1997 Supreme(Pat) 914
PATNA HIGH COURT
Gurusharan Sharma, J.
Meghlal Ram
Versus
Gyatri Devi Bagaria
Appeal from Original Decree No. 25 of 1994 ;
Decided On : DECEMBER 19, 1997
Important Points
Subject
Contract Law - SPECIFIC PERFORMANCE
Act Referred
Headnote
SPECIFIC PERFORMANCE OF CONTRACT - ORAL AGREEMENT FOR SALE - SUIT FOR - DISMISSAL OF - VALIDITY OF ORAL AGREEMENT - REQUIREMENTS - EVIDENCE - SUFFICIENCY - BURDEN OF PROOF.
Fact of the Case:
Plaintiff filed a suit for specific performance of an oral agreement for sale of the suit property. The defendants denied the existence of any such agreement. The trial court dismissed the suit, holding that the plaintiff had failed to prove the oral agreement.
Finding of the Court:
The High Court upheld the trial court's decision, holding that the plaintiff had failed to prove the oral agreement for sale. The court found that the plaintiff's evidence was inconsistent and contradictory, and that the witnesses who testified on his behalf were not credible.
Issues: 1. Whether the plaintiff had proved the existence of an oral agreement for sale of the suit property. 2. Whether the defendants were bound by the oral agreement.
Ratio Decidendi: 1. In order to prove an oral agreement for sale, the plaintiff must produce clear and convincing evidence of the agreement. 2. The evidence must show that the parties reached a meeting of the minds on all the essential terms of the agreement, including the price, the subject matter, and the time for performance. 3. The plaintiff must also show that the agreement was supported by consideration.
Final Decision: The High Court dismissed the plaintiff's appeal.
Gurusharan Sharma, J.
1. The plaintiff is the appellant. His suit for specific performance of contract in respect of the suit property, detailed in schedule of the plaint filed against the defendants has been dismissed by the impugned judgment and decree dated 11.3.1994, passed by the Third Subordinate Judge, Giridih, in Title Suit No. 1 of 1991/4 of 1993.
2. According to plaintiff, he was carrying on his business in the suit premises as tenant of the vendors of the defendants 1 to 4 since December 1966. By registered sale deed dated 28.7.1978, the defendants 1 to 4 purchased holding No. 463 including the suit premises for a consideration of Rs. 35000.00 . After purchase the defendants 1 to 4 had intention to sell the suit premises in order to earn profit.
3. The defendants 1 to 4 filed Eviction Suit No. 24 of 1979 under the provisions of the Bihar Buildings (Lease, Rent and Eviction) Control Act, 1982 for evicting the plaintiff from the suit premises, which was decreed on 22.8.1989, by the Subordinate Judge, Giridih. Against the said eviction decree, the plaintiff preferred Title Appeal No. 16 of 1989, before the District Judge, Giridih.
4. During the pendency of the eviction matter to avoid unnecessary litigation, the plaintiff requested the defendant No. 1 to sell the suit premises to him by giving priority and considering him to be a needy person. In presence of Ram Prasad Bagaria, the full brother of the defendant No. 1, the defendants 1 to 3 finally settled and orally agreed on 15.6.1990 to sell the suit premises to the plaintiff for a consideration of Rs. 2,00,000.00 . It happened in presence of respectable persons; namely, Deoki Nandan Ram, Satyendra Mohan Ram and Sudhansu Mohan Sinha and after receiving the entire consideration amount by September, 1990, they agreed to execute and register the sale deed therefor.
5. Several title in the month of July, 1990, the plaintiff approached to the defendants 1 to 3 with ready money, in presence of witnesses, for executing and registering the sale deed but they always avoided the plaintiffs request on one pretext or the other.
6. On the contrary, the defendants 2 and 3, at the instance of the defendant No. 1, on 31.7,1990 executed sale deed in favour of the defendant No. 5, at the instance of defendant No. 6, who was the husband of the defendant No. 5 and had knowledge of the oral agreement dated 15.6.1990 for a fictitious consideration of Rs. 40,000.00 only. In this way the defendants 1 to 3 practised fraud. On 31.7.1990 itself the plaintiff filed a.petition before the District Sub-Registrar requesting him not to register the sale deed, but he was asked to go to the civil Court. However the defendant No. 5 was impleaded as party respondent in the aforesaid Title Appeal No. 16 of 1989, which was a subsequently dismissed and Second Appeal in this Court by the tenant was also dismissed.
7. The plaintiff served a notice on the defendants to execute and register the sale deed, but it was not headed to.
8. Since there was a threat by the defendant No. 5, through the defendant No. 6 for evicting the plaintiff from the suit premises in the present suit a separate petition for grant of temporary injunction, restraining the defendants from executing the decree passed in Title Suit No. 24 of 1979 was filed. The plaintiff claimed to be always ready and willing to perform his part of the contract. He was admittedly in possession of the suit premises as a tenant and hence he had his first right to purchase the suit premises from the vendors of the defendant No. 5.
9. The defendants on the other hand denied any talk for sale of the suit premises between the plaintiff and the defendant No. 1. It was falsely alleged by the plaintiff that the defendant 1 to 3 orally agreed on 15.6.1990 to sell the suit premises to him for a price of Rs. 2,00,000.00 . The persons referred to in the plaint as witnesses were the henchmen of the plaintiff.
10. Since there was no agreement for sale of the su