide letter dt. 3-1-1984 (Annexure-8) apprising him with the facts of the case and praying him for an early payment. Subsequently, on 1-2-1984. petitioner- company was paid an amount of Rupees 3,83,906.25 paise by cheque as part payment still a balance of Rs. 1,48,371.56 paise remained due as against the supply of lanterns. The petitioner company again wrote to the Director, Adult Education, respondent No. 3 praying that the balance payment should be made at an early date. It has also been state
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.