SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Judicial Analysis Court Copy Headnote Facts Arguments Court observation
Listen Audio Icon Pause Audio Icon
judgment-img

2001 Supreme(Pat) 117

PATNA HIGH COURT
Sachchidanand Jha, J.
Mohd.Sirajuddin And Others
Versus
State Of Bihar
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 12828 of 2000 ; 13127 of 2000 ; 13128 of 2000 ; 13241 of 2000 ; 13251 of 2000 ; 13303 of 2000 ; 13306 of 2000 ; 1316 of 2000 ; 13364 of 2000 ; 13452 of 2000 ; 13474 of 2000 ; 13475 of 2000 ; 13570 of 2000 ; 13572 of 2000 ; 13661 of 2000 ; 13664 of 2000 ;
Decided On : FEBRUARY 08, 2001

Headnote:Service Law-Repatriation-A person holding any post on deputation has no right to hold that post and can at any time be repatriated to the parent post/Cadre/department. (Para 5)

       Service Law-Repatriation-Grounds for repatriation of Agriculture Officers from the post of B.D.O. to Agriculture department is that the post substantively held by them is not equivalent to the pay-scale of Deputy Collector‘s post-Pay scale admissible to the post is relevant consideration-Basis of their claim of equivalence at this stage that they are getting their pay in the same scale which is admissible to Deputy Collector by virtue of interim order of this court-The interim order cannot be interpreted as verdict of the Court on the point of entitlement-Even after their repatriation they will Continue to get their salary in the same pay scale in their parent post/cadre by virtue of the interim order till the final decision-No error in the impugned decision of repatriation-However, direction issued not to give effect to the order till the census operation and panchayat elections are over. (Paras 8 to 11)

       Bihar Panchayat Election Rules, 1995-Section 30-Agricultural Officers functioning as BDOs are competent to function as Returning Officer in the Panchayat election. (Para 13)

Judgment

Sachchidanand Jha, J.

1. The petitioners in each of these cases are aggrieved by their repatriation from the Rural Development Department, to be precise, from the post of Block Development Officer to the Agriculture Department, which is their parent department vide notification No. 9839 dated 27.11.2000 of the Rural Development Department. The grievance and the controversy being the same the cases have been heard together and are disposed of by this common order.

2. The facts of the case may be mentioned from the record of C.W.J.C. No. 13661/2000 which has been argued as the representative case. The case of the petitioners is that scale of the post of Agriculture Inspector/Agriculture Graduates was revised from Rs. 850-1,360 to Rs. 1,000-1,820 upon upgradation of the 1423 posts of Bihar Subordinate Agriculture Service and merger in the Bihar Agriculture Service Class II. They were allowed the replacement scale of Rs. 2,200-4,000 pursuant to the recommendation of the 5th Pay Revision Committee. The same scale was allowed to the Deputy Collectors in the Bihar Administrative Service. The scale was later reduced to Rs. 2,000-3,800. The Bihar Agriculture Graduates Service Association filed C.W.J.C. No. 767/91 challenging the decision of the State Government, which was dismissed. The Supreme Court on appeal set aside the order of the State Government in Civil Appeal No. 4602/92 on 12.5.1993 which, according to the petitioners, amounted to restoration of the scale of Rs. 2,200-4,000. The Supreme Court, however, had given liberty to the Government to issue show-cause notice to the employees concerned and then take fresh decision. On 16.9.1993, the Government issued an order allowing the scale of Rs. 2,200-4,000 but the same was recalled on 6.12.1993. The Association again moved this Court in C.W.J.C. No. 12050/93 in which on 16.12.1993 an interim order was passed directing that the petitioners shall meanwhile be paid the salary which were being paid to them before issuance of the impugned order until further orders. The writ petition was eventually dismissed by a learned Single Judge on 10.1.1997. In LPA No. 166/97 however while admitting the appeal against the said order, the Division Bench passed similar interim order. By virtue of the said interim orders the petitioners have been getting their pay in the then existing scale of Rs. 2,200-4,000 (now Rs. 6,500-10,500) till date. The same scale being admissible to the Deputy Collectors, the petitioners must be held to be equivalent in rank and status to the Deputy Collectors and therefore, the order of repatriation on the ground that they are not eligible for the appointment as Executive Officer under Sec. 58(1) of the Bihar Panchayat Raj Act, 1993 (in short Panchayat Act) is not legal.

It is also said that occasion for appointment of Executive Officer under the Panchayat Act would arise after the panchayat elections are held and Panchayat Samitis are constituted, since even the elections have not been held so far, the ground that the petitioners are not qualified for appointment as Executive Officer does hot exist. Alternatively, it is said that the process for holding elections under the Panchayat Act has already commenced and the repatriation of the petitioners at this stage is likely to jeopardize the election process. As a matter of fact, it is submitted, the very shifting in the garb of repatriation is for extraneous purposes-to bring pliable and convenient officers of choice on the post of Returning Officer to help the powers-that-be in the ensuing elections. Another ground on which the petitioners seek interference with the impugned order is that having been appointed as Charge Officer under Sec. 4(2) of the Census Act, 1940 read with Rule 3 of the Census Rules, 1990 vide notification No. 244 dated 20.4.2000 of the Revenue and Land Reforms Department, they cannot be transferred at a stage when the census operation has actually commenced in the form of enumeration of the

















Click Here to Read the rest of this document

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
Judicial Analysis

SupremeToday

SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
logo-black

An indispensable Tool for Legal Professionals, Endorsed by Various High Court and Judicial Officers

Please visit our Training & Support
Center or Contact Us for assistance

qr

Scan Me!

India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!

For Daily Legal Updates, Join us on :

whatsapp-icon Back to top