High Court Of Calcutta
Sankar Bhattacharyya, J. N. More
NARESH KUMAR SHARMA - Appellant
Versus
STATE - Respondent
Criminal Appeal 433 Of 1981
Decided On : 06/08/1987
CRIMINAL APPEAL - MURDER - VOLUNTARY CONFESSION - JUDICIAL CONFESSION RECORDED UNDER SECTION 164 CR. P. C. - TEST OF ADMISSIBILITY - INTERPRETATION OF SECTION 24 OF THE EVIDENCE ACT - RELIABILITY OF CONFESSION - CORROBORATION BY INDEPENDENT EVIDENCE - COMMON INTENTION - CONVICTION UNDER SECTIONS 302/34 AND 394/34, INDIAN PENAL CODE - UPHELD.
Fact of the Case:
The appellant, Naresh Kumar Sharma, along with three others, was convicted by a trial court for the murder of a taxi driver, Subhalal Das, in furtherance of their common intention. The appellant was also convicted for robbery of the taxi and the property of the deceased. The appellant challenged the conviction and sentence in an appeal.
Finding of the Court:
The court held that the judicial confession of the appellant, recorded under section 164 Cr. P. C., was voluntary and reliable. The confession was corroborated by independent evidence, including the seizure of the taxi, the driving license of the deceased, and the paint and brush used to alter the taxi's number plate. The court found that the appellant actively participated in the strangulation of the deceased and shared the common intention with other accused persons to kill him. The court also found that the appellant was involved in the robbery of the taxi and the property of the deceased.
Issues: 1. Whether the judicial confession of the appellant was voluntary and reliable? 2. Whether the confession was corroborated by independent evidence? 3. Whether the appellant shared the common intention with other accused persons to kill the deceased? 4. Whether the appellant was involved in the robbery of the taxi and the property of the deceased?
Ratio Decidendi: 1. The court held that a confession, if voluntarily and truthfully made, is an efficacious proof of guilt. The court applied the double test laid down by the Supreme Court in Shankaria v. State of Rajasthan to determine the admissibility and reliability of the confession. The court found that the confession was not caused by any inducement, threat, or promise and that it appeared to be a probable catalogue of events that fit in with the rest of the evidence. 2. The court held that the confession was corroborated by independent evidence, including the seizure of the taxi, the driving license of the deceased, and the paint and brush used to alter the taxi's number plate. The court found that this evidence supported the appellant's confession in several material particulars. 3. The court held that the appellant actively participated in the strangulation of the deceased and shared the common intention with other accused persons to kill him. The court found that the appellant's conduct showed that he shared the common intention with other accused persons to kill the deceased. 4. The court held that the appellant was involved in the robbery of the taxi and the property of the deceased. The court found that the evidence clearly showed that the appellant along with others committed robbery of the taxi and papers relating to the taxi.
Final Decision: The court dismissed the appeal and affirmed the order of conviction and sentence.
( 1 ) APPELLANT Naresh Kumar Sharma and three others were convicted by a learned Additional Session Judge. 24-Parganas under sections 302/34, Indian Penal Code for committing murder of Subhala Das, a taxi driver, in furtherance of their common intention on 29th June, 1979 at Gopalpur within P. S. Airport and sentenced to imprisonment for life. The appellant was also convicted along with others under sections 394/34, Indian Penal Code for committing robbery in respect of taxi No. WST 2706 and the property of the deceased at Shekharpur within P. S. Rajarhat in furtherance of the common intention of them all and sentenced to rigorous imprisonment for 7 years. The appellant seeks to assail the said order of conviction and sentence in this appeal.
( 2 ) SHORN of unnecessary details, the prosecution case is as under:taxi No. WBT 2706 is owned by P. W. 7 Smt. Ruby Bose on whose behalf husband Ranjit Bose (P. W. 5) used to look after the taxi business. Subhalal deceased was the driver of the taxi at the relevant time. The taxi used to be kept in a garage at 12/b, Cames street within P. S. Park Street. The driver used to take out the taxi from the garage in the morning by signing in the Garage Register and return the taxi to the garage at the end of the day. In course of this usual practice, the driver took out the taxi from the garage on the morning of 29. 6. 79 and at that time P. W. 5 Ranjit Bose was with the driver. Four, persons boarded the taxi near the Ujjala Cinema. P. W. 5 went in the taxi upto Hasra Road. Thereafter, the driver drove away the taxi with the four passengers. On that night the driver did not return to the garage with the taxi. On the following morning P. W. 5 Ranjit Bose came to the garage but could not find the taxi or the driver there.- He lodged a missing information at Park Street Police Station. On 29. 6. 79 at about 8. 30 p. m. accused Basudeb and 3 others including appellant Naresh were seen going to Shekharpur in the said taxi No. WBT 2706. Two of the companions of Basudeb including the appellant left Shekharpur while Basudeb and Asit remained at Shekharpur with the taxi. Basudeb was found changing the number of the taxi by altering the first digit in the rear number plate. The first digit was found to have been altered to 8 in place of 2. P. W. 10 Sagar Roy, a resident of village Shekharpur found Basudeb changing the number of the rear number plate of the taxi. Out of suspicion he reported the matter to the village resistance party and P. W. 21 constable Haripada Sur and another constable of Rajarhat Police Station who had come to the village on night patrol duty. The two constables then challenged accused Basudeb and Asit who could not offer satisfactory explanation for their possession of the taxi with the number in the rear number plate altered. The constables then took these two accused persons along with the taxi to Rajarhat Police Station. An attached case with wearing apparel two tin containers with black and white paint, one brush and a signed photograph of Basudeb and some papers relating to the taxi were recovered from the taxi. In the mean time, on the morning of 30. 6. 79 P. W. 20 Arun. Baidya found the driving licence of the deceased lying on the road and he deposited the same at Rajarhat Police Station. P. W. 4 found the dead body of the deceased by the side of the railway line and informed the Airport Police Station over telephone about the discovery of the dead body. On receipt of the telephonic message P. W. 30 S. I. Ranjit Narayan Majunder went to Gopalpur with force and found a dead body lying in a bush of Kalmi plant to the north of the old railway line with a napkin tied round the neck. One Biswanath Mandal, since deceased, made over a written complaint to him, which was forwarded to tie police station for starting a case. On the basis of the written complaint the f formal First Information Report was drawn up at Airport Police Station and a case under section 302,
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.