1979 Supreme(Pat) 242
PATNA HIGH COURT
S. SARWAR ALI & S.K. CHOUDHURI, JJ.
Nag Narain Singh - Petitioner
Vs.
The State of Bihar & ors - Respondent
C.W.J.C. No. 1561 of 1979
Decided on : 7.11.1979
For the Petitioner: M/S Prabha Shankar Mishra & Ganesh Prasad Singh.
For the State : M/s Tarkeshwar Dayal. G.P. II, & D.P. Chaudhary.
Headnote:Bihar Education Code, Art. 118-Bihar High School (Control & Regulation of Administration) Act, 1960-Sec. 8-Provisions of Education Code which were published in the Gazette of 23.3.1955 and which were not in consistent with any Provision of the Act, received Statutory recognition in matters connected with the Act-Other provisions of the Code not Statutory-Matters enumerated in Art. 118 of the Code can be amended or modified by another Government order. (Paras 3 & 4)
In this writ application the petitioner prays for quashing of Annexure 2' to 4' Annexure 2' is the decision of the State Government dated 4.5.1977 recategorising the different cadres or branches of the Subordinate Education Service, Annexure 3' is order of transfer in relation to a number of officers including the petitioner issued by the Deputy Director (Primary Education), Bihar annexure 4' is the order issued by the Deputy Inspector of Schools, Siwan dated 5.5.1979 directing the petitioner to hand over charge to respondent no. 8. it may be stated that by virtue of the orders of the transfer aforesaid the petitioner, who was in the inspecting branch of the service has been transferred as Lecturer in Hansdiha Primary Teachers Training College in the district of Santhal Parganas.
2. The case of the petitioner is that formerly there were three cadres in the Subordinate Education Service, namely. (1) Inspection (male) Branch, (2) Teaching (male) Branch and (3) Inspection and Teaching (Female) Branch. This was done under Government order no. 5489 dated 25.11.1955, which it is said, is incorporated in Article 118 of the Bihar Education Code. The petitioner was appointed as Sub-Inspector of Schools in the Inspecting Cadre on 31.5.1958 and confirmed by order dated 21.2.1969. The post of Sub-Inspector of Schools was later designated as Block Education Extension officer. At the time of the impugned order of transfer the petitioner was working as Block Education Extension Officer, in the district of Siwan. A Government Order dated 4.5.1977 was issued by which different cadres of the Subordinate Education Service were recategorised and instead of three cadres four cadres were brought into existence. They are (l) Elementary Branch (male). (2) Teaching Branch (male). (3) Elementary Branch (female) and (4) Youth Branch (mixed). In the first category of the Elementary Branch (Male), were included 14 posts including those of the Headmasters of the Government Basic Schools. Lecturers and Coordinators of Elementary Teachers Training Colleges, Sub-Inspectors of Schools Block Education Extention Officers, Deputy Inspectors of Schools, Deputy Superintendents of Education, Assistant Area Officers and others. In Teaching Branch (Male), were included teachers of Government Boys High Schools, non Gazetted teachers of Teachers Training Colleges and non Gazetted teachers and officers of the State Research and Training Board, Patna. The contention of the petitioner is that as a result of the issue of this Annexure Inspecting Branch has been abolished and in its place Elementary Branch (Male) has been sought to be created in which officers belonging to the Inspecting Branch such as the petitioner, as well as Headmasters of Government Basic Schools and Lecturers and Coordinators of Elementary Teachers Training Colleges have been included. This makes it possible to transfer the personnel belonging to the Inspecting Branch to the teaching posts as included in the first category.
3. The main challenge in this writ application is to tile issue of Annexure 2', It is contended with reference to Article 118 of the Education code that there was in existence three separate cadres or Sub-Cadres and that the same could not be changed, or amalgamated by an executive order issued by the State Government. The result of this change it was pointed out was that the petitioner who was in the Inspecting Branch could be put under the supervision of a person who was junior to the petitioner and continued on an Inspecting post in the redefined cadre. The challenge to the validity of Annexure 2' cannot be accepted. The Education Code has no statutory force except in relation to the previsions which have received a statutory recognition by virtue of section 8 of the Bihar High Schools (Control and Regulation of Administration) Act, 1960 (Bihar Act, XIII of 1960). Bihar Act, XIII of 1960 was promulgated to control and regulate administration of High Schools other than schoo