Heard learned counsel for the petitioner and counsel for the State as also counsel for the private respondent no.4.

2. In this case, the petitioner is seeking relief of appointment on compassionate ground. Subash Ram and the present petitioner Jawahar Lal Ram are sons of Late Chabinath Prasad. The present petitioner is the son from the second wife whereas Subash Ram is the son from the first wife. Earlier, it appears that Subash Ram has applied for compassionate appointment and, in the event of non-selection, he approached to the Lokayukt and the Lokayukt started enquiry and asked the State authorities to find out reasons for non selection on compassionate ground and an enquiry, with regard to educational certificate, was conducted. The then Headmaster was asked to verify the certificate issued from his institution. On perusal of the same, Sri Budhan Ram, who was the then Headmaster of the school, refused to recognize the certificate filed by Subash Ram and declared the same to be fabricated and forged certificate. On the basis of the enquiry, the District Education Officer, Bhojpur, Arah vide letter dated 19.1.2008 submitted a report to the District Magistrate, Bhojpur, A