PATNA HIGH COURT
R.P. MANDAL, J.
Nazir Hussain – Petitioner
Vs.
Dukhmochan Thakur, Durabadal – O.P.
Cr. Rev. No. 1839 of 1978
Decided On : 15.9.80
Is different by treatment of different aspect it cannot be an infringement of copy right-For
Contravention of the provisions it has also to be proved that the accused knowingly tried to copy the basic and necessary idea. (Para 30 & 31)
Code of Criminal Procedure, Sec. 439-Revisional Court will interfere where in a special circumstance the decision taken by the Courts below has aroused the conscience or has committed an error of law resulting in failure of justice. (Para 11)
1- iqufoZpkj ¼fjfHktu½ gsrq bl vkosnd dks izLrqr dj vkosnd us ;g izkFkZuk fd gS fd twfMfLk;y
eftLVªsV] iwf.kZ;k ds }kjk fnukad 14-11-1977 dks fn;s x;s fu.kZ; rFkk vkns’k] ftlds }kjk mUgksus vkosnd dks dksih jkbZV ,DV] 1857 ds /kkjk 63 ds vUnj nks”kh djkj dj ikap lkS :i;s tqekZuk nsus] ftlds u nsus ij ,d ekg dk lk/kkj.k dSn Hkqxrus dh ltk nh] ftldh vihy es f}rh; vij l= U;k;k/kh’k] iwf.kZ;k us fnukad ik¡p tqykbZ 1978 dh laiqf”V dh] gVk nh tk;A
2- fojks/kh i{k] nq[k ekspu Bkdqj] nqokZny us tks ys[kd vkSj dfVgkj ds vf/koDrk Hkh gS ^xkoa dh xksjh^ ,d miU;kl fy[kk ftlds dkih jkbV dks mUgksus fnukad 22-7-1961 dks djk;k fnukad 30-4-1963 dks rhu cts fnu dfVgkj ds ‘;kek Vkfdt es fQYe ^gs xaxk eb;k rksgs fi;jh p<boh^ dks tc os ns[kus x;s rks bl fQYe dks ns[kdj mUgs ;g izrhr gqvk fd ;g fQYe mudh d``fr ^xkao dh xksjh^ dk Hkjk udy ds flok vkSj dqN u Fkk] ftls mudh btktr ds cxSj rS;kj dj fy;k x;k Fkk vkSj bl rjg muds vf/kdkj ij vfrdze.k dj fn;k x;k FkkA ;|fi miU;kl dh dgkuh dks rksM+ ejksM+ dj fn;k x;k Fkk] fQj Hkh ;g fQYe ewyr% miU;kl dk udy gh FkhA ml fQYe ds dFkkdkj vkosnd Loa; ukftj gqlSu Fks vkSj mldk fuekZ.k fo’oukFk izlkn ‘kkgkoknh us fd;k FkkA
3- vfHk;ksx i= es fy[kk x;k gS fd miU;kl ^xkao dh xksjh^ dk ewy Hkko gS jk/kk vkSj d`”.k dh vej izse xkFkkA uk;d mlh rjg ca’kh ctkus es izoh.k gS] tSlk Jhd`”.k FksA ca’kh ls fudyh /kqu ij ukjh lHkh eqX/k gks tkrs FksA izfrfnu tc lqcg dh /ofu xwat mBrh rks ;qofr;k vkdqy O;kdqy gks mBrhA ijUrq dFkk uk;d nhid dh vk[ksa pkanuh dks gh <w¡<+rh jgrh] ftls vutkus es gh fny ns fn;k FkkA ijUrq :f<okfnrk] m¡puhp dk HksnHkko rFkk tkfr;rk ds dkj.k mu nksuks dk fookg gks ugh ldkA reke miU;kl] tSlk vfHk;ksx i= es fy[kk x;k gS] bUgh dqfopkjks ij fd;s x;s vk?kkrks ls vksr izksr gSA miU;kl] ds izFke Hkkx es mfYyf[kr blh dgkuh dks fQYe dk vk/kkj cuk;k x;k gS vkSj pwafd miU;kl dk nwljk Hkkx ugh fy[kk tk ldk gS blfy, fQYe es fuekZrkvks es fQYe es e/;kUrj ds ckn dqN vLoHkkfod ?kVukvks dks tksM+dj fQYe dks iwjkdj fn;k gSA ijUrq okLrfodrk ;g gS fd reke fQYe mi;qDr miU;kl dk udy gh gSA
4- vfHk;ksx i= es fy[kk x;k gS fd fQYe dh ‘kq:vkr xaxk fdukjs fLFkr n`”;ks dks fn[kkrs gq, xhr^^^^^^^^^gs xaxk eb;k rksgs fi;jks p<+boh ls dh xbZ gS vkSj miU;kl ds 32 os i`”B ij cgqr lkjs yksxks dk iwlh iwf.kZek ds volj ij xaxk Luku djus dk mYys[k gSA
5- fQYe dh ukf;dk] ;|fi mlds firk us ckgj tkus dks euk fd;k Fkk] pqipqi viuh lgsfy;ks ds lkFk unh es Luku djus pyh tkrh gS] tgka os lHkh ikuh mNkyrs gq, vB[ksfy;ka djrh fn[kk;h x;h gS vkSj miU;kl ds i`”B 33] 34] 35 rFkk 36 ij ,slk gh o.kZu fd;k x;k gSA
6- fQYe es ,d ukpus okyh yM+dh dks ukprs vkSj xkrs fn[kk;k x;k gS] tks miU;kl ds i`”B 50 ij tV vkSj tkfVu dh ukp rFkk i`”B 64 ij fy[ks x;s d`”.k yhyk n`’; ds leku gh gSA
7- fQYe ds uk;d dh mlds fe=x.k esyk ys tkrs gS tks fd miU;kl ds i`”B 53 dk udy gSA fQYe es dksbZ lg&ukfdk dk pfj= ukf;dk es gh fufgr dj fn;k x;k gSA tks fd iqLrd i<+us ls >yd tk;xkA taxy es gh uk;d vkSj ukf;dk dk feyu] cklqjh oknu ds }kjk ukf;dk dk eueksgus
rFkk esys ls okil ykSVkus dky dk Hk;kud n`f”V vkSj mlh dky es mu nksuks dk vpkud feyu miU;kl dk jaxHkjk udy gh gSA ;s lHkh n`’; miU;kl ds i`”Vks 66]67]128]129]130 ,oa 131 ds udy gSA
8- fQYe dk ,d n`’; gS ftles uk;d ds pfj= dks ysdj ,d iapk;rh gqbZ gS vkSj miU;kl ds i`”V 137]138 ,oa 139 ij uk;d dks ltk nh tkrh gS vkSj fQYe es ukf;dk ds ekrk firk mls tcjnLrh C;kg dj nsus ds ckjs es ckrphr djus gS] tSlk dh miU;kl ds i`”V 147 ,oa 148 es gSA fQYe es ukf;dk dh ekrk uk;d ds firk ds ikl tkrh gS vkSj miU;kl es ukf;dk ds firk uk;d ds firk ds ikl tkrs gSA miU;kl es of.kZr n`’; ds rqjUr gh fQYe es Hkh ukf;dk dh fookg ds volj ij mldh lgsfy;k mlds ikl tkrh gSA tSlk fd miU;kl es gS mlh rjg fQYe es ukf;dk dh ‘kknh fdlh nqljs O;fDr ls gh tkrh gS vkSj miU;kl es ukf;dk viuh llqjky ikydh ij tkrh gS ijUrq mlds ckn fQYe es dgkuh dks dqN rksM+ ejksM+ fn;k x;k gSA
9- bUgh lc vk/kkjks ij ;g vkjksi yxk;k x;k gS fd vkosnd rFkk fo’oukFk izlkn us oknh nq[kekspu Bkdqj ds vf/kdkjh ij mi;qDr izdkj ls vfrdze.k fd;k gS] tks naMuh; gSA
10- vfHk;kstu us viu
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.