( 1 ) THIS appeal arises out of the judgment of Basak, J. discharging the Rule Nisi obtained by the appellant Sm. Mayabati Halder on her application under Article 226 of the Constitution.

( 2 ) RANJIT Kumar Nandy, the husband of the respondent No. 2 Sm. Aparna Nandy, was a tenant of two rooms of premises No. 51/b, Mohim Halder Street, Calcutta. On February 10, 1969, the said Ranjit Kumar Nandy filed a petition of complaint under Section 31 of the West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act, 1956 before the Rent Controller, Calcutta alleging inter alia that his landlady, the said Sm. Mayabati Halder had wilfully stopped the supply of tap water to the said premises by cutting and rendering unserviceable the water connection and had totally blocked and dosed the drain used for the purpose of outflow of garbage water from inside the said premises. The said application was registered as R. C. Case No. 71 of 1969. The appellant entered appearance in the proceeding started on the said petition of complaint and contested the tame by a petition of objection. As many at three witnesses were examined in the proceeding. Before the hearing was concluded, the complainant Ranjit Kumar Nandy