SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

1996 Supreme(Pat) 210

PATNA HIGH COURT
Prasun Kumar Deb and Surinder Sarup JJ.
Heldhar Kumar Singh
Versus
State Of Bihar
Criminal Appeal No. 24 of 1994 ;
Decided On : MARCH 29, 1996

Subject

Criminal Law - Narcotics

Act Referred

CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE : S.100, S.165
NARCOTIC DRUGS AND PSYCHOTROPIC SUBSTANCES ACT : S.42, S.50

Headnote

Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substance Act, 1985, Section 20, 50-conviction u/s 20 of the Act for possessing charas which was recovered and seized-propriety of- provisions of section 50 not-complied-seizure whether illegal-scope of section 50-it is mandatory and it is obligatory on the part of the officer concerned to inform the accused that he has a right to claim for search before a Gazetted Officer or Magistrate-search having been made by a police officer in presence of Gazetted Police Officer, provision of see 50 was complied-court below was satisfied that the Dy. Supt. of Police of C.B.I. has also been included within the designated officer-on merits at the time of search nothing could be found in possession of Haldhar Singh and as such confusion before C.B.I personnel have got no bearing by implicating him for conviction u/s 20-case could not be proved against him and he is to get acquittal on benefit of doubt-1993 Cr. L.J. 432, 1994 (3) SCC 299=1995 (1) BLJR 6, 1995 (2) East Cr. C. 21, 1993 (1) Crimes 865 ref.

       (Paras 7, 8, 10, 12, 16 & 17)

       

Judgment

Prasun Kumar Deb, J.

1. These two appeals are taken up together for disposal as both arise out of the same judgment of conviction and sentence dated 21st of January,1994 passed by shri S. K. Murari 6th Additional Judicial Commissioner, Ranchi in R;c. Case No.3 of 1992 (R)/t. R. No.133 of 1992 convicting the accused- appellants under Sec.20 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act,1985 (hereinafter to be referred to as the act) and sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for 12 years each and also to pay a fine of rs.1,00.000 (Rupees one lac) each and in default there, to undergo simple imprisonment (for a period of two years each ).

2. The case of the prosecution in brief is that the Central Bureau of Investigation (for short C. B. I.) on a secret information to the effect that the accused-appellant Rajendra Kumar was doing illegal business of selling narcotic drugs in his shop No. G/120 and residing in H. E. C. Quarter No. DT/1415 dhurwa, with his other associates. A raiding party was formed consisting of shri N. Jha, Deputy Superintendent of police (PW 5), Shri Sharwan Kumar, deputy Superintendent of Police (PW6)and other C. B. I. Bench, Ranchi, at instance of Superintendem of Police, c. B. I. Ranchi. Two independent witnesses, namely, Ratneshwar Sharma (PW 1), Head Security Guard and bhudeo Prasad Marandi (PW 4), security Guard of C. C. L. were procured and were associated with the raiding party. They went to J. P. Market, dhurwa on 16-2- 1992 at about 11 a. m. As per the plan, PW 6 would contact the accused appellant Rajendra Kumar a prospective buyer of narcotic drugs, namely, Hasis (Charas and other members of the party were instructed to be vigilant and keep a constant watch over the movement of PW6. It was further designed that in the event Hasis or other narcotic drugs could be found in the position of Rajendra Kumar, Then pw 6 would wave his hands wipe his head to give signals to the other members of the party. Accordingly, PW 6 visited shop No/g/120 of the accused appellant Rajendra Kumar in J. P. Market at Dhurwa. He posed himself to be the prospective purchaser of some general articles in the midst of conversation he could be in position to influence Rajendra Kumar and develop intimacy with him. PW 6 then posed himself to be buyer of narcotic drugs and informed the accused-appellant rajendra Kumar that he was in search of such drugs. Accused-appellant rajendra Kumar at the beginning had some hesitation but ultimately he was impressed by PW 6s behaviour and then he agreed to arrange Charas (Hasis) for him. After bargaining the price was fixed at Rs.20,000 per kilograms. It was further agreed that rajendra Kumar or his men would make delivery of Charas in an autorickshaw. It was agreed that PW 6 would pay the money at auto-rickshow at the time of delivery. For some time rajendra Kumar left his shop and reappeared with other accused who also discussed about the price and place of delivery of Charas. In pursuance of the agreement accused appellant Haldhar kumar Singh brought auto-rickshaw bearing registration No. AIN 9191 and kept the same near the shop of rajendra Kumar. Then Haldhar Kumar singh went away for bringing Hasis and came back after ten minutes with air bag. Haldhar Kumar Singh handed over the air-bag saying that it contained about 4 kilograms of Charas. PW 6 was satisfied by taking smell of the materials and all the tree then sat in the auto-rickshaw with the bag containing hasis Rajendra Kumar and Sharwan kumar (PW 6) sat on the back seat holding the air bag in his hand. Haldhar Kumar Singh sat along with the tempo driver on the front seat. When the auto-rickshaw was about to start, then as designed earlier. PW 6 gave signals thereupon the other members of the raiding pray surrounded the auto-rickshaw. Both the accused-appellant were challenged by N. Jha (PW 5), for being in possession of Charas. It is stated that both the accused persons admitted to be in possession ot Charas. PW
























1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top