HIGH COURT OF PATNA
B.M. LAL & S.K. SINGH, JJ.
Md. Arif Khan – Petitioner
Versus
Bihar Public Service Commission & other – Respondents
CWJC No. 9475 of 1998
Decided on: 9.11.1998
Postal Department - Application for Drugs Inspector's examination - Prima facie case for admission and direction to make proper arrangement for appearance
Fact of the Case:
The petitioner applied for the post of Drugs Inspector through registered post before the deadline, but the application was rejected by the Public Service Commission for reaching after the deadline.
Finding of the Court:
The court found that the petitioner had a prima facie case for admission and directed the Public Service Commission to make proper arrangement for the petitioner's appearance in the examination.
Issues: The issue was whether the rejection of the petitioner's application for the Drugs Inspector's examination was justified.
Ratio Decidendi: The court held that since the application forms were invited through the postal department, any mistake by the postal department was attributable to the Public Service Commission, and the petitioner could not be blamed for it.
Final Decision: The court admitted the petition for hearing, issued notices to the respondents, and directed the Bihar Public Service Commission to make proper arrangement for the petitioner to appear in the examination, with the result subject to the final decision of the writ petition.
1. Heard Shri Jagdish Pandey for the petitioner and Shri K.K. Mandal and Shri Anil Kumar Tiwary for the respondents on the question of admission.
2. This petition is for directing the respondents to make proper arrangement for petitioner's appearance in the Drugs Inspector's examination scheduled to be held on 11.11.1998.
3. It is contended that as per terms and conditions of the advertisement, annexure 1 to this writ petition, applications were invited for the post of Drugs Inspectors through registered post and the last date for receipt of the application form was 10.11.1997. Accordingly, the petitioner had despatched his application form through registered post on 5.11.1997 but the Public Service Commission has rejected his application form on the ground that the application form sent by him on 5.11.1997 could not reach the office of the Public Service Commission on or before 10.11.1997 but has reached thereafter.
4. According to the terms and conditions of the advertisement the application forms were invited through postal department. Thus, the postal department has acted as an agent of the Public Service Commission and if the agent commits a mistake, indeed it is attributable to the Public Service Commission for which the petitioner cannot be blamed. Therefore, in our opinion arguable prima facie case is made out for admission as well as directing the Public Service Commission to make proper arrangement for petitioner's appearance in the ensuing examination of Drugs Inspector commencing from 11.11.1998.
5. The petition is, therefore, admitted for hearing the parties.
6. Let notices be issued to the respondents for a date to be fixed by the office.
7. Process fee, etc. be filed within seven days, failing which, this writ petition shall stand dismissed without making further reference to this Court.
8. Meanwhile, we direct the Bihar Public Service Commission to make proper arrangement and to allow the petitioner to appear in the ensuing examination of Drugs Inspector commencing from 11.11.1998. However, the result of the examination shall be subject to final decision of this writ petition.
9. Let certified copy of this order be supplied to learned counsel appearing for the parties on usual charges during course of the day.
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.