SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2010 Supreme(Pat) 2557

PATNA HIGH COURT
Mungeshwar Sahoo, J.
State Of Bihar
Versus
Ram Janam Singh
FIRST APPEAL No. 686 of 1995
Decided On : NOVEMBER 26, 2010

Important Points

The Plaintiff must prove malicious prosecution, absence of reasonable and probable cause, and damage to succeed in an action for damages for malicious prosecution.

Subject

Civil Law - Employment Law

Act Referred

CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE : S.80
INDIAN PENAL CODE : S.511, S.420, S.419

Headnote

malicious prosecution - Money Suit - Section 420, 419 and 511 IPC - Section 80 CPC - Specific Relief Act - Estoppel, Waiver and Acquiescence - Nagendra Kumar v. Etwari Sahu1 AIR 1958 Pat 329

Fact of the Case:

The Plaintiff, a teacher, filed a Money Suit claiming salary for a period when he was allegedly not paid, alleging malicious prosecution and seeking damages.

Finding of the Court:

The Court found in favor of the Plaintiff on the salary claim and awarded damages for malicious prosecution, but the Appellate Court set aside the finding of malicious prosecution and the awarded amount.

Issues: The issues included the maintainability of the suit, cause of action, bar under Section 80 CPC, limitation, Specific Relief Act, Estoppel, Waiver, Acquiescence, damages for malicious prosecution, salary entitlement, interest, and other reliefs.

Ratio Decidendi: The Plaintiff failed to prove malicious prosecution as there was reasonable and probable cause for the prosecution, and the report of the Block Education Extension Officer was not binding in the Criminal Court.

Final Decision: The appeal was allowed in part, and the judgment and decrees relating to the awarding of damages for malicious prosecution were set aside.

JUDGEMENT

Mungeshwar Sahoo, J.

1. The Appellants have filed this first appeal against the judgment and decree dated, 17th April, 1995 passed by Sri Raj Kishore Lal, the learned Subordinate Judge Ist, Gaya in Money Suit No. 25 of 1990 decreeing the Plaintiffs Money Suit in part.

2. The Plaintiff filed the aforesaid Money Suit claiming Rs. 1,79,222.50 alleging that he was appointed as Matric Trained Assistant Teacher by the District Superintendent of Education in the pay scale of Rs. 230-5-280-E.B.-6-340 and joined U.P. School, Adai, Konch, District Gaya on 25th July, 1973. He was getting his salary till 1974. In 1974, his enemies gave false information that the Plaintiffs real name is Bhagwan Singh and in fact, the Plaintiffs brother is Ram Janam Singh, who is actually appointed as Assistant Teacher but because he is invalid, the Plaintiff impersonating him as Ram Janam Singh and working as Assistant Teacher. Thereafter on 8th September, 1976, he was arrested from the office of District Superintendent of Education without asking any explanation or show cause. According to the Plaintiff, the arrest was illegal and unjustified.

3. The further case of the Plaintiff is that he was bailed out in the criminal case Under Section 420, 419 and 511 IPC chargesheet was also submitted in the said criminal case which was ultimately disposed of by Sri N.K. Verma, Judicial Magistrate 2nd class, Gaya on 16th January, 1983 in which the Plaintiff was acquitted on the ground that the prosecution did not substantiate and prove the charge. Thereafter, the Plaintiff was reinstated on 1st September, 1985 and since then, he is getting his salary. The Plaintiff further alleged that he was not getting his salary from the year 1974 till August 1985, so, he moved from pillar to post but nothing was paid to him and none of the authorities heard him. The Plaintiff further alleged that no departmental proceeding was ever initiated against him and the prosecution launched against him was a malicious prosecution causing damage to the Plaintiff and therefore, he is entitled to litigation cost amounting to Rs. 1,12,222 as per the account given in Schedule-II of the plaint. The Plaintiff also claimed interest at the rate of 12 per cent per annum before filing the suit. After serving notice Under Section 80 Code of Civil Procedure on the State of Bihar, the Plaintiff filed the suit valuing the same at Rs. 1,79,222.50.

4. The Appellants appeared and filed a contesting written statement alleging that the Plaintiff was absent from 1974 to August 1976 and therefore, he was not paid his salary. So far salary from the period of September 1976 till his joining is concerned, the State of Bihar did not dispute the fact, in other words, the State of Bihar admitted the claim of the Plaintiff. So far malicious prosecution is concerned, the case of the Defendant-Appellant is that, in fact, it was a bona fide prosecution launched against the Plaintiff according to law and after investigation, chargesheet was also submitted against the Plaintiff. It is also alleged that the Plaintiff was not even discharged at the time of framing charge and therefore, it cannot be said that it was a false and malicious prosecution. It is also stated that public filed a petition levelling the allegation against the Plaintiff that in fact, he is impersonating his brother.

5. On the basis of the aforesaid pleadings, the learned Court below framed the following issues:

(i) Is the suit as framed maintainable?

(ii) Has the Plaintiff got any cause of action for the suit?

(iii) Is the suit barred Under Section 80 CPC ?

(iv) Is the suit barred by the law of limitation?

(v) Is the suit barred under the provision of Specific Relief Act?

(vi) Is the suit barred by the principle of Estoppel, Waiver and Acquiescence?

(vii) Is the Plaintiff entitled for the damages sustained on account of malicious prosecution?

(viii) Is the Plaintiff entitled to get pay, D.A. and Bonus and increment as claimed?

(ix) Is the Pla
















1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top