2006 Supreme(Pat) 151
PATNA HIGH COURT
Syed Md.Mahfooz Alam, J.
Badru Nisha @ Madhuri Devi
Versus
Yogendra Prasad Sinha
Appeal from Appellate Decree No. 603 of 1986 ;
Decided On : FEBRUARY 07, 2006
Important Points
Subject
Civil Law - Property Law
Act Referred
CONTRACT ACT : S.55
Headnote
Specific Performance - Contract for sale of immovable property - Mahadanama - 30th Baisakh 1382 Fasli corresponding to 25.6.1975 - Sec. 55 of the Indian Contract Act - Time not of essence of contract - Plaintiff not always ready and willing to perform her part of the contract
Fact of the Case:
Plaintiff filed suit for specific performance of contract for purchase of land and house. Defendant contended that plaintiff was not ready and willing to perform her part of the contract and time was the essence of the contract.
Finding of the Court:
First appellate court held that time was the essence of the contract and plaintiff was not always ready and willing to perform her part of the contract.
Issues: Whether time was the essence of the contract and whether plaintiff was always ready and willing to perform her part of the contract.
Ratio Decidendi: The court held that time was not of the essence of the contract based on sec. 55 of the Indian Contract Act. The court found that the plaintiff was not always ready and willing to perform her part of the contract.
Final Decision: The second appeal was dismissed, upholding the judgment and decree of the first appellate court.
Syed Md.Mahfooz Alam, J.
1. This second appeal has been preferred against the judgment and decree dated 26th May, 1986 passed by Ist Additional District Judge, Begusarai in S.J.T.A. No. 8 of 1981 / 14 of 1982 whereby the learned Additional District Judge has been pleased to set aside the judgment and decree dated 1.4.1981 and 14,4.1981, respectively, passed by Sri Nagendra Narayan Singh, 3rd Additional Subordinate Judge, Begusarai in Title Suit No. 100 of 1977 / 17 of 1981 decreeing the suit of the plaintiff for specific performance of the contract.
2. The brief facts of the case are that the plaintiff-appellant has brought a suit for specific performance of contract against the defendant-respondent claiming relief for issuing direction to the defendant-respondent to execute a sale deed in favour of the plaintiff-appellant in respect of 10 dhurs of land and the house standing thereof appertaining to Khesra No. 87 Khata No. 96 situated in Mohalla Lohianagar, Begusarai.
3. The case of the plaintiff-appellant is that in the year 1,974 the defendant-respondent approached and requested the plaintiff-appellant to purchase a portion of his land measuring 10 dhurs with the house standing thereon situated in Mohalla Lohianagar appertaining to Khata No. 96 Khesra No. 87 for a consideration of Rs. 7,000.00 as the defendant was in urgent need of money. The plaintiff accepted the proposal and agreed to purchase the land and the house standing thereon and accordingly, an agreement to sell (Mahadanama) was executed on 19.12.1974 after payment of Rs. 3500.00 towards part consideration money. The plaintiff-appellant agreed and promised to pay the rest amount (Rs. 3500) at the time of execution of the sale deed. The defendant-respondent promised to execute the sale deed by 30th Baisakh 1382 Fasli corresponding to 25.6.1975 after receiving the rest amount from the plaintiff. It was also stipulated that in case of failure to execute the sale deed, the defendant-respondent will return back the advance money forthwith. Further case is that after execution of the Mahadanama, the defendant delivered the possession of the land and the house to the plaintiff and since then the plaintiff was residing in the said house. Further case is that the plaintiff-appellant through her husband repeatedly requested the defendant-appellant to execute the sale deed but the defendant-respondent on one pretext or the other remained postponing the issue then the plaintiff-respondent sent a lawyers notice through Shri Brijnandan Rai, Advocate upon the defendant for execution of the sale deed but he refused to receive the same. From the action. conduct, manner and behaviour of the defendant, the plaintiff could understand that the defendant was not ready to execute the sale deed. It is further stated that the plaintiff was always ready and willing to pay rest of the consideration money and to get the sale deed executed but the defendant was never ready and willing to perform his part of the contract and so necessity of filing of the suit arose and the plaintiff-appellant filed the suit against the defendant for specific performance of the contract.
4. From perusal of the record it appears that the defendant appeared in the suit and by filing written statement, controverted the Claim of the plaintiff. The case of the defendant, in short, is that it is true that on 19.12.1983 a Mahadanama was executed by the defendant whereby the defendant agreed to sell the suit land along with the house standing thereon for a valuable consideration of Rs. 7000.00 and in token of Mahadanama the plaintiff also paid Rs. 3500.00 to the defendant and it was agreed that the rest amount will be paid at the time of execution of the Sale deed which was to be executed by 30th Baisakh 1382 Fasli corresponding to 25.6.1975. It is further stated that after execution of the Mahadanama the defendant was always ready and willing to execute the sale deed on receipt of the balance consideration mon